Chapter 8 - Language Change Flashcards
What Does Historical Linguists Do?
Chart out how and why long term, far reaching changes occur in a language
What do prescriptivists say?
- Proscribe a way that we should say things
- Believe that changes to the norm result from sloppiness
What does every instance of change start with?
Variation
What do traditional approaches claim about language change
- We can not see a change we can only see the consequences
- The important changes = permanent structural changes
- Variation is not important - it is random
What two things are sociolinguists interested in regarding language change
- How linguistic variation relates to L. change
* How L. change relates to social variables (social class, gender, age)
Traditional HIstorical linguistics looks only at what?
Structural concequences of change
What two types of change do Traditional Historical Linguists consider?
o Internal change: within the language because of some innate development, direction that the language is predisposed to change (phonological, morphological, syntax, semantics etc.)
o External change: at the pressure of external factors - other languages, economics (borrowing)
Examples of internal and external change?
Internal :
>Phonological - Lenition
> Morphological change - a napron sounds like an apron, so we artificially moved the word boundary
> Syntax -grammaticalization of I’m going
External:
> Phonological borrowing - the sound /j/ (as in jean)
> Lexical borrowing - yogurt (turkish)
Give an example of a language that encourage borrowing
- Urdu encourages borrowing from the arabic languages to stress their heritage
Give an example where borrowing was discouraged
The Nazis wanted to irradicate all non-german borrowed words (hitler actually stopped them!)
What type of change to Historical linguists value as being more important
Internal Change
What was the Major theoretical model discussed in class?
Family tree model - one sound has a phonemic split and there are two, and then those phonemes change etc.
Criticism of family tree model
- says that the process of change is instant.
- ignores external influences because they belong to different branches
- Focuses on the consequences (results)
What is the Wave Theory
- Various changes are floating from different centres and spread equally in all sides and directions (but at different speeds)
- circles can interact
- waves of changes diffuse through a language
- can affect linguistic, social and geographical space
Does every variation cause change?
NO and we cannot predict which ones will lead to change
What is long term/stable variation
a long lasting variation UNlikey to lead to a change
ex. h dropping, g dropping
- Related to social class, style, age, gender, social network etc
What is the Northern cities chain shift?
- typical of major urban centres: Chicago, Detroit, Cleveland and buffalo
- Some aspects are detectable in Milwaukee, Pittsburg, Columbus and Indianapolis
-Canada not affected
CHAIN SHIFT: Each vowel receives a new place of articulation by pushing other vowel out (domino effect)
ex. bit > bet / but
Do sociolinguistics believe you can see changes in progress?
YES
Give an example of a change in progress
The spread of uvular r in Europe:
o In France the king could not pronounce the trill /r/ and instead was pronouncing the uvular. So people started to imitate him and this change began to spread
o Has yet to reach Great Britain
What is the Lexical Diffusion Model
- Changes travel gradually \
\through linguistic, social or geographical space
2 Major factors effecting difusion
1) Density - How many people live in that place
2) Influence of language urban centers - the prestige of the language in the nearest center
Gravity Model
- Change first effects urban centers then smaller citys and finally rural areas (geographical space)
What prevents diffusion between close cities?
Spatial barriers - mountains, rivers, political boundaries
ex. Detroit isn’t affected by chain shift like windsor because of a national boundary
What is age grading?
- using speech appropriately to the speaker’s age
ex. child who only speaks native language until 10, will not speak that language for fear of embarrassment