Chapter 2 - Science and Sciencing Flashcards
Folk Methods
Ways of doing things either by intuition or by society. (ask authority, make own inquiries, think things through)
What branches or approaches to Psychology uses folk methods?
Popular Psychology, Artistic Psychology, or Literary Approach to Psychology
Folk Theories
Beliefs based on received wisdom, not concrete facts
What are 2 main problems with folk theories? (Why do we need to do science?)
Inaccuracy (either through personal biases or counter-intuition), and dogmatism (believing theories regardless of contrary evidence, or not knowing that we believe in a particular theory)
Retrievability Bias
The tendency to recall what is easy to remember (what’s common, recent, and/or leaves a strong impression)
Apophenia bias
The tendency to look for patterns and spot patterns in randomness
Anchoring Bias (insufficient adjustment bias)
The failure to adjust to new information given existing salient information
What is the Latin meaning of science? (not the definition in english)
“Scientia”; Knowledge
Science (definition)
Extensive, Shared, Durable and Organized knowledge
Sciencing (define)
The employment of methods to produce knowledge in science
What are the scientist’s obligations?
To believe what’s dependable and not believe what isn’t dependable, to be a reliable source of knowledge, and to create knowledge through sciencing (with other scientists)
What’s the Demarcation Problem?
The conundrum of finding criteria to differentiate science and non-science.
What did Aristotle believe is scientific knowledge?
To know what is and why
What is the modern solution to the demarcation problem?
Find clusters of features that constitute science and make it on a spectrum
What is wrong with Aristotle’s criteria for science?
There are far too many counterexamples (this is a problem with anyone who tried coming up with criteria for science)
Sufficient (if) vs. Necessary (only if) conditions for the following scenarios:
A is sufficient or necessary for B.
1) B has occurred. What is true about A?
2) A has occurred. What is true about B?
3) B not occurring. What is true about A?
4) A not occurring. What is true about B?
1 Sufficient: If B occurred, A is not guaranteed to have occurred.
1 Necessary: If B occurred, A is guaranteed to have occurred.
2 Sufficient: If A occurred, B is guaranteed to have occurred.
2 Necessary: If A occurred, unknown about B
3 Sufficient: If B didn’t occur, A didn’t occur
3 Necessary: If B didn’t occur, unknown about A
4 Sufficient: If A didn’t occur, unknown about B
4 Necessary: If A didn’t occur, B didn’t occur
Both Necessary AND Sufficient Condition (define)
B if and only if A
What are some features of Facts?
They describe the way things are. They don’t exist inside the world. They cannot be True/False. They are never wrong, only we are. They cannot be definitions or meanings.
What are the 2 disciplines in science? What are their differences?
Factual and Formal Sciences. Factual sciences are focused on factual verification (Biology, Psychology, Physics, etc.) and Formal sciences are focused on generating ideas and knowledge (Math, Logic, etc.)
What is C, S and D in “components of the sciences?”. The substantive framework of the sciences.
Community, Society, and Discourse:
Community is about the group of trained people. Scientists/Researchers;
Society is the group that hosts the community. Ideally they support the community;
Discourse is the contents of discussions and inquires of objects initiated by the community
What are objects?
Anything perceivable or conceivable
What is W and F in “components of the sciences?”
Worldview and Formal Background:
Worldview is the philosophical views that guide thoughts and approaches;
Formal Background is the systems and models derived from theory
What is InterK and IntraK in “components of the sciences?”
InterK is knowledge borrowed from other fields;
IntraK is knowledge borrowed from past or current members of the Community
What is P, A, and M in “components of the sciences?”
Problematics, Aim, and Methodics
Problematics are a set of problems for the Community to solve, either for curiosity or for a mission
Aim is the direction to solve Problematics. They can be basic (curiosity-heavy) , applied (mission-heavy), or technical (applying artefacts)
Methodics are orderly methods using a series of techniques for the Community to do the Aim
What are the Hallmarks of Scientific Technique?
1) They roughly produce the same results to anyone competent that replicates the research
2) They produce results that are open to investigation
3) The results are explainable through scientific theory
What does non-science roughly consist of?
The humanities and occult fields
What’s different about the non-sciences (humanities) in the D (Discourse)?
They tend to be more conceptual than physical
Is it true that science and humanities have little to no overlap?
No, there should be criteria to distinguish if that’s true.
Pseudo-science (definition)
Fake science; appears to be but is not science
What is unique about F (formal knowledge) in the occults?
It doesn’t exist, or when it is applied, it often demonstrates that things are defective
What are scientific worldviews?
Philosophical disagreements concerning belief
Realism
A belief system that some things are real, and that those things are mind-independent
Ontology
The study of being (ie. existing) and be-ing anything (eg. being hot)