Chapter 9 - Cognitive Development in Early Childhood Flashcards
Piaget’s Theory: The Preoperational Stage
2 – 7 years old
Most obvious change in the extordinary increases in representational or symbolic activity.
Piaget acknowledged that language is our most flexible means of mental representation. By detaching thought from action it permits far more efficient thinking. But Piaget did not regard language as the primary ingredient in early childhood cognitive change. Instead he believed it was advances in Mental Representation that allowed for internal images of experiences that children label as words.
Piaget tended to focus in limitations on thought, rather than abilities, during the preoperational period
Make believe play
An example of mental representation
Piaget believed that children practice and strengthen newly acquired representational schemes.
As young as two they understand play is a representational activity and this strengthens over early childhood.
Development of Make believe play
Mental representation is required
• Play detaches from the real-life conditions associated with it. – Toddlers only use realistic objects, imitates adult’s actions, and are not yet flexible. After age 2 children pretend with less realistic objects, increasing in flexibility until they can imagine objects and situations without support from the real world
• Play becomes less self centered. – at first make believe play is directed towards self. Later towards objects (doll).
• Play includes more complex combinations of schemes. -
Benefits of make believe
Piagets views are too limited.
Play not only reflects but contributes too cognitive and social skills.
Strengthens mental abilities like: sustained attention, memory, logic, reasoning, language, literacy, imagination, creativity, the ability to reflect on one’s own thinking, regulate one’s own emotions and behavior, and to take others perspective.
Imaginary companions
Imaginary friends
Human like qualities
Sociodramatic play
Make believe with others
Underway by end of second year and increases rapidly in complexity during early childhood
- Last longer, shows more involvement, and is more cooperative than other peer shared activities like drawing
- Children who do this more are seen as more socially competent
Enhancing make believe play in early childhood
- Provide space and materials for play
- Encourage but don’t control play
- Offer realistic and unclear objects for play
- Ensure many rich real world experiences to inspire positive make believe play
- Help children solve social conflicts constructively
Enhancing make believe play in early childhood
- Provide space and materials for play
- Encourage but don’t control play
- Offer realistic and unclear objects for play
- Ensure many rich real world experiences to inspire positive make believe play
- Help children solve social conflicts constructively
Dual representation
Viewing a symbol object as both and object in its own right and a symbol
- Exposure to divers symbols like books, pictures, drawings, make believe, and maps can help
Advances in Mental Representation
Mental representations allow us to
• Think about objects or events not present
• Think about abstract concepts
• Think about past or future
Limitations of Preoperational Thought
Piaget tended to focus in limitations on thought, rather than abilities, during the preoperational period
- Egocentrism
Animism
- Centration
- Irreversibility
- Problems with the Appearance-Reality Distinction
- Hierarchical classification
Egocentrism
Egocentrism is the failure to distinguish the symbolic viewpoints of others from one’s own
Most fundamental deficit of preoperational thinking.
Prevents them from accommodating.
Animism
The belief that an inanimate object has lifelike qualities such as thoughts, wishes, feelings and intentions.
Piaget thought that this was because of egocentrism
conservation
The idea that certain physical characteristics of objects remain the same even when their outward appearance changes.
Errors are caused by
- centration
- The Perceptual appearance
- Ignoring dynamic transformation (poring of water)
- irreversibility
Centration
Focusing on one aspect of a situation, neglecting other important features
Irreversibility
The inability to mental go back through a series of steps in a problem and then reverse direction, returning to the starting point.
Problems with the Appearance-Reality Distinction
Distinguishing between two identities, a real one and an apparent one.
Appearance from reality
Understanding that the contents of mind represent rather than reproduce the contents of the world involves understanding that thoughts of a thing may have different characteristics than the thing itself.
From this it follows that no entity in the world has a unique representation in the mind — individuals may differ in their representations of objects or events in the world, and a single individual may possess multiple representations of particular objects or events, either simultaneously or in succession.
3-year-olds appear to lack the ability to maintain two or more representations of particular objects or events. This is revealed by responses to questions concerning whether the appearance and true nature of objects or events may diverge.
Cat or dog test
Hierarchical classification
Hierarchical classification is the organization of objects into classes and subclasses on the basis of similarities and differences Preoperational children tend to fail class inclusion tasks because they center on the overriding feature.
Follow-Up Research on Preoperational Thought
- Preschoolers can pass simplified versions of the 3-mountains task
- Preschoolers can alter their speech to listeners’ developmental level
- Animistic beliefs are seen most often in relation to objects that seem to move by themselves or have other life-like features
- Preschoolers do retain some fantastic beliefs but their beliefs are flexible and appropriate for example they are when things seem to violate physical laws and not social conventions and when something seems to have caused the event. Because they entertain the possibility that something they imagine might materialize they are more sensitive to scary movies and stories.
- Preoperational children can often pass conservation tasks if the task is simplified and/or the child receives training
- They can reason by analogy about physical changes
- Preoperational children show causal reasoning in some situations—they use if-then expressions as accurately as adults do
- Use illogical reasoning when grappling with unfamiliar topics, too much information, or contradictory facts they can not reconcile
- Although they have difficulty with class inclusion, preoperational children are skilled at categorization (by: common function, behavior, or natural kind) challenging that they categorize solely by appearance.
- Children often have difficulty with appearance-reality distinctions up until age 6 or 7
3-mountains task
Jean Piaget used the three mountains task to test whether children were egocentric. Egocentric children assume that other people will see the same view of the three mountains as they do. According to Piaget at age 7, thinking is no longer egocentric as the child can see more than their own point of view.
