Alternatives, Mitigation and Environmental Management Plans L3 Flashcards
What are the types of alternatives?
No action Locations Scale of Project Processes or equipment Site layouts and designs Operating conditions (May be limited by commercial considerations; and should be developed in consultation with stakeholders).
Outline the Dibden Terminal Alternatives
Primary use: terminal will be the import, export and distribution of unitized freight in containers. The terminal will also be used for the import aggregates/ for roll-on/roll-off (roro) cargo vehicles and lift-on/lift on (lo-lo) cargo.
Operational area: 202 hectares.
Environmental measures: 185 hectares (including planting, landscaping and nature conservation enhancements) and agriculture.
Principal land uses within the Terminal :
Approximately 1.8 kilometres of quay providing 6 deepwater berths; cranes, storage areas, railway yards, offices, parking, landscaping
What were the landscape and design issues with Southampton Biomass Power project?
Initial design was very badly received by the local community
What were the major oppositions to Southampton Biomass?
- 125m from homes
- Just 1 mile from city centre will cover 20 acres and have buildings that are over -300ft high, thats twice the height of the civic centre clock tower
- Seen from Lyndhurst!!
- Much of the city’s air is already failing to meet air quality objectives, the pollution from the plant will make this worse.
- Emitted pollutants considered dangerous to health, specifically particulate matter that is well known to cause serious health problems.
- Biomass not GREEN- considered by FOTE, Green party and the Bio Fuel Watch.
TOO BIG TOO CLOSE NOT GREEN.
How will the redesigns fit in with the proposed consultation?
- Smaller stack, buildings etc.
- More sensitive alternatives designs
- Further consultation with community and statutory consultees
What was the marine design?
-Mimicking a container ship
-Sloping profiles
-External features echoing masts or containers
WAVE DESIGN:
- Curves soften appearance from a distance
-Flows between components
-Use of blocks of colour to break up visuals
What was the High-tech design?
- Inspired by the language of modern high technical equipment
- Highlights the industrial nature of the plant whilst providing an area of the processes that take place (e.g. red for boiler house).
What was the further Consultation?
- Community Consultation sought the local community’s views on the alternative design approaches for the scheme.
- Those local community respondents, and the statutory consultees, who selected a preferred design approach demonstrated a clear preference for the ‘Marine’ design approach (52% for Marine, 35% Wave, 13% High Tech).
Stonehenge- A303 improvement: what were the options for alternatives?
- 2.1km bored tunnel- rejected because of costs (£510m).
- Northern route (£283m)
- Southern route (£246m)
- Cut and cover tunnel (£389m)
- ‘Partial solution’ (£159million)
Describe the Stonehenge alternatives.
- Published scheme= expensive
- Northern and southern routes- impacts on monuments, landscape, bio-diversity, residence
- Cut & Cover- cheaper- potential damage on landscape & heritage; 9m high embankment.
- Partial solution- some traffic improvements and improvements to setting
- 2009: visitor centre to be relocated to Airman’s Corner- now open
- A344 now closed; grassland being restored
THERE IS NOW FURTHER PROPOSAL FOR TUNNEL.
What were the changes in 2014 directives?
Requirements should be clearer:
- A description of the reasonable alternatives studied by developer, which are relevant to the project and its specific characteristics.
INSTEAD OF:
- an outline of the main alternatives studied by the developer
What is the 97/11 directive?
Mitigation approaches: measures envisaged to avoid, reduce and is possible, remedy significant adverse effects- from Directive 97/11
What is the significance spectrum?
Look at phone picture.
What is the mitigation hierarchy?
Avoid: the impact by not taking certain action
Reduce: the impact over time by maintenance or preservation
Restore: the impact by repair or restoration
Compensate: by replacing resources
-(Plus enhance: positive changes)
What is involved in ‘Avoid’?
In the extreme, don’t build or avoid land-take
Change site layout, for example, to avoid destruction of hedgerows
Schedule lorry movements to avoid traffic congestion or late night noise