Chapter 5: Eyewitness Testimony Flashcards
Recall memory
Reporting what you remember off the top of your head
Recognition memory
Determining whether the person or thing you saw in the past is the same as what you’re looking at now (ex. multiple choice, choosing the one you recognize)
What are the 5 stages of memory?
1) perception/attention
2) encoding stage
3) short-term memory
4) long-term memory
5) retrieval stage
how to study eyewitness research
Archival Data
police reports, transcripts, etc
Naturalistic Observations
(of witnesses)
Observe witness in real time
How are lab studies used to do research on eyewitness testimony?
(what is their focus?)
Most common is tests relating to memory (ex. showing change blindness videos)
IND. Estimator Variables
variables present at the time of the crime that cannot be changed (ex. age of witness)
IND. System Variables
Variables that can be manipulated in order to increase or decrease eyewitness accuracy (ex. the type of lineup used)
What are the 3 general DEP. variables in eyewitness studies?
- recognition of perp.
- recall of perp.
- recall of event/crime
Open-ended recall/Free narrative
- recount without being prompted
- TED questions (tell, explain, describe)
Direct question recall
- asked specific questions about the event/crime (ex. what was the colour of their jacket?)
What are the 3 ways recall of info is measured?
1) Amount (ex. how many details)
2) Type (ex. important? related? specific?)
3) Accuracy (ex. how many errors when comparing to other answers)
What are the 2 ways that witness recognition is measured?
- Accuracy (rate of correctly identifying the perp in a lineup)
- Errors (rate of identifying an innocent person, rate of stating perp isn’t present when they are)
Memory conformity
When there are multiple witnesses to a crime, one can be “contaminated” when they know what another witness has said about the crime
- when what one witness reports influences what another witness reports
Is it beneficial to mix visual and auditory questions during an interview?
No because asking a witness to recall on physical memories and audio memories can get confusing and may impact what is remembered correctly
What did Loftus and Palmer (1974) discover?
A witness recall report can be altered by the phrasing of the question being asked
- studies on “smashed” vs. “hit” cars (ex. the people who were asked questions using “smashed” reported that the car was going faster than the people who were asked “hit” questions)
Misinformation Effect/ Post-Event Information Effect
If a witness is given false information about the event after it has happened, they are more likely to incorporate that misinformation into their recall of the event
Misinformation Acceptance Hypothesis
- witness trying to please the questioner
- guessing which answer they think the questioner wants to hear
Source Misattribution Hypothesis
witnesses remember their accurate and inaccurate memories of the event but can’t remember which one is which
Memory Impairment Hypothesis
Original memory gets overwritten by a new memory that is likely influenced by leading questions
Why is it thought that hypnosis can improve eyewitness recall?
Idea that a hypnotized person may be able to retrieve more details about an event from their subconscious
What’s an issue with using hypnosis in an interview?
Hypnotized people are highly suggestible and are usually equally confident in their accurate and inaccurate info
Is hypnosis allowed in canadian courts?
no
Cognitive Interview
an interview based on the principles of memory storage and retrieval
What are 4 memory retrieval techniques used in a cognitive interview?
- reinstating context
- reporting everything
- recall event in a different order
- changing perspective
Enhanced Cognitive Interview
includes principles of social dynamics