Block 11 Flashcards
3 factors to be taken into account in reproductive ethics =
- Parents
- Future or existing children
- Third parties (e.g. the state)
What autonomy to parents have?
Procreative autonomy
Procreative autonomy =
Parent’s wishes regarding reproductive choices should be resepected with minimal interference from the state.
What can override procreative autonomy?
Interests of future children
ART =
Assisted reproduction technologies.
Definition of ART =
Any treatment involving in vitro handling of human oocytes or embryos for the achievement of human pregnancy
Arguments for ART
- Procreative autonomy
- Psychological health of parents
- Welfare interests
Arguments against ART
- Involves destruction of embryos
- Harmful to parents: disappointment, risk of multiples
What are the restrictions to reduce the number of multiple pregnancies with ART?
<40 - 2 embryos
> 40 - 3 embryos
What do we mean by ‘interests of future children’
If, as a result of being concieved, a child is likely to suffer serious physical or mental harm, then it would be hard to justify ART in child’s best interests
What Act includes ‘welfare cirterion’
Human fertilisation and embryology act
What is a welfare criterion:
A woman shall not be provided with ART unless account of future childs welfare has been taken
Criticisms of welfare criterion:
- Fertile couples don’t have to meet this
- Research shows father isn’t needed - ammended
Fertile couples don’t have to meet the welfare criterion, what is the counter argument to this?
- Maybe they should
- Difference to between positive and negative rights. Don’t have the +ve right to conceive without state if state is helping.
What argument is used against selection of embryos with disabilities?
Right to an open future
Right to an open future =
Choices should be make to ensure child will have maximally open future.
3rd party interests in ART =
- ART is expensive
- Child may place high burden on state
What does NICE recommended for women between 23-39:
Up to 3 IVF cycles funded on NHS
PGD =
Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis
Less contentious use of PGD:
Screen for genetic abnormalities like CF
More controversial use of PGD:
Sex-selection
Desirable traits
Survivor sibilings
MRT =
Mitochondrial replacement techniques
Positives of MRT
Health benefits to child
Benefits to parents
What act allows termination of pregnancy?
The abortion act (1967) - 1990
Abortion is legal if:
- 2 docotrs
- <24 weeks
- Risk to mothers life
- Risk to mother physical or psychological wellbeing
- Risk of child suffering from serious physical or psychological handicap
GMC on conscious objection:
Respected, provisions need to be made. Refer, don’t obstruct. Must in an emergency situation
York IV criteria:
- 28-42
- 2 yr stable relationship
- 2 yr unprotected sex
- BMI 19-29
- No smoking for 6 months prior
- No other children
Why are young people particular vulnerable?
- Vulnerable to harm
- Rely on others for care
- Communication issues
- difficulty accessing services
What does the GMC say about young people
They are individuals with rights that should be respected. Should listen and take into account what they have to say. Respect their decisions and confidentiality.
Making treatment decisions: children <16
- If child is Gillick competent, can consent
- If child isn’t competent, someone with parental authority can consent
- If parent won’t consent to childs best interests, court or treat in an emergency
Those with parental responsibility have a legal obligation to:
Act in child’s best interest
Gillick competence refers to what age
Children under 16
Gillick competence:
The parental right yield to the child’s right to make his own decisions when he reaches a sufficient understanding and intelligence to be capable of making up his own mind on the matter requiring decision
Fraser guidelines refer to
Contraception/STIs/Sexual health
What are the Fraser guidelines:
- Understand all aspects of advice and implications
- Cannot be persuaded to tell parents
- There is risk of physical or mental harm without
- In patients best interest to recieve advice without parental knowlege
- Likely child will have sex with/without advice
Young people aged 16-17 consent:
- Assumed competent to consent to treatment
If someone under the age of 18 refuses treatment =
Allows treatment is consent from parents or court
Why are parents generally allowed to make treatment decisions for children?
Parental autonomy
Parental autonomy =
Assumption that parents know children the best (best interests) and will be motivated to act in best interests
Can parental autonomy be overruled?
Yes - e.g. Charlie Guard
Arguments for compulsory immunisation:
- Harm principle
- Bring about public good
Arguments against compulsory immunisation:
- Parental autonomy
- Risk harm (side effects)
Who described the harm principle?
Mill
The harm principle (Mill) =
The harm principle holds that the actions of individuals should only be limited to prevent harm to other individuals.
How does the harm principle relate to childhood immunisations?
- Prevents harm to others
- Prevents more harm than it will cause
What does, as present, the BMA recommend in regards to compulsory immunisation?
Inform and educate patients
Confidentiality and children =
Doctors owe children obligation of confidentiality. This isn’t absolute
When should you share info in regards to child’s sexual health?
- Young person too young/immature to understand
- Disparity in age/power
- Position of trust - teacher, healthcare worker
- Threat, force, pressure
- Drugs or alcohol
- Partner known to police/child protection
Medicalisation =
Process by which human conditions and problems come to be defined and treated as medical condition
Childbirth is becoming increasingly
Medicalised
Tokophobia =
Psychological condition characterised by extreme fear of childbirth or pregnancy
Are all vaginal deliveries natural?
No
‘Normal’ labour occurs with
- Spontaneous onset and vaginal delivery
- Low obstetric risk
- Sequential nature
- Progressive cervical dilation and effacement
- Progressive urterine contractions which are regular
‘Normal’ labour occurs without
Induction
Instrumental assistance
Surgical assistance
Epidural/spinal/general anaesthesia
Social model of birth =
Aim for increased choice and greater control of own labout.
Birth rate/trends
Declining
Older mothers
More single parents
More mothers in work
C-section rate
25% of births
Name a mode for the active management of labour:
O’Driscoll’s model
O’Driscolls model for active management of labour:
- Diagnosis at 2cm
- ARM (artificial rupture of membranes)
- 2 hrly vaginal exam
- Syntocinon if slower than 1cm/hr
- Personal nurse
What did O’discolls model do?
Increased rate of spontaneous vaginal births
What was the most important factor in O’Driscolls model?
Personal nurse
What influences a woman’s ‘choice’ in birth?
- Media
- Stories from family/friends
- Fear of unknown
- Fear for safety of body or baby
- Perception of the birth process
Examples of high risk pregnancies =
Psychiatric disorders Multiple pregnancies Prev PPH Borderline DMI HIV/AIDS Groups B Strep Blood disorders: sickle cell, thalassemia High Bp Lupus Maternal age >35, teenage Thyroid disease Diabetes (type 1, 2 and gestational) Alcohol/smoking/substance abuse
Fergurson reflex =
Fetal ejection reflex. Neuroendocrine reflex comprising the self-sustaining cycle of uterine contractions
Fergurson reflex is initiated by
Pressure at the cervix or vaginal wall
3 things highlighted in Maternity matters (2007) -
- Continuity of care
- More choice
- Improve access to care