Attachment Flashcards
What is ‘reciprocity’?
The term describing the idea of ‘turn-taking’, so that an infant and a mother respond to each other’s signals and each elicits a response from the other
What is interactional synchrony?
A mother and infant reflecting both the actions and emotions of the other in a co-ordinated, synchronised way
Describe the findings of two studies that investigate interactional synchrony
- Meltzoff and Moore - found an association between expression/gesture of adult and actions of babies
- Isabella et al - Found high levels of synchrony were associated with better quality mother-infant attachment (when 30 mothers and their infants were observed)
Outline the idea of ‘PARENT-infant attachment’ (according to Schaffer and Emerson)
- Majority of children become attached to mother first (around 7 months) but could also soon create multiple attachments with other family members including father - ( In 75% of infants studied, an attachment was built with father, by 18months, as children protested as father walked away)
Outline what Grossman did (2002) and the findings of his study
What he did: carried out longitudinal study and looking at both parent’s behaviour and its relationship to the quality of childrens attachments in their teens
- Quality of infant attachments with their mothers (but not fathers) was related to teen attachment
What can we conclude from Grossman’s (2002) study?
- findings suggest father attachment was less important
BUT - Quality of fathers play with infants WAS related to quality of infants attachments. This suggests father has a larger role in play and stimulation, rather than nurturing
What did Tiffany Field (1978) do and what were the findings of her study?
What she did: filmed 4 month old babies in face-to-face interaction with primary caregiver mothers and fathers, and secondary caregiver fathers
-Findings; PCF spent more time smiling, imitating and holding infants (like mothers) than SCF. This is behaviour that is important in building relationships with infants
What can we conclude from Tiffany Fields (1978) study?
- Fathers can be the more nurturing attachment figure. - - Attachment can be determined by the level of responsiveness, not the gender of the parent.
Evaluate research on care-giver infant interactions?
Strengths
- Controlled observations: well controlled procedures means that very fine details of behaviour can be recorded and later analysed
- No demand characteristics: Babies wont change their behaviour due to demand characteristics so research has good validity
Weaknesses
- Demand characteristics: caregivers may change behaviour
- Infants perspective: Don’t know whats happening from infants perspective, so dont know whether interactions have special meaning
- Doesnt explain purpose: Observations ALONE dont explain purpose of synchrony and reciprocity
Evaluate research into the role of the father
Strengths
- Research support: Grossman and Tiffany fields
- Important economic implications: Mothers may feel less pressured to stay at home
Limitations
- Different research questions: Some researchers are interested in the father as a secondary attachment figure whilst others as a primary attachment figure. So ‘the role of the father’ is hard to conclude
- Contradicting research: Researchers found that children without fathers dont developany differently
- Gender: could be that female hormones create higher levels of nurturing and therefore, women are biologically pre-disposed to be the primary attachment figure (as opposed to idea of level of responsiveness)
- Observer bias: caused by stereotypes about how father and mothers parenting behaviours
What was the aim of Schaffer and Emerson’s (1964) study?
To investigate the formation of early attachments
Describe the method of Schaffer and Emersons study.
1- used 60 babies: 31 male, 29 female (from Glasgow and skilled working-class families )
2- Babies and mothers were visited every month till baby was 18 months
3- To measure infants attachment, Researchers asked mothers questions about the kind of protest their babies showed in 7 everyday separations e.g. adult leaving room ( a measure of separation anxiety).
4- Researchers also assessed stranger anxiety - the infant’s anxiety response to unfamiliar adults
Describe the results of Schaffer and Emersons study.
- Between 25 and 32 weeks of age, 50% babies showed signs of separation anxiety towards a particular adult, usually mother (this is called specific attachment)
- Attachment tended to be to caregiver who was most interactive and sensitive to infant signals and facial expressions (showed reciprocity). Not necessarily the person who spend most time with child
Evaluate Schaffer and Emersons study (Pros and Cons)
Pros:
- Good external validity: Carried out in childrens home (real life setting) and observations made by parents (natural behaviour from children)
- High internal validity: Longitudinal study better than cross-sectional study as no participant variables
Cons
- Limited sample characteristics: Families were all from same district, same social class and city. Hard to generalise
- Study of its time: Carried out over 50 years ago. Results may differ now
- Used limited behavioural measures: Stranger anxiety and separation protest are too crude
Describe stage 1 of the stages of attachment
Asocial stage (first few weeks)
- baby’s behaviour towards non-human objects and humans are quite similar
- Baby’s show SOME preference for familiar adults (familiar adults find it easy to calm them)
- Babies are happier in presence of other humans
Describe stage 2 of the stages of attachment
Indiscriminate attachment
- more observable social behaviour (prefer people rather than objects, and recognise and prefer familiar adults)
- will accept affection from ANY adult
- will not show stranger/separation anxiety
Describe stage 3 of the stages of attachment
Specific attachment (7 months)
- Will start to show stranger anxiety and separation protest (with biological mother in 65% of cases)
- Baby forms a specific attachment with primary attachment figure, who offers baby most interaction and responds to baby’s signals with most skill
Describe stage 4 of the stages of attachment
Multiple attachments (1 year)
- Form multiple attachments with adults who they spend most time with (secondary attachments)
- In schaffer and emersons study, 29% of children formed secondary attachments within a month of forming primary attachments
Evaluate the stages of attachment theory (Cons since there are no pros)
Cons
- Ignores childs feelings and cognitions in asocial stage: Child has poor co-ordination so behaviour is difficult to observe
- Multiple attachment stage: Not clear on when this develops. Bowlby says primary first then multiple but other researchers say that multiple attachments develop from start (especially collectivists)
- Separation protest can also be shown towards play-mates but this doesnt necessary mean attachment
Describe the procedure of Harlows experiment
- Divided a clutch of goose eggs
- Hatched half with the mother and the other half in an incubator where the first thing they saw was Lorenz
- Observed their behaviour
Describe the findings of Lorenz experiment
Control group followed Mother goose everywhere whilst Experimental group followed Lorenz everywhere (Even when they were mixed)
What is imprinting?
The phenomenon where a bird species, that are mobile from birth, attach to and follow the first moving object they see