Addiction: genes and environment Flashcards
How do we know genes matter in addiction differences between individuals, compared to the environmental causation?
e. g. Smokers
- differ in amounts of cigarettes smoked per day
- some can be explained by environment (time, money)
- However: even in controlled environments, there are differences
- > genes play a role
=> genetic studies of addiction
- we need to understand both genetic and environmental factors to understand addiction
What is the simple theory of phenotype variation?
Phenotype = genes + environment
What is the aim of genetic studies?
Identify genes that contribute to variation in a phenotype
e.g. age of first use
What is the method of genetic studies?
Twin studies
- controlled experiments would be unethical
What do twin studies indicate on the variation of addiction-related phenotypes?
> Genes account for 50/70% of variation of addiction-related phenotypes
= heritability
> Environmental factors can be considered “errors”, but not always
What is the complex theory of phenotype variation?
There are interactions and correlations between genes and environments
- e.g.: no environmental factor -> no gene expression
(= no expression of predisposition)
How did Caspi and Moffitt (2006) show that environmental factors alter the expression of genes (gene-environment interactions)?
> 2 versions of dopamine receptor gene (DRD4 VNTR) in tobacco smokers
> DRD4 short:
- no differences in self-reported craving between before and after exposure to lit cigarette (environmental stimulus)
> DRD4 long:
- higher level of reported craving after exposure vs. before exposure to lit cigarette
What is a gene-environment correlation?
Genetic predisposition that influences likelihood of exposure to particular environmental factors
e. g. people with predisposition toward novelty-seeking behaviours
- not directly predisposed toward drug-taking
- BUT may be more likely to seek out drugs as novel experience
How can gene-environment relationships influence addictive behaviours in the real world?
Genetic variation is key, but the strength of genetic expression seems to depend on context
e.g.:
> Public health policies
- some US states have more restrictive smoking legislation -> difficult access to substance
- lower heritability of adolescent daily smoking
> Peer influence
- some social environments are more likely to encourage drug-taking -> easy access to substance
- higher heritability of substance abuse in these groups
Which studies allow us to know which genes matter?
Gene association studies:
- Candidate gene association studies
- Genome-wide association studies
What do candidate gene association studies consist of?
Investigating small number of genes
- based on known information
-> “usual suspects”
What do genome-wide association studies consist of?
Investigating genetic variation across the whole genome
- large sample
-> “finding needle in a hay stack”, by making needle bigger so it’s easier to find
What characterises candidate gene association studies?
> Hypothesis driven
> Focus on few, selected genes
> Genes chosen from knowledge of phenotype mechanisms
Which type of genes are chosen in candidate gene association studies on addiction phenotypes?
- Genes involved in behaviour
(e. g. dopamine reward pathway) - Genes involved in drug’s mechanism of action
(e. g. drug metabolism -> enzymes or receptors involved)
How is a candidate gene study carried out?
> Target neurotransmitter gene from controls and cases
> We calculate the number of controls and cases who have the target genetic variant
-> odds ratio
What is the procedure to obtain the odds ratio?
- Create two-way table of outcomes
- Multiply the diagonals
- Divide one product by the other
How is an odds ratio of 10 considered for a genetic variant?
Odds ratio of 10 for genetic variant is extremely large
What are the limitations of candidate gene studies?
> Circular logic
- selecting candidate genes requires prior knowledge
- > difficult to generate new knowledge of genes
> Small samples
- due to costs, genotyping studies have historically used small samples
> Lack of replication studies
- due to costs, replications are rare
- meta-analyses are often negative
- > no association between genetic variants and phenotypes of addiction studied