Chapter 5 - The UK Financial Regulators Flashcards
UK regulatory landscape - PRA, FPC & FCA (what are they, characteristics and objectives) & PRC (creation and what)
PRA - responsible for promoting safety and soundness of systematically important firms such as insurers and ensuring policy holders are protected if the firms fails. Approach to reg and supervision has three characteristics; judgement based, forward-looking & focused.
FPC - committee within BoE that tries to identify emerging risks to financial system and provides strategic direction for regulators. Uses macro-prudential tools to counter systematic risk such as leverage limits on banks or enforcing capital requirements for given asset classes. BoE responsible for micro and macro-prudential reg along with monetary responsibilities thus becoming one of worlds most powerful central banks.
FCA - objective to ensure that relevant markets function well. 3 operational objectives; protect consumers, protect financial markets (protect & enhance integrity of financial system) & promote competition. Takes proactive approach
PRC - creation and integration of PRA into bank were required by BoE & FS Act 2016. PRC on same legal footing as MPC & FPC as well as making PRA’s most important decisions.
PRA - General overview, three objectives with explanation (for first point)
Responsible for authorisation, prudential regulation and supervision of larger financial firms. Sets standard and supervises financial institutions and is governed by PRC.
3 objectives:
- Promote safety and soundness of firms it regulates;
Focuses on harm that firms can cause to UK financial system. A stable financial system is one in which firms continue to provide critical services - a precondition for healthy and successful economy. Institutions and firms that pose greatest risk to the stability are the focus of their work.
- Contribute to securing of appropriate degree of protection for those who become insurance holders (specific to insurance firms);
- facilitate effective competition (secondary objective)
PRA continued - Threshold conditions & PRC, two key tools, approach to reg and supervision (3)
There are threshold conditions that firms must met including maintaining appropriate capital, liquidity and having suitable management. Most significant decisions make by PRC and they are accountable to parliament.
Advances it objectives using two key tools;
- Regulation - sets standards/policies that firms must meet.
- Supervision - assesses risk firms pose to PRA objectives and takes action to reduce them if necessary.
PRA’s approach to regulation and supervision has three characteristics;
- Judgment-based - uses judgement to determine if firms are safe and sounds i.e. if insurance firms are providing appropriate protection needs and whether firms continue to meet threshold conditions.
- Forward-looking - Assesses against current and future risk. Will aim to intervene at early stage.
- Focused - focuses on issues and firms that pose greatest risk to stability of the financial system and policyholders.
PRA - Global & European engagement - Bodies involved with & why, key responsibilities and info sharing.
Effective international co-operation vital to PRA’s success.
PRA is actively involved with FSB, BCBS, IAIS & joint forum and uses these forums to advances its safety and soundness and policyholder protection objectives.
Key responsibility is supervision of overseas firm operating in the UK as well as UK groups operating abroad. Actively engages with overseas counterparts in supervising cross border firms and have agreements that allow them to share confidential information with one another. Also participates in ‘supervisory colleges’ for firms with significant operations in the UK and also UK firms.
PRA - European engagement and legislation - PRA engagement with these bodies, European supervisory authorities, PRA UK representation.
Policy standards agreed internationally are implements in Europe through directives or directly-applicable regulations. PRA actively engages with EU institutions and regulators which lead to legislative programme being has been implemented in the UK.
Regulation of financial services overseen by ESFS which comprised of three ESA’s:
- EBA
- ESMA
- EIOPA
PRA is UK representative of these three bodies. Ongoing involvement in EU regulations remains unclear until terms of Brexit are agreed. ESA’s have a large effect on UK and European legislation and PRA is involved with groups that develop rules and guidance.
Financial Policy Committee (FPC) - Scope & Objectives - responsibilities & macro-prudential tools
Run by BoE, FPC has responsibility for macro-prudential supervision, spotting systematic risks attributable to structural features of financial markets or to the distribution of risk within the financial sector and identifying unsustainable levels of leverage, debt and credit growth. FPC has obligation to limit impact of policies on economic growth.
If identified risk, FPC has power to use ‘macro-prudential tools’, these include:
- Setting countercyclical capital buffers - ensuring banks increase capital during the good times to protect against bad times. Should also affect tempering of lending and therefore have dampening effect on credit cycle.
- Variable risk weights - enforcing targeted capital requirements for specific sectors and asset classes e.g banks required to hold greater levels of capital against asset exposures that represent large risk.
- Leverage limits - limiting excessive build up of on-and-off balance sheet leverage. Measures of risk unreliable, leverage ratio can act as buffer to risk-weighted requirements e.g. capital buffer.
