Chapter 21 Notes Flashcards
- Can the debt be satisfied through the possession and (usually) sale of the collateral?
- Will the creditor have priority over any other creditors or buyers who may have rights in the sale collateral?
Two Main Concerns of the Creditor if the Debtor Defaults
Failure to pay a debt when it is due.
Default
- Unless the creditor has possession of the collateral, there must be a written or authenticated security agreement that clearly describes the collateral subject to the security interest and is signed or authenticated by the debtor.
- The secured party must give something of value to the debtor.
- The debtor must have “rights” in the collateral.
Requirements to Create a Security Interest
Under Article 9 of the UCC, any party who owes payment or performance of a secured obligation.
Debtor
Once the requirements to create a security interest are met, the creditor’s rights are said to ____ to the collateral.
Attach
In a secured transaction, the process by which a secured creditor’s interest “attaches” to the collateral and the creditor’s security interest bcomes enforceable. In the context of judicial liens, a court-ordered seizure of property before a judgement is secured for a past-due debt.
Attachment
When the collateral is not in the possession of the secured party, the security agreement must be either written or authenticated. It must also describe the collateral.
Written or Authenticated Security Agreement
To sign, execute, or adopt any symbol on an electronic record that verifies that the person signing has the intent to adopt or accept the record.
Authenticate
The collateral must be reasonably identified:
- Pharses like “all the debtors assets” or “all the debtors personal property” would not consitute a sufficient description.
Decription of the Collateral
Normally, the value given by a secured party is in the form of a direct loan or a committment to sell goods on credit.
Secured Party Must Give Value
The debtor must have a current or a future ownership interest in or right to obtain possession of the collateral.
- Misconception: that the debtor must have title to the collateral to have rights in it, but this is not a requirement.
Debtors Must Have Rights in the Collateral
The legal process by which secured parties protect themselves against the claims of third parties who may wish to have their debts satisified out of the same collateral. It is usually accomplished by filing a financing statement with the appropriate government official.
Perfection
Whether a secured party’s security interest is perfected or unperfected can have serious consequences for the secured party.
- The creditor with a perfected security interest will prevail.
- In some circumstances a security interest becomes perfected even though no financing statement was made.
Perfecting a security interest.
A financing statement gives public notice to third parties of the secured party’s security interest. The security agreement itself can also be filed to perfect the security interest.
- Financing statement must have names of the debtor and secured party, and must identify the collateral covered by the financing statement.
- Can be filed electronically
- Can be filed before a secruity agreement is made or a security interest attaches.
Perfection by Filing
- Communication of the financing statement to the appropriate filing office
- Correct filing fee; or
- The acceptance of the financing statement by the filing officer
What Constitutes a Filing
Filed by this so that the financing statements can be located by subsequent searches.
- Slight variations will not be considered misleading if a search of the filing office’s records, using a standard computer search engine routinely used by the office, would disclose the filings.
The Debtor’s Name
- Corporations
- Trusts
- Individuals and organizations
- Trade names
Categories of Rules for Determining when the Debtor’s Name as it Appears on a Financing Statement is Sufficient:
The debtor’s name on the financing statement must be “the name of the debtor indicated on the public record of the debtor’s jurisdiction of organization.”
Corporations
The financing statement must disclose this information and provide that trust’s name as specified in its official documents.
Trusts (or Trustee for Property Held in Trust)
The financing statement must disclose “the individual or organizational name of the debtor.” If the organizational debtor does not have a group name, the names of the individuals in the group must be listed.
- Organization includes: unincorporated associations, such as clubs, churches, joint ventures, and general partnerships.
Individuals and Organizations
When this name is not the legal name of the business, providing only this name in a financing statement is not sufficient for perfection.
- Must also include the owner-debtor’s name.
- If debtor’s name changes, the financing statement remains effective for collateral the debtor acquired before or within 4 months after the name change. (if not filed within 4 months, anything after that 4 months is unperfected).
Trade Names
Both the security agreement and the financing statement must describe the collateral in which the secured party has a security interest.
- The description in the security agreement must be more precise than the description in the financing statement.
- UCC allows broad, general descriptions in the financing statement, as long as they are accurate.
Description of the Collateral
Must describe the collateral because no security interest in goods can exist unless the parties agree on which goods are subject to the security interest.
Description- Security Agreement
Must describe the collateral to provide public notice of the fact that certain goods of the debtor are subject to a security interest.
- Other parties can check the file when they wish to buy collateral or lend money.
