Ch. 7 Administration of the USA Flashcards
Who regulate securities-related activities that occur within their states?
Administrators
Two parts to a transaction-
1) Offer
2) Sale
What is jurisdiction?
1) The power to interpret and apply the law
2) Territorial range of authority or control
Administrator’s jurisdiction with security offerings?
Any offerings made or accepted in the state
What dictates if an offer was made in the state?
If the offer was originated in, directed to, or received in the administrator’s state
On Monday, Phillip, an agent of a broker-dealer, calls Jean, an existing client, and recommends that she purchase 10,000 shares of stock. Jean calls Phillip on Wednesday night and agrees to purchase the stock. The transaction is executed early on Thursday morning. When did the offer and/or sale take place?
Although Jean didn’t agree to purchase the stock immediately, the offer occurred on Monday when Phillip first made the recommendation.
The sale occurred on Thursday—the day the trade was executed. The execution signals the existence of a contract in which a buyer and seller agree to exchange a security for value. Under the USA, this example describes both an offer and a sale.
Mark, an agent of a broker-dealer, is located in his firm’s Connecticut branch office. Mark calls and speaks with his client who lives in New Hampshire. While speaking with his client, if Mark solicits the sale of EBH, Inc. common stock, which state Administrator will have jurisdiction?
Since the offer originated in Connecticut and was directed to and received in New Hampshire, the offer is considered to have been made in Connecticut and New Hampshire. Ultimately, since the offer was made in both Connecticut and New Hampshire, the Administrators of both states have jurisdiction over the offer to sell.
An agent of a broker-dealer, who works out of his firm’s Virginia branch office, calls a client who lives in Maryland to solicit the sale of a security. The client agrees to buy the security and arranges to meet the agent at a restaurant in West Virginia to take possession of the securities and provide a check as payment. Which state Administrator has jurisdiction in this example?
The offer was made in Virginia where it originated, but also in Maryland, where it was directed, received, and accepted. Therefore, both the Virginia and Maryland state Administrators have jurisdiction. What about the Administrator of West Virginia? The USA doesn’t recognize the jurisdiction of states where securities are simply delivered or where the payment is made. Therefore, the state Administrator of West Virginia doesn’t have jurisdiction. Remember, the determination of which Administrator has jurisdiction is based on the details of the offer, not the details of the payment or delivery of the securities.
Herman is an agent of a broker-dealer that’s located in California. To solicit the sale of a security, he sends a letter to Ms. Rose, his client who resides in Arizona. Unbeknownst to Herman, Ms. Rose is visiting her brother in Wyoming for a few weeks and is having her mail forwarded to Wyoming. Will the state Administrator from all three states have jurisdiction?
The Administrator of California will have jurisdiction since the offer originated there. Although Ms. Rose never received the offer while in Arizona, an offer was considered to be made because it was directed to and received in Arizona. The USA jurisdiction rule doesn’t recognize an offer being made in any state to which mail is forwarded. Therefore, the offer is made in California and Arizona and the state Administrator of these two states will have jurisdiction over the offer.
Jill, an agent licensed in Ohio, publishes an offer to sell bonds in a local newspaper. If the newspaper has some of its circulation in Pennsylvania, is the offer considered to have been made in Pennsylvania?
No. An offer in a newspaper may only be made in the state in which the paper is published. In this example, the newspaper is published in Ohio and, since there’s no indication that more than two-thirds of the circulation is outside of the publishing state, the offer is made in Ohio. Therefore, the Ohio Administrator has jurisdiction.
Jim lives in Texas and is watching a ballgame being broadcast by a station in Chicago, IL. At a break in the action, a reporter is shown interviewing an agent in Chicago. The agent is promoting a stock and provides his firm’s number for interested investors. Is this considered an offer to residents of Texas?
No. Since the reporter’s interview is being broadcast from Illinois, the offer is only be considered to have been made there, because the agent has no control over where the broadcast is received.
Al gives his nephew Eric 1,000 shares of stock that trade on the NYSE. Al tells Eric that the stock will help to cover the costs of his future college education. However, within one year, the company is bankrupt and the stock is worthless. Will the Administrator in Eric’s state consider this situation to be a sale?
No. Al freely gave his nephew the stock without requiring payment or other exchange in value. While it was unfortunate that the company became insolvent, since the stock was a gift and Eric had nothing to lose, it’s not considered an offer or sale. The stock Eric received was considered non-assessable.
Earl owns 1,000 shares of assessable Hawaiian Railroad (HRR) stock. The board of directors of HRR announces a $3.00 per share assessment to investors which must be paid over a period of two years. Earl doesn’t want to put more money into the investment and decides to use the stock to entice a customer to buy products from his general store. Earl tells the customer that if he spends a certain amount of money at his store, he will give him a free gift of shares of the Hawaiian Railroad Company. How does the state Administrator view this situation?
In the 1880s, many would have considered this an unethical act. However, today this practice is illegal. Under the USA, Earl is required to disclose to the customer the ramifications of accepting a gift of assessable securities. If the customer takes possession of the assessable shares, Earl will be relieved of any obligation to pay the assessment to Hawaiian Railroad—an obligation that the customer (unknowingly) will assume. For this reason, a gift of assessable stock is considered to involve both an offer and a sale.
Jim, an agent of a broker-dealer, has been accused of unauthorized trading by a customer. After a hearing, the state Administrator revokes Jim’s registration as an agent. May this disqualification be used against the broker-dealer’s registration?
Yes. The Administrator may take action against Jim’s broker-dealer if it’s determined that the firm failed to reasonably supervise Jim’s activities.
What is a cease and desist order?
demand to halt an activity immediately or risk facing legal action