Preschoolers do retain some fantastic beliefs
Most believe in supernatural forces, and use ‘magic’ to explain events that they don’t have explanations for
Although they tend to figure out Santa, the Tooth Fairy, and magicians between 4 and 8, their understanding that imagination can’t create reality remains wobbly
conservation tasks
Number
Mass
Liquid
weight
causal reasoning
Causal reasoning is the ability to identify relationships between cause and the effect.
categorization
During the second and third years, they form basic, subordinate, and superordinate categories. (hierarchical)
Ability is partially do to interest and exposure to subject.
In sum early childhood categorization is: less complex, but the can classify hierarchically and on the basis of nonobvious properties and use logical, causal reasoning to identify the interrelated features that form the basis of a category and to classify new members.
Adult child conversations are a major source of categorical learning. (picture book reading)
Subordinate – husky (subcatgorys)
Basic - dog
Superordinate - animal
class inclusion
The understanding, more advanced than simple classification, that some classes or sets of objects are also sub-sets of a larger class. (E.g. there is a class of objects called dogs. There is also a class called animals. But all dogs are also animals, so the class of animals includes that of dogs)
Why do Children often have difficulty with appearance-reality distinctions up until age 6 or 7
It is not a hard time distinguishing appearance from reality rather it seems to be largely a verbal issue
In cases where they can pick the right answer from objects then they do better than when they need to name the object
It involves the attainment of duel representation
At first this understanding is fragile
Piaget and Early Childhood Education
Piaget’s theory has led to three educational principles that continue to have a major influence on childhood education
Offered strong theoretical justification for child-orientated approaches to classroom teaching.
• Discovery learning – children learn for themselves through spontaneous interactions with the environment. Teachers provide a rich variety of activities designed to promote learning.
• Sensitivity to children’s readiness to learn – teachers introduce activities that build on children’s current thinking and challenge incorrect ways of viewing the world but do not try to speed up development by imposing new skills before children indicate they are interested and ready.
• Acceptance of individual differences – different rates of the same stage development. Activities planned for individuals or small groups
Some cognitive attainments of early childhood
2-4 years
Dramatic gains in represential activity as reflected in the development of language, make-believe play, understating of dual representation, and categorization.
Takes perspective of others in simplified, familiar situation and everyday face to face communication
Distinguishes animate beings from inanimate objects; denies that magic can alter everyday experiences
Grasps conservation, notices transformation, reverses thinking, and understands many cause-and-effect relationships in familiar contexts
Categorizes objects on the basis of common function, behavior, and natural kind. Devises ideas about underlining characteristics that category members share and uses inner causal features to categorize objects varying widely in external appearance.
Sorts familiar objects into hierarchically organized categories
Distinguishes appearance with reality.
4-7 years
Becomes increasingly aware that make believe play (and other thought processes) are representational activities
Replaces magical beliefs about fairies, exedra and events that violate expectations with plausible explanations
Solves verbal appearance-reality problems, signifying a more secure understanding
Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory
Whereas Piaget was sometimes criticized for focusing on children’s interaction with the physical environment, to the exclusion of the social environment, Vygotsky focused on development in a social context
Piaget de-emphasis on language as a source of cognitive development brought on another challenge from Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory.
In Vygotsky’s view the child and social environment collaborate to mold cognition in culturally adaptive ways.
During early childhood, rapid growth of language broadens preschoolers participation in social dialogues with more knolagable individuals who encourage them to master culturaly important tasks.
Private speech
Vygotsky
Greatly enhances the complexity of their thinking
Brighter preschoolers use more private speech than do those who are less bright
Children use private speech more often when engaged in tasks that are within their zone of proximal development, but challenging
More attentive and better task performance at a task then children that did not use it
Children with learning and behaviour problems engage in private speech longer than do their peers
This helps them control their own behavior.
Self guidance
Eventually becomes internalized as silent “inner speech”
egocentric speech
Piaget
Self speech that is directed to them self because of egocentrism. “talk for self”
Precursor to social speech
Now called private speech and uses Vygotsky’s ideas
Social interaction needs what two features in order to promote cognitive development?
Effective social interaction
(Vygotsky)
Intersubjectivity – the process by which two participants who begin a task with different understandings arrive at a shared understanding.
Between 3 and 5 children strive for intersubjectivity in dialogues with peers, as when they affirm a playmates message, add new ideas, and make contributions to ongoing play to sustain it. It this way they create a zone of proximal development for one another.
Scaffolding – adjusting the support offered during a teaching session to fit the child’s current level performance. (direct teaching activitys)
Guided participation
Effective social interaction
Vygotsky
Guided participation is shared endeavors between more expert and less expert participants, regardless of the precise features of communication.
More diverce opportunities to learn. (indirect teaching)
Vygotsky and Early Childhood Education
Both Piagetian and Vygotskian classrooms emphasize active participation and acceptance of individual differences but a Vygotskian classroom goes beyond independent discovery to promote assisted discovery.
Vygotsky’s theory suggests that classrooms should involve
Assisted discovery
Peer collaboration
Make-believe play – learn to follow internal ideas and social rules rather than their immediate impulses.
assisted discovery
Teachers guide learning with explanations, demonstrations, and verbal prompts, tailoring their intervention to each child’s zone of proximal development.
It is aided by peer collaboration