Block 12 Flashcards
name the 5 big CAMs
Chiropractic Osetopathy Acupuncture Herbal medicine Homeopathy
Most used CAM
Chiropractic
least used CAM
Homeopathy
Which 2 CAMs have statutorys regulation of professionals
Chiropractic
Osteopathy
Number of people using chiropracters a year
7.5 million
Number of people using acuptuncture a year
3.1 million
Number of people using homeopathy a year
1.3 million
3 ways people can access CAMS?
Self-referral
GP referral
NHS professional referral
Most common way of accessing CAMS
Self-referral (70%)
What % of CAMs use if GP referal
17%
Ways of financing CAMs
Self
NHS
Other
What % of CAMs is financed on NHS
14%
CAMS is mostly accessed through what and funded through what?
Self-referral
Self funding
68% of CAMS is used for what kinds of problem:
MSK
Effectiveness gap =
An area where there is a lack of efficacy for treatment
What % of people believe there is an effectiveness gap for msk problems?
95%
The key principles that underline CAM use for msk problems can be shown by what model?
Biopsychosocial model
biological side of CAMs:
Manipulation Moblisation Massage Guided movement Acupuncture
Psychological aspects of CAMs
Communication
Compassion
Changing beliefs/perceptions
Promote self-efficacy
Social aspects of CAMs
Advice on adjustments
Promote back to work
NICE guidelines for lower back pain:
- Don’t offer acupuncture
- Consider manual therapy (massage, manipulation)
Why don’t NICE offer acuptuncture for LBP?
> 0.5 placebo effect with sham needling
NICE guidelines for headache:
- Consider course of 10 sessions of acupuncture for chronic tension-type headache
NICE guidelines for osteoarthritis =
- Do not offer acupuncture
- Manipulation and stretching core treatments
Why do we need research ethics?
Historical examples
Social and political trends towards increased autonomy
Legislation
Research ethics codes
Historical examples of why we need research ethics =
Nazi medical experiments
Tuskegee syphilis study
Alderhey
Wakefield
Name some legislations which are related to research ethics involving humans/human tissues
Human Rights Act
Human tissues act
Name 2 research ethics codes of conduct
Numremberg Code
Helsinki declaration
Nuremberg code comprises a set of principles concerning research with
Humans
Nuremberg code states that research with humans should be:
- Voluntary consent
- Avoid all unneccessary physical and mental suffering
- Be done by scientific qualified persons
Helsinki declaration requires what
Any form of human research to be subject to independent ethical review
Why is human research more tricky than some others?
Need for consent
Respect autonomy
Reduce harm
Which research subjects are important in research ethics?
Vulnerable - children, mentally ill, reduced capacity
6 key principles of research ethics =
- Usefulness
- Necessity
- Risk
- Consent
- Confidentiality
- Approval
Usefulness =
Is the study likely to find something new?
Necessity =
Does the study need to be done on humans/this particular group?
Risk in research should be
Minimised, outweighed by potential benefits
Consent =
Getting permission from a person before involving them in research project
Why is consent important?
- Respects patients autonomy
- Less likely to cause harm
Consent must be
Informed
Voluntary
How can we aid informed consent?
Giving patient information sheets
How to facilitate consent =
Patient info sheet Clear, avoid jargon Summary of key points Time for patient to ask questions TIme to think about/decide
Human tissues act =
Consent for stoarge and use of tissue for ‘schedules purposes’ required for tissue from living or deceased persons
Why is confidentiality important?
Autonomy
Aids good care
Reduces harm - stops info getting in hands of wrong people
- Trust
Guidlines for confidentiality in research =
- All info confidential
- Anonmyised/coded
- Stored securely
- Accessed on need to know
When is research ethics approval needed?
Humans
Human tissue
Personalised data
When is research ethics not normally needed?
Clinical audit
Service evaluations
Why do we need ethics approval?
Ensure research adheres to ethical principles Protects patients Protects researchers Minimises negligence claims Keeps integrity of profession Legal Publication.funding
Who is approval needed from?
NHS - if used patient data or facilities
Uni faculty/research ethics committee
What do RECs consider when looking at an application?
- Purpose and scientific/ethical important
- Potential risks
- Consent procedure
- Vulnerable groups involved
- Method of recruitment
- Use of patient info sheet
- Storage procedure/confidentiality
- Likelihood of achieving aims
Process of EBDM =
- Answerable question
- Search
- Critical appraisal
- Make a decision: evidence, resources, patient preference, clinical experience
PICO =
Patient, problem, population
Intervention
Control, comparator, comparison
Outcome
When you have a factor you cannot control, what type of question do you use?
PEO
PEO =
Patient
Exposure
Outcome
Study for diagnosis question =
Cross-sectional study
Study of aetiology question:
Cohort
Case-control
Study for prognosis question:
Cohort study
Study for treatment question:
RCT
Study for evaluation question:
Qualitative research
Systematic reviews =
Type of literature review that uses systematic methods to collect secondary data, critically appraise and synthesise studies.
Benefits of SR over individual primary studies =
Include all avaliable evidence
Research that is unpublished/not in English language journals
- Increases total sample size
- Meta analysis
- Indicate variation among studies
- Permit subgroup and sensitivity analysis
Subgroup analysis =
Evaluation of treatment effects for a specific end point in subgroups of patients defined by baseline characteristics
Sensitivity analysis =
Asks whether results are sensitive to quality of the research (e.g. what happens if we only look at 10 strongest trials)
Error =
Difference between average values in study population and average values in true population
Bias =
Systematic introduction of error into a study that can distort the results in a non-random way
We should assess a research study for:
Bias
Limitations
Values
Applicability
3 discrete questions when assessing study results:
Are the results valid
What are they
Can I apply them to my patient?