Chapter 1-5 Flashcards
(44 cards)
Three Steps of Theory
-UPC
-Understand
~Watch over and over
-Predict
~See when they move backwards
-Control
-UPC is based on Data
Lex (Jus) Talionis
-Rule of Law
-Vingence
~An eye for an eye
~Tooth for a tooth
~Blood for blood
The World become COMPLEX with people of different cultures
-People can’t agree on the spiritualism or other concepts
Three levels of rules
-Folkways
-More’s
-Law
~Is smaller in terms of limitations
Folkways
-Family rules, small segments of culture
More’s
-Rules for your community
Laws
-Rules in terms for everyone
Lex Talionis Worked
-Because our world was small and as long as no one new came in then it worked
~But new people coming in would break these laws
*Sometimes without meaning to
**Social complexity Increased
Galielo
-Sun is the center of the universe
~We don’t need these elaborate gear ideas
Attributed Error
-You attribute something to something else and your wrong
~Planetary motion
*Wrong
Theories Graphic Kuhn
-Theory one takes off, and plateau then drops off
-Theory two takes over and plateau, then drops off
-Then theory three takes over, and the plateau drops off
-Finally, theory one takes off again after new data modifications
~None of the theories fully die out
Kuhn
-Pre-paradigm
~No framework
~No Why
~No How
~We observe and observe
*We understand
**We try to predict
~Tons of Pre-Theories
*One wins
-Normal science
~We all agree to use this one theory
~Standardized
*We agree on what to call things, name things, measure things
~Crime Pie
*Theory one only explains this much crime
-Crisis
~Challenging the theory
~Finding exceptions to the theory
~Find other possible theories that are around
-Revolution
~Throw old theory out
~Pick a new theory
~The cycles beck the NORMAL SCIENCE, and the cycle continues
*Theory two explains more, so it is better
Hegel
-Before Kuhn
-Hegel’s Dialectic
~Start with a Thesis
*Opening idea
~Anti-Thesis
*Rejection of an idea
~Synthesis
*Merge all ideas together
Society Changes
-Nothing works for everyone all the time
Why do We have Theories?
-To test out ideas
What makes a theory good?
-Dominant Theory
-Logical Consistency
~Has to make sense
-Scope (Broad)
~Explain things in a lot of different situations
~Broader the Scope, the better the theory
*Generalizability
-Parsimony
~Cheap
*Efficient
~Explains the phenomenon, using the fewest parts
-Test Ability
~Can you test it?
-Empirically Valid
~It has to report what it claims
~It has to measure what is claims
-Utility and Policy
~It has to be useful and guide us toward a solution
-Ideology
~Has to make a statement about the people or society or area it is working for?
~What is the theory saying?
Spiritualism Theory (Pre Science)
-Believes things that are difficult, if not impossible, that people can now see
~The theory might be successful but might not correct
*Hysteria
Demonic Possion
**Spirits float around when there are bodies; spirits enter the body through the mouth (which is why you cover your mouth)
**Causing people great pain to get out of the body to get the demon out
**Knocking people in the head to get the demon out or drilling into the head
**In Europe, there are a lot of holes in the head to release the demons out
**Drills ended up localizing the holes in the temporal lobe to let the demon out
**Removing the fisher in the brain, called the trephine, helps limit the amount of seizures
Phrenology
**Shows the different parts of the brain where certain areas could be mappable
**Musical
Positivism Theory (Glueck)
-If we can know everything, then we can predict everything accurately
~Knowledge is power
-Agrarian background
~Form and Function
-When Phrenology and Form/Function start to meet for positivism
~When a person starts to perform something that they are good and the assumption is that part of the brain would be larger and create more brain tissue
*People would feel the cranium to determine where the bump is and try to figure out what parts of the brain are stronger than other areas
-Lombroso (Cesare) MD and worked in prisons
~Could tell if they are natural criminals or people who chose to be a criminal
~We didn’t all form from the same starting point, and due to this, some people are less evolved
Are the less evolved people more likely to be criminals?
**Yes, they are less evolved
**They don’t have the same social standards as the “evolved” people (Atavis)
~Ataivism (are more likely to be criminals) 1/3 of the population
*They have heavier bones, are shorter, and have broader shoulders, muscles, etc.
