Assessment of Stuttering Flashcards
Why do we assess?
Get useful info
Understand the history and development of their disorder
To get a starting point
Set goals
What are the Principles of Assessment?
- Explore the impact that stuttering has had
- Explore the impact of previous intervention
- Identify the outcomes the person hopes for
- Create an agreement/contract about what
outcomes are attainable
What are the consensus guidelines for assessment? (Brundage et al, 2021)
- Stuttering related background
information - Speech, language ,
Temperament, and related
background information - Speech Fluency and Stuttering
behaviour - Speaker’s reactions to
stuttering - Reactions to stuttering within
the Environment - Adverse Impact associated
with Stuttering
ICF (International Classification of Functioning and Health - Yaruss & Quesal, 2004)
- Shift towards creating a distinction between aetiology and consequences
- Distinction between cause and results
- Impact on daily life
Reducing Negative Reactions (Murphy and Yaruss, 2007):
- Strategies to overcome children’s negative reactions to their stuttering
- Talking about thoughts and feelings about stuttering
- Understanding the nature of the problem
OASES (Overall Assessment of the Speaker’s Experience of Stuttering - Yaruss & Quesal, 2006)
- Quality of lifw
- Thoughts and feelings behind stutter
- Focuses on the speaker’s experience of stuttering as defined by the ICF
WASSP (Wright-Ayre Stuttering Self-Rating Profile):
Based on the ICF framework
Understand how individuals who stutter see and feel about their stuttering
How they avoid certain speaking situations
Whether they feel like stuttering puts them at a disadvantage in any way
Their personal feelings and perspectives on stutterin
Observations during Assessment:
- Frequency of stuttering is most commonly reported as % of syllables stuttered
- Variety of samples, ideally video with written consent
- Average the duration of the 3 longest stutters in a sample
- Secondary behaviors: physical movements/extra sounds/pitch rise
Discrepancies:
- Disagreements between people who stutter, professionals, and authorities on what constitutes stuttering
- Research into outcomes has focused on quantifiable behaviors
- Consistency in measuring stuttering events is essential
Persistence and Recovery:
Rates of recovery differ across studies
- recovery occurs between the ages of two and half and four and a half years (Bernstein Ratner,
2010)
- spontaneous recovery may
occur up to five years post onset (Baxter, 2015; Bernstein
Ratner, 2005; Curlee & Yairi, 1997; Blomgren, 2013).
Approximately 70-80% of children who begin to stutter will spontaneously recover
Factors influencing persistence and recovery
Predicting persistence and recovery
Walsh et al (2018)
Provide supplemental evidence of the role of known predictive
factors (e.g., sex and family history of persistent stuttering).
Provide evidence that
*early delays in basic speech motor processes (especially in boys),
* poor performance on a non word repetition test,
*stuttering severity at the age of 4 to 5 years,
*and delayed or atypical functioning in central nervous system
language processing networks are predictive of persistent
stuttering.
Onset, development and recovery
Longitudinal study by Yairi & Ambrose (2005)
- Identifies cognitive abilities for CWS are no different to CWNS
- Expressive language skills are average or above average close
to onset, although children who persist in stuttering tend to be
slower in phonological development than those who recover - Approximately 70-80% of children who begin to stutter will
spontaneously recover from symptoms within one to two
years post-onset (Bernstein Ratner, 2005; Curlee & Yairi,
1997)
What are you assessing?
- Family history of stuttering
- Language development
- Phonological development
- Motor development
- Temperament
Assessing feelings and attitudes:
- The need to work with the whole person
- Instruments such as OASES and WAASP
- The impact of self-stigma on self-esteem and self-efficacy
Key elements in Assessment/Therapy?
- Identification
- Desensitization
- Stigma and Stereotyping
- The importance of addressing the whole person
Goals of assessment may include:
Assessing confidence and participation in communication
Understanding self-perception as a communicator
Evaluating support systems
Gathering input from various sources
Handling questions, teasing, bullying, and reactions when talking
Behaviours to assess:
- Avoidance: the degree to which the PWS
successfully use avoidance behaviours in order
to give the appearance of a person with mild or
even no stuttering - Postponement: as the PWS approaches a
feared word there is often a moment of
hesitation or the speaker may use a serious of
sounds e.g. um/ah/let me see/you know - Substitution: substitution of words
- Loss of control: speaker identifies
Normal non fluency vs stuttering
Normal non fluency:
- part/whole word repetitions (<3)
- phrase repetitions
- single syllable word repetitions
Stuttering:
- Part/whole word repetitions (>3)
- Phoneme/syllable repetitions
- prolongations/blocks
- tension
- incresed awareness
- secondary behaviours