- Land related security interests- a legal description of the reality is also required.
Description- Financing Statement
A financing statement must be filed centrally in the appropriate state office, such as the office of the secretary of state, in the state where the debtor is located.
- Exception- When collateral consists of timber to be cut, fixtures, or items to be extracted- such as oil, coal, gas, and minerals. These are filed in the county where the collateral is located.
- Debtor’s location, not the location of collateral.
Where to File- Most States
- Individual debtors- the state of the debtor’s principal residence.
- Organization tht is registered with the state (Corporation or LLC)- the state in which the organization is registered.
- All other entities- the state in which the business is located or, if the debtor has more than one office, the place from which the debtor manages its business operations and affairs.
Determining the Debtor’s Location
Renders the security interest unperfected and reduces the secured party’s claim in bankruptcy to that of an unsecured creditor.
- i.e.- name is seriously misleading, collateral is not sufficiently described in financing statement
Consequences of an Improper Filing
Two types of situations security interest can be perfected without filing a financing statement:
- Occurs when the collateral is transferred into the possession of the secured party.
- Occurs when the security interest can be perfected on attachment (without a filing and without having to possess the goods).
Perfection Without Filing
Means that these security interests are automatically perfected at the time of the creation. Two common examples:
- purchase-money security interest in consumer goods
- An assignment of a beneficial interest in a decedent’s estate.
Perfected on Attachment
Past more common means of obtaining financing: to pledge certain collateral as security for the debt and transfer the collateral into the creditor’s possession. When the debt was paid, the collateral was returned to the debtor.
- Stocks, bonds, negitiable instruments, and jewelry are commonly transferred into the creditor’s possession when they are used as collateral for loans.
- For most collateral, possession by the secured party is impractical because it denies the debtor the right to use or derive income from the property to pay off the debt.
Perfection by Possession
A security device in which personal property is transferred into the possession of the creditor as security for the payment of a debt and retained by the creditor until the debt is paid.
Pledge
A security interest that arises when a seller or lender extends credit for part or all of the purchase price of goods purchased by a buyer.
- Consumer goods
- Entity that extends the credit and obtains this can be either the seller or a financial institution that lends the buyer the funds with which the purchase the goods.
Perfection by Attachment- The Purchase-Money Security Interest in Consumer Goods
Items bought primarily for family, personal, or household purposes.
Consumer Goods
A PMSI in consumer goods is perfected automatically at the time of a credit sale- at the time the PMSI is created. The seller in this situation does not need to do anything more to perfect her or his interest.
Automatic Perfection
- Certain types of security interests that are subject to other federal or state laws may require additional steps to be perfected.
- certificate-of-title statutes- establish certain perfection requirements for security interest
- PMSIs in nonconsumer goods (business inventory or livestock) are not automatically perfected.
Exceptions to the Rule of Automatic Perfection
Generally divided into two classifications:
- Tangible collateral
- Intangible collateral
Perfection and the Classification of Collateral
Collateral that can be seen, felt, and touched.
Tangible Collateral
Collateral that consists of or generates rights.
Intangible Collateral
A statement that, if filed within 6 months prior to the expiration date of the original financing statement, continues the perfection of the security interest for another five years.
- Financing statement is effective for 5 years from the date of filing (before filing for continuation)
- This can be continued indefinitely
- Anything filed otuside of this window is ineffective.
Effective Time Duration of Perfection- Continuation Statement
- Proceeds
- After-Acquired Property
- Future Advances
- The floating-lien concept
Scope of Security Interest
Under Article 9 of the UCC, whatever is recieved when collateral is sold or disposed of in some other way.
- A security interest in the collateral gives the secured party a security interest in this acquired from the sale of that collateral.
- Perfects automatically on the perfection of the secured party’s security interest in the original collateral, and it remains perfected 20 days after perfection period in their original security agreement.
Proceeds
Property that is acquired by the debtor after the execution of a security agreement.
- Generally debtor will purchase new property to replace the inventory sold. The secured party wants this newly acquired inventory to be subject to the original security interest. This clause continues the secured party’s claim to any inventory acquired thereafter.
After-Acquired Property
Often, a debtor will arrange with a bank to have a continuing line of credit under which the debtor can borrow funds intermediately. Advances against lines of credit can be subject to a properly perfected security interest in certain collateral.- may provide that future advances are also subject.
- Future advances do not have to be of the same type otherwise related to the original advance to benefit this type of cross-collateralization.
- Each advance is perfected as of the date of the original perfection.
Future Advances