FPC - Governance - Who’s on it?
13 members and chaired by governor of BoE with five independent external members appointed by CotE (expertise & balance of opinion).
FPC - Accountability - Treasury conts & reports
Treasury provides FPC with guidance to help shape pursuit of financial stability. FPC has to respond detailing the extent to which they agree and actions required - may reject if doesn’t agree.
FPC required to publish financial stability report twice a year and a record of every meeting within 6 weeks.
FCA - aims in relation to conduct and discharging functions, responsible, 2012 Act & transparency
Aims to ensure that all business across financial services is conducted in a way that advances interests of consumers and market participants. Discharge function in way that promotes effective competition.
Responsible for consumer credit regulation.
2012 Act - Gov granted product intervention power which enables them to ban or impose restrictions on financial products quickly.
FCA can disclose or publish details of warning notices in relation to disciplinary action and take formal action against misleading financial promotions and disclose this.
Prudential Regulation Committee (PRC) - BoE Act 1998, works alongside & what does good financial system support
BoE Act 1998 requires Treasury to make recommendations to PRC about aspects of economic policy that PRC should consider when looking on how to advance objectives of PRA and when considering the application of regulatory principles set out in FSMA 2000. - i.e. Treasury tell PRC what bits of their economic policy need to look out for when considering their own objectives.
PRC main contribution to economic policy is promoting safety and soundness of firms which maintains and enhances financial stability.
Should work alongside FPC, MPC and FCA.
A strong, stable and competitive financial system supports economic growth, facilitates productive investment and underpins UK as important global financial centre.
PRC - Considerations in assessment of cost, burdens and benefits of policies when thinking about how to advance PRA objectives (6)
Competition - Gov keen for more competition in all sectors of industry - includes minimising barriers to entry and ensuring a diverse set of business models across the industry.
Growth - FS markets need to make positive contribution to sustainable economic growth in the medium to long term through the facilitation of finance for productive investment and being a productive sector.
Competitiveness - Ensure that the UK remains attractive for international financial institutions and London remains leading international financial centre. Need for robust institutions and resilient system.
Innovation - Gov keen to see innovation - can be through how they engage with consumers and new ways of raising capital. Important to recognise differences in nature and objectives of business models and ensuring burdens are equal.
Trade - aim to encourage trade and inward investment that can help boost productivity and growth across the economy. Being flexible to change to show UK good place to do business.
Better outcomes for customers - ensure working in the best interests of the customer.
FCA Objectives - Acts & strategic objective, 8 reg principles
Set up under FSMA 2000 as amended by FS Act 2012. Latter act states FCA has strategic objective to ensure that the relevant markets function well.
Must consider reg principles when discharging functions:
- Efficiency and economy - need to use its resources in most efficient and economical way. Treasury can issue value-for-money reviews which are controls over the above.
- Proportionality - burden or restriction imposed should be proportioned to the benefits. When making judgements in this area, FCA considers costs to consumer and firm - cost benefit analysis.
- Sustainable growth - ensure that there is desire for sustainable growth in the economy for medium to long term.
- Responsibility of consumers - consumers should take responsibility for their decisions.
- Senior management responsibility - firms SM is resp for its activities and ensuring that the firm compiles with regulatory requirements.Principle designed so an adequate level of intervention can be made by holding senior manager to account. Firms must take care to monitor and control affairs as well as making it clear who is responsible for what.
- Recognising the way business is carried out by different regulated persons - exercise functions in a way that recognises differences in nature of and objectives of businesses carried out by different persons subject to requirements under FSMA.
- Openness and disclosure - publishing information about reg person or requiring them to publish information therefore making market information available. This reinforces market discipline and enhances public knowledge in financial matters.
- Transparency - Ensuring appropriate information is provided on reg decisions and FCA should be open and accessible to public and reg community.
FCA objectives - these objectives are to…
- provide political and public accountability. Annual report that contains assessment to measure the extent that they have met these objectives. Parliament committees will scrutinise FCA and focus on how it achieves its objectives.
- Govern way FCA carries out functions i.e. rule-making, giving advice/guidance and determining policy and principles. Must show how draft rules relate to their objectives.
- Assist in providing legal accountability. If FCA interprets objectives in the wrong way, liable to be challenged in courts.
FCA - Operational Objectives - Protecting consumers - list then promoting competition.
Protect customers from actual or potential detriment, powers enhance confident in retail markets, aim to intervene, focus on firms conduct and knock-on effect actions may have.
