Ch. 8, 9, 10, & 11 Flashcards
Hasty Generalization
jumping to a conclusion
Transfer
extend reasoning beyond what is logically possible
Fallacy of composition
when a claim asserts that what is true of a part is true of the whole
Fallacy of division
what is true of the whole will be true of its parts
Fallacy of refutation
Straw Man Argument
Mischaracterization and rebuttal of the argument
setting other person up for failure
Non sequiturs
Does not follow logically
Post Hoc
Does not follow temporally
Circular Reasoning
a logical fallacy in which the reasoner begins with what they are trying to end with. The components of a circular argument are often logically valid because if the premises are true, the conclusion must be true.
Simple evasion
changing the subject for no apparent reason, or bypassing a critical issue, diverts attention from the issues central to the argument
Ad hominem argument
Attacking the person not the argument (personal attack)
Shifting ground/ Moving the goalpost
Occurs when an arguer abandons his or her original position on a particular argument and adopts a new one
Seizing on a trivial point
When you locate another’s weak or indefensible argument and magnify it out of all proportion to discredit his entire position on the proposition
Forcing a Dichotomy (false Dilemma)
Choice a or choice b” but there can be more than two options
Slippery Slope
If a, then B, C, D, E, F, G
Red Herring
something, especially a clue, that is or is intended to be misleading or distracting
Appeal to Ignorance (ad ignoratium argument)
ask the audience to accept a claim solely because no proof exists to deny its validity Example: is god real or not?
Appeal to the People (ad populum argument
jumping on the bandwagon/ ask an audience to accept a claim because it is supported by majority opinion
Appeal to Emotion
pity and fear
Appeal to Authority
encourage reliance on some ultimate source of knowledge in place of reasoning as the basis of a claim
Appeal to Humor
either fail to make a serious point or reduce another’s claim to its most absurd level
Reduction ad absurdum
absurd meaning
Appeal to Tradition
ask an audience to accept a claim because it represents a customary belief or course of action
Ambiguity
unclear/ occurs when a term is used in legitimate but different senses by two or more persons involved in argumentation
Equivocation
more than just one meaning/ occurs when an individual uses a term in different ways in the context of the same argument.
Emotionally Loaded Language
generates an emotional response/ becomes a problem when we use terms that show more about our feelings on the issues tan about the rational basis from which those feelings derive or when we use emotion as the sole means to alter the belief or behavior of others
Technical Jargon
words audience does not understand/ becomes a problem when the audience is overwhelmed with too many new terms or when it is used to impress the audience or replace sound reasoning
Effect arguments
forces on one or more units of argument that call the audience’s attention to the results, outcome, or consequences of the relationship alleged by the proposition of fact
Inherency arguments
often deals with attitudes
Preempting Opposing Arguments
Consider the proposition from the opponent’s perspective
Preemptive arguments
arguments that respond to the probable objections the opponent will make before he has a chance to raise them.
Core American values
Acceptance of diversity Belief in hard work and productivity Child-centeredness Community and charity Cooperation with other countries Hunger for common ground Individualism Patriotism Pragmatism and compromise
Pragmatism
desire to get things accomplished
Values in Conflict
Generational difference Value hierarchy differences Cultural differences Societal difference worldwide
Value change
events can influence what is valued at a particular point in time by a particular culture
Engines of change (societal values)
-New information is introduced -Political and ideological change -Erosion of a value – occurs when large numbers or people resist acting in accordance with a value -Change in the operating environment