Adaptations & Traits 1 Flashcards
what “pushes” evolution
- selection and drift
what “persists” the push of evolution
- genetics + development
genetics (2)
small scale: population genetics
big scale: phylogeny
an adaptation
- A TRAIT or an integrated set of traits that has evolved by natural selection
adaptation
- A PROCESS in which the traits of a population change over generations (evolve), resulting in individuals that are better able to survive/reproduce
an adaptation for X
- a trait or an integrated set of traits that has evolved by natural selection involved X as a selective pressure
why should we be cautious when interpreting traits as adaptations (2)
- trait might be an adaptation, but not for the function stated
- trait might not be an adaptation at all
evidence for adaptive origin (2)
- among species, purported selective force is associated with the trait repeatedly
- phylogeny shows replicate origins of the trait, in each case in the context of the selecting condition
when are adaptations “for X” (2)
- when selection for X was involved when the trait was originally established in an ancestor long ago
- when the trait is currently being maintained by selection for X
how could we demonstrate a trait is currently being maintained or established by natural selection (4)
- variation: there is variation in traits in the population
- genetics: the variation is heritable
- fitness: trait affect function related to the proposed selective mechanism
- fitness: there are measurable effects of the trait on survival and reproduction
ancestral constraints
- traits inherited from an ancestor that are difficult to change, and which are suboptimal or limit subsequent adaptation
- eg: the crossing of our airway with the passage of food, small pelvic girdle that makes giving birth difficult
ancestral baggage: food and air pathways (3)
- our food and air pathways cross, leading to risk of choking
- our fish ancestors evolved lungs to supplement gills in the belly and below the gut, but the air is above at the water surface: the two paths crossed, but it was okay because air was only breathed occasionally
- now we require air constantly so its a bad idea that the paths cross; but, our whole developmental system is committed to this arrangement and there would be MANY mutations that would be needed to change it and genetic variation is not available for this
ancestral baggage: pelvic girdle (3)
- evolved to provide support for limbs by connecting them to spine and to each other in fish ancestor; thus, it surrounds our reproductive system and babies must pass through pelvic on way out
- no problem for eggs to fit through pelvic girdle in fish very challenging for humans who have babies with large brains and smaller pelvises to walk upright
- many mutations are needed to re-route reproductive system through the tummy; it is difficult to undo 450 millions years of commitment
what are the consequences of the reproductive system going through the pelvis (5)
- human babies must be born before fully developed, so they are dependent on their parents for many years
- mother’s pubic bones must temporarily separate
- baby’s skull must remain flexible
- during birth process, baby has to twist sideways (for head), then backwards (for shoulders)
- mother needs assistance for birth
maladaptive intermediates
- fitness valleys where the phenotype is not desirable for survival/reproduction, but must be overcome to achieve a different fitness
by what mechanism could adaptive valleys be crossed
- in small populations, selection is less effective, and genetic drift (chance effects) could cross valleys
- selection varying through time might raise the valley momentarily
lack of foresight or vision of possibilities (2)
- natural selection can see only the small amount of variation currently in the population, it cannot see distant possible phenotypes
- there are no direct paths to better phenotypes, so we may be sitting at any place in a fitness landscape
natural selection operates without any foresight (2)
- natural selection choose among alternatives that already exist
- these alternatives are generated randomly (through mutation, recombination, meiosis and sex)
why can cause an organism to be less than perfect in any given trait (4)
- ancestral constraint
- population genetic complications
- inconsistent selection
- trade-offs