In providing appropriate consumer protection, FCA looks to measures that promote competition. In relation to products or services, remedies that solely focus promoting competition may not improve customer outcomes due to market power not always being central to the problem. Measures that promote competition that remedies market power and information asymmetry, they provide consumer protection.
Protecting financial markets - role in stability, FPC recommendations & directions & what they are concerned with re this objective
Does not have explicit responsibility for financial stability but their supervision and regulatory activities play a role in stability. Objective vital in supervision one financial Infrastructure.
FCA subject to FPC recommendations and directions on use of regulatory tools in the pursuit of macro-prudential policy. Continues exchange of views and info between these two bodies.
In relation to protecting financial markets, FCA concerned with;
- soundness and resilience of trading structure
- integrity of financial markets including reliability of their price formation process and suitability of listing rules
- combating market abuse
- examining extent UK financial system may be used for financial crime.
FCA - Promoting competition - markets & informed choices and competition objectives.
Seeks to promote competition but some markets that consumers cannot exercise informed choice - FCA need to be able to tackle underlying characteristics of markets to ensure that consumers can make informed choice.
FCA’s competition objectives mean that:
- firms must compete for business by offering better services.
- prices offered in line with costs.
- FCA will draw line between good innovation and ones that exploit consumers.
Competition concurrency - Acts & relation to CMA&FSMA
FCA has concurrent competition powers which means it can;
- enforce against and fine for breaches of anti-competitive agreements and abuse of dominant position (Competition Act 1998).
- make a market investigation reference to CMA (Consumer Rights Act 2015)
These powers can also be exercised by CMA and FCA can use FSMA powers to reach competition objective.
FCA - Scope - applying & powers with regards to enforcement, supervision and authorisation.
Any person wishing to carry on one or more regulated activities must apply to relevant regulator for direct authorisation - applying for Part 4A permission.
FCA has following powers over those carrying out regulated activities;
- Enforcement - to… impose penalties for market abuse, carry out investigations, take disciplinary action against authorised person and instigate criminal proceedings.
- Supervision - to… make rules including those for conduct of business, client money, financial promotions and fighting money laundering, require an authorised person to provide information or documents, regulate changes of control over UK authorised persons, keep Lloyd’s insurance market under review and to cooperate with other regulators.
- Authorisation - to… grant, vary and cancel authorisations and permitted activities, approve individuals to perform controlled functions, issue codes for conduct, take action for misconduct, be represented in court, authorise unit trusts, recognise overseas collective investment scheme, recognise investment exchanges and clearing houses, maintain public record of authorised persons.
FCA’s main roles and activities and what they include (3)
Direct authorisation and regulation of UK financial services system this includes,
- authorising businesses
- ensuring authorised businesses are financially sound (pr)
- regulating conduct of business.
Monitoring activities of various recognised bodies, this includes;
- recognised investment exchanges ie London Stock Exchange
- recognised overseas investment exchanges ie NASDAQ
- recognised clearing houses ie CREST
- designated professional bodies.
Policing financial services system, this includes;
- Stopping firms and individuals from carrying out unauthorised investment business.
- preventing certain individuals from being employed or becoming representatives of authorised firms.
FCA - Accountability - Policeman role, who answerable to & small representations
FCA oversees most of financial industry and has a policeman role in pursuing unauthorised businesses operating illegally and has the power to shut down these businesses and bring prosecutions if necessary. Can act against those who are authorised by other bodies and can act against market trends e.g. PPI
Occupational pension schemes and buy-to-let falls outside FCA remit.
FCA answerable to Treasury and CotE has ultimate resp for regulatory system. Also required to make annual report to Parliament and can be subject to Upper Tribunal, CMA & Complaints Commissioner.
FCA required to maintain practitioner, consumer, smaller businesses and markets panels so they are represented but does not have to take any action recommended by them.
Financial Services Practitioner Panel (FSPP) - aims
Aims to convey the views and concerns of the regulated industries. Senior figures from FS industry meet on monthly basis to discuss issues of relevance to regulated firms with sub groups formed to discuss specific matters with the FCA in more depth.
Aim to provide early and effective input into FCA policy development and main focus is on areas that have greatest impact on financial firms and consumers to help improve outcomes for all.
Financial Services Consumer Panel (FSCP)
Represents interests of consumers through debating and making recommendations on FCA policy. They review, monitor and report to the FCA on the effectiveness of their policies.
Smaller Business Practitioner Panel (SBPP)
Overall objective to ensure that regulatory environment enables smaller firms to be viable and able to flourish. Has statutory status under FS Act 2012.
Markets Practitioner Panel (MPP)
Role is to represent interests of practitioners who are affected by FCA functions regarding markets in relation to short selling powers and regulation of investment exchanges.