**They are typically Sicelians
~Criminaloids
*Don’t appear to be criminals, but their environments drove them to become criminals
Two different types of positivism
-Idiviual poss.
~Crime is caused by something unique in an individual abnormality and pathology (environment)
~Something deficient in a biological form, but we can see it physically
~Behavior is caused by genetic factor
*(Biology is destiny)
~Crime is a concept of a moral consensus
*Dissagress with the moral consensus
~Variable that can change with socialization
~Criminals can be treated
*Meds, therapy, socialization
~Deal with an individual-level condition
-Sociological poss.
~Crime caused by social pathology (Deviant)
~Crime is a product of dysfunction in the society
*Social, economical, and political
~Behavior is conducted in social environments
~Crime is a violation of shared views of the group
*(Deviant and criminal)
~Crime varies from region to region
*Economics, political conditions, history, etc.
~Crime is part of a “healthy” society
~Crime is normal, but it is too high or too low indicates social dysfunction
ZEIT GEIST (Spirit of the times)
-ZEIT (Time)
-GEIST (Spirit)
-Change in thinking from the “normal” to change the society
Classical Theory
-One-word summary: Deterrence
-Something weakened Theory One and changed the Zeit Geist, so Theory Two took off
-One Goal
~To DETER people from committing criminal actions
-Social and environmental change
-Renaissance
~Enlightnement
Climate increased
**More food
**Less work
**Extra time
**Surplus food
**Reading
**Writing
~Changement for the common folks, not for the nobleman; instead, it was a threat to them
-Just oriented to crime control
-Cesare Beccaria
Cesare Beccaria
-Noble
~Essay on a crime and punishment (book)
*Written by the Verri brothers
*Common folks were trading books, which was a sign of wealth in the Renaissance
-He hung out with “Thinkers”
~The commoners were coming up with ideas, which were also a challenge to the noble thinkers
*Verri brothers
**If their names were on the book, they would have been in prison or executed
-The nobles would make money off the common folks because they did not know the laws
-In the book (deterrence)
~Judges cannot interpret the laws or set punishments for breaking laws
*Only can do what the law can do and
*Only the king can change the law for what the punishment is
~The law has to be written in a way that everyone can understand the laws
~The laws must be available to the public so they don’t violate the laws by accident
~Punishement must be proportionate to the crimes that were committed
*Commoners lose respect for the government, give punishments
~For the punishment to be successful, it needs to be certain, swift, and severe
*But not excessively severe
*Correct them, but not to the point of being hand-shocked
~The goal of punishment is only to control the individual, but not to over-punish the person who commits the crime
-Failed because each person has different motivations
J. Bentham
-He was a writer
-We are hedonistic people
~ Hedonistic Calculus
*We create a calculation of the consequences and the pleasures (benefits)
-The five beliefs
~Humans are pleasure-seeking and pain-avoiding creatures
~The calculations of the potential of pleasure and pain
~If you want to control crime, make the pain outweigh the pleasures
~To control the crime, one has to determine the probability of getting caught
~Deterrence of getting caught it had to exceed the original crime
*20% of getting caught of stealing $20
*Seal $100 = 100% of getting caught
**Punishment $101 paid back
-Failed because each person has different motivations
Clans
-Society has roughly 20 people to create different healthy eating
~The space where they are set up could not always handle each of the food groups
*Protein
*Veg.
*Fruit
*Grains
*Dairy
~Beach has
*Protein (fish)
**Needs 3
*Grains
**Needs 5
**Dairy
**Needs 3
*Fruits and Vegs.
**Needs 9
~Mountain
*Protein
**Needs 5
*Fruits and Vegs.
**Needs 5
*Grains
**Needs 7
*Dairy
** Needs 3
*New Module
**Dairy -7
**Grains- 2
**Fruits and Vegs.- 4
**Protein- 5
Surplus of two people
****They bring eggs, cheese, and beef to the town square, and they bring back stuff they can’t make
**They got rid of the ones that were the least successful in the original clans
****The people who got removed from the clans now hangout at the town center because of the most amount of foot traffic
-The people in the mountains wonders to the beach
~They spot the dried-out fish, and they decide to swap the fish for dairy
*One Saturday of every month, they decide to trade dairy, fish, and fruits/Vegs.
**Between three clans, there are now ten people out of work for efficient