FCA - Enforcement and discipline - actions it can take & insider dealing
FCA’s enforcement division investigates if firms breach FCA rules or FSMA provisions. They can take such action as;
- withdrawing firms authorisation.
- disciplining firms and their authorised employees
- requiring skilled persons reports on any aspects of regulatory compliance
- imposing penalties for market abuse
- applying to courts for injunction and restitution orders
- prosecuting offences
FSMA grants FCA power to take action using Criminal Justice Act 1993 and Money Laundering Regulations 2017 (MLR) for insider dealing. This gives them power to interview people and require them to hand over documents.
FCA - Enforcement and Discipline cont - what they consider when making decision, RDC and Upper Tribunal
Investigate unauthorised parties carrying out regulated activities and works with other reg bodies and law enforcement agencies
Takes a risk based approach when considering what cases to review - this includes considering Regulatory Objectives, Principles of Good Regulation and its Referral Criteria. They need to consider carefully course of action to take and exercise fairness. Settlement is possible at any stage but Regulatory Decisions Committee makes final decision on those that don’t settle. Upper Tribunal handles any appeals in decision.
FCA - Enforcement in civil and criminal courts - civil and criminal law and main civil actions (3)
Civil law - parties in a transaction, enforced by themselves & usually compensation given.
Criminal law - rights of the public, enforced by State & involves fines imprisonment etc.
FCA can issue civil proceedings in the High Court - main civil actions include;
Asking high court to grant injunctions which are orders that forbid individual from continuing or repeating certain type of misconduct. Forward looking instruments that;
- prevent conducting regulated activities without authorisation
- prevent misleading statements in breach with FSMA
- stop unlawful financial promotions
- prevent market abuse
Ordering the payment of restitution - if person breached requirement and profits or losses have been made as a result, a successful court order will make this repayable to victim. Can also freeze assets so that they are not sold off.
Granting insolvency orders - can apply for winding up or administrative order against any firm that breaches the general prohibition.
FCA - Enforcement in the civil and criminal courts - Criminal proceedings - summary only, indictable, either way and punishments and offences.
FCA has power to prosecute several specific offences. Some are dealt with at magistrates court (summary only), others can be heard at crown court (indictable) and some are either way.
Some may be punishable via fine whilst others max prison sentence of 7 years and include falsely claiming to be FCA authorised, reg activity without authorisation, misleading statements to induce investment and failing to co operate with FCA investigations
FCA - Market Abuse - what is it & civil offences
Market abuse is Improper conduct that undermines UK financial markets or damages interest of ordinary market participants. FSMA creates civil penalties which run parallel to criminal offences (making misleading statements and engaging in misleading conduct).
Civil offence (FSMA) can be any of these;
- Insider dealing - when insider deals or tries to deal with inside information that is not available generally.
- Improper disclosure - where an insider improperly discloses inside information to another person.
- Misuse of information - behaviour based on information not generally available but effects investors decision about terms on which to deal.
- Manipulating transactions - trading that gives false impression of the supply and demand for an investment causing the prices to rise to abnormal or artificial levels.
- Manipulating devices - trading which employs fictitious devices or any form of deception.
- Dissemination - knowingly giving out info that conveys false or misleading impression of investment.
- Distortion and misleading behaviour - behaviour that gives a false or misleading impression on supply and demand for an investment or beh that distorts the market in an investment.
FCA - Criminal Offences cont - sentences and where appropriate
Misleading statements, misleading conduct and insider dealing are punishable with 7 years in prison or unlimited fine. FCA must impose a financial penalty or make a public statement about behaviour.
FCA policy to follow through on cases where criminal prosecution is appropriate. These will be cases where;
- enough evidence to provide decent prospect of convicting defendant.
- prosecution is in public interest due to seriousness of offence.
Money Laundering - FCA are able to + other money laundering activities
Fourth Money Laundering Directive requires supervisors to have the power to impose effective, proportionate and dissuasive sanctions for non-compliance. FCA are able to;
- give penalties to firms that breach money laundering regulations.
- Prosecute officer of business if in breach of money laundering regulations. This can carry 2 year prison sentence, fine or both.
Other offences;
- having anything to do with criminal property or assisting another is an offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison and unlimited fine.
- failure to report any knowledge or suspicion of person money laundering or terrorist funding is offence punishable up to 5 years and or fine.
FCA - Regulatory supervision - 3 approaches to regulation
FCA approach to regulation can be summarised as follows;
Product intervention and governance - FCA aims to be proactive and intervene early in the products life span and address the root cause of the problem. Powers include temporary intervention rules and product pre-approval.
Super-complaints - FCA able to review and react to submission by consumer group on behalf of consumers.
Competition powers - FCA competition objective is to promote effective competition in the interests of the consumer.
FCA approach to supervision - what is it, risk based assessed against (5), reg effort and potential risks prioritised using what and what does this effect
Supervision is term used to describe day to day regulatory relationship with authorised firms.
Risk based approach for this as well - firms are individually assessed against where the firm is operating, volume of transactions, type of product, type of customer and impact of potential loses to client. Greater regulatory effort is expended on higher risk firms. Risk is embedded throughout regulations firms must manage and control risk.
Potential risks are prioritised using impact and probability analysis and FCA then decides approach it will take and resources it will allocate to mitigate risk.
FCA approach to supervision - general principles & supervisor organisation
General Principles - supervisory system designed so that businesses are encouraged to base model, culture and running of their business with fair treatment of customer their main priority.
Supervisor organisation - this approach requires more flexible focus on bigger issues as they arise. Some larger firms might have supervisor assigned with intensive contact and vice versa.
FCA - Conduct supervision - three pillar supervision model - proactive, event driven and thematic
FCA’s supervision work is based around three pillars of activity which use its ongoing analysis of each industry sector and the risks within them.
Proactive firm/group supervision - designed to assess firms conduct risk. Entails business model and strategy analysis including culture, product design, sales and transaction process and post sales services. Take proactive approach.
Event driven, reactive supervision- supervisory activity in response to issues that have recently happened. Flexible element of how FCA will allocate supervisory staff so that resources are given to situations with higher risk to consumers. whistle blowing, spike in complaints etc.
Thematic approach - issues and products supervision - FCA looks at risks and issues in each sector to analyse events and investigate drivers of poor outcomes for consumers. Does this often to address common risk before it causes widespread damage. Issues like particular business practice or problem with certain product.
FCA - Conduct Supervision- firm categorisation
FCA will continue to look at the way individual firms and people behave but also focus on how markets work as a whole with emphasis on sector and market-wide analysis.
Firms are now categorised as either fixed portfolio or flexible portfolio. Fixed portfolio firms are subject to group specific supervision whilst flexible firms are subject to event driven reactive supervision and thematic issue.
Over time, firms could see a change in how they’re supervised and 70 firms have already been newly classified.
FCA - Conduct supervision - fixed and flexible portfolio firms
Fixed portfolio firms - small population of firms, that, based on factors such as size, market presence and customer footprint, require the highest level of supervisory attention. Pro-actively supervised using continuous assessment approach.
Flexible portfolio firms - majority and supervised through market based thematic work and programmes aligned with risk identified in their sector. Not allocated a named individual and use FCA Customer Contact Centre as port of call.
FCA - conduct supervision - ten supervision principles
FCA’s approach to supervision is built on these principles and forms the basis of its interaction with firms;
- Ensuring fair outcomes for consumers and markets
- Forward looking and preemptive
- Focused on big issues and causes of the problems
- Judgment based approach
- Ensuring firms act in right spirit
- Examine business models and culture - FCA interested on how firm makes its money as this could drive many potential risks.
- Emphasis on individual accountability
- Robust when things go wrong - ensuring problems are fixed and consumers are protected.
- Communicating openly
- Having joint up approach - ensuring firms get consistent messages from the FCA and engage with other bodies when necessary.
FCA - Conduct supervision - Earlier intervention - Banning products, withdrawing misleading financial promos, publication of enforcement action (product offerings and notice given) and market intelligence gathering and research (risk and compliance oversight and what sources of information)
FCA now look into the root causes of detriment as per FS Act 2012, examples of this include;
Banning products
- if serious problem identified then product can be banned and can intervene to stop a product being sold prior cost-benefit analysis or consultation.
Withdrawing misleading financial promotions
- can take action against above, can disclose that action against a firm has commenced and it is required to alert a firm to proposed course of action and allow for firm to make adjustments before publishing details of action.
Publication of enforcement action
- objective is to improve product offerings by bringing more enforcement cases and tougher penalties. FCA allowed to publish warning notice has been issued about firm as well as summary of the notice but must consider factors when publishing i.e. will it be unfair. Gov can repeal early warning notice if deemed contrary to interest of the public.
Market intelligence gathering and research
- FCA has ‘Risk and Compliance Oversight Division’ that identifies and assesses risks to consumers and creates a common view to inform FCA’s supervision, enforcement and authorisation functions. Sources for evidence are consumer groups, media, ongoing market analysis and consumer action line.