A. Business models and value creation Flashcards
what was the traditional approach to understanding markets?
- markets defined as individuals who exchange products within environment governed by demand and supply
- key assumption:operate in INDIVIDUAL SELF-INTEREST
- marketing involves: understanding customer needs, segmentation, targeting and positioning and developing a marketing mix (e.g. 4Ps)
- strategies were simple:B2B, B2C etc
- use PEST(EL) to identify drivers of change and asses growth and reasons for growth
- Porter’s 5 forces to understand threats to achieving profit margins
- Porter ‘generic strategies’ to deal with 5 forces
What is PEST(EL)?
Political Economic Social Technological Environmental Legal
what is Porter’s 5 Forces model?
COMPETITIVE RIVALRY:drive down prices and force you to improve quality to compare, driving costs
THREAT OF NEW ENTRANTS:new entrants drive down prices, ‘barriers to entry’ are key
THREAT FROM SUBSTITUTES:substitutes put a cap on prices and again can drive quality improvements to stay competitive
POWER OF BUYERS: powerful customers can negotiate lower prices and higher quality
POWER OF SUPPLIERS: powerful suppliers can insist on high prices, driving up costs
-ranked low, moderate, high as they determine profit potential of the industry
What are the generic strategies to deal with Porter’s 5 forces?
COST LEADERSHIP:low cost, broad target
DIFFERENTIATION:high cost, broad target
COST + FOCUS: low cost, narrow target
DIFFERENTIATION + FOCUS: differentiation + focus
what technologies drive change?
social media IoTs Mobile devices User interfaces AI and ML Big data and analytics Cloud technologies Bio and nano-technologies-wearable tech Digital assets Bitcoin, cryptocurrencies-can make secure payments without using banks Blockchain-highly secure distributed data system
What impact and effect has tech had on traditional markets in the typical areas?
rapid changes in CUSTOMER EXPECTATIONS-more individualised, integrated experiences
NEW types of products and services-tech now strongly influences how value is created and delivered
NEW business models-Uber vs cabs, netflix vs Blockbuster
MARKET DISRUPTION-keeping up with advancements
How are emerging technologies creating an environment in traditional markets?
CONNECTED AND OPEN-new levels of trust and accountability
SIMPLE AND INTELLIGENT-advances in tech reduce and mask complexity, orgs can leverage analytics and insights to drive decision-making
FAST AND SCALABLE-as transactions increase in number and frequency and the cost of collaboration inside and outside the organisation continues to decline
what is an ecosystem?
complex web of interdependent enterprises and relationships aimed to create and allocate business value
what is a web?
network of organisations
what are the key characteristics that ecosystems share with traditional markets?
Participants: individual players or organisations
Interactions:products or services exchanged among participants
what are the 3 components of ‘participants’?
Role-behaviour within environment, what do they bring?
Reach-ability to influence environment, B2B, B2C?
Capability-key value proposition, range of activities
what are the 3 components of ‘interactions’?
Rules:explicit guidelines
Connections:elements and linkages
Course:speed and direction at which content or value is exchanged
what are the key characteristics that distinguish ecosystems from traditional markets?
MUTUALITY: deliver more by acting together for mutual benefit
ORCHESTRATION:coordination, management and arrangement of complex environments to make things happen
What is value creation?
bringing something of value into existence
what is value capture?
act or process of appropriating or allocating value
what are direct and indirect value capture?
direct: through own transactions
indirect: through orchestrator
what are the value creation/capture differences in traditional markets and ecosystems?
traditional:
value creation:incremental and focused on covering costs and gaining a return
value capture:additive, linear sequential and based on exchanges
ecosystems:
value creation:collaborative, eco created value as a whole rather than sum of individuals participating independently
value capture:networked, dynamic, everyone to everyone process of exchange
What are the 4 categories of ‘ecosystem archetypes’ i.e strategies to capture value?
high complexity:high barriers, roles scarce/hard to replicate
low complexity:low barriers, high threat from new entrants, roles easy to replicate
tight orchestration:ability to influence behaviour or actions across the entire ecosystem
loose orchestration:no individual participant has significant influence across the ecosystem
what are the 4 strategies of the ecosystem archetypes?
HORNET’S NEST: fragmented competition
LION’S PRIDE: winner-take-all
SHARK TANK: turbulent environment
WOLF PACK: collaboration
what are the challenges to regulating ecosystems?
speed of change:can take years to regulate, tech changes fast, privacy issues and consent
innovators find ‘back doors’:loopholes
ecosystems evolve:regulators must be careful not to limit small innovators when trying to control larger players
innovations cross lines of jurisdictions:who owns oversight of new players/markets
According to the World Economic Forum/Accenture analysis, what do digital customers want?
contextualised interactions:individualised products
seamless experience across channels-continue where they left off
anytime anywhere:24/7 accessibility
great service:regardless of loyalty, shop around
self service:prepared to spend time to get what they want
transparency-best value for money, protect consumer data
peer reviews/advocacy-trust reviews, trade journals
how do companies keep ahead of customer expectations?
design thinking:individualised experience
experiential pilots:behaviour of customers & reactions
prototyping:beta testing, 80% ready product released, gauge feedback
brand atomisation: widely distributed
what does the term market mean?
groups of individuals or organisations that make up the pool of actual and potential customers for their goods or services
-dictated by demand and supply
what is ‘competition’?
two parties strive for a goal which cannot be shared:one gain one loss
what is a society?
a group of individuals involved in persistent social interaction typically subject to the same political authority and dominant cultural expectations
what are societal norms?
constructed patterns of behaviour by deeming certain actions or speech as acceptable or unacceptable
what is regulation?
management of complex systems according to a set of rules and trends
what are some examples of PESTEL factors?
P:legislation, policies, import duties
Ec:international situation, domestic developments, changes in consumption
S:social, cultural or demographic factors i.e. population shifts, age profiles, change in lifestyles, education and health
T:changes in material supply, processing methods
L:changes in laws and regulations
En/ec: impact organisation has on external environment
what are Porter’s 3 generic strategies through which an organisation can generate superior competitive performance?
cost leadership:offer same quality as competitors by lower prices
differentiation: changing higher prices by offering more innovative products or with higher quality
focus: concentrating only on a small part of the market
What are the key drivers of the digital revolution?
mobile and internet penetration connected devices data analytics and the cloud user interfaces global accessibility:rising living standards in developing economies increasing urbanisation
how does Pager and Uber show benefits of transferring to another industry?
Former Uber engineer founded Pager
-from transport to healthcare for on demand health care via mobile-based services
what are the goals of business ecosystems?
- strong barriers to entry for new competition
- compete against system
- leverage technology achieve excellence in research and business competence
- driving new collaborations to address rising social and environmental challenges
- harnessing creativity and innovation to lower the cost of production or allow members to reach new customers
- accelerating the learning process to effectively collaborate and share insights, skills, expertise and knowledge
- creating new ways to address fundamental human needs and desires
what is a combination of direct and indirect value capture?
pay-to-play component and some direct component
what is the level of complexity in activities?
function of the number and diversity of participants
high:
- high barriers
- threat of new entrants is low
- participant’s role is relatively secure and hard to replicate
low:
- low barriers
- high threat from new entrants
- role is vulnerable and easy to copy
what are some examples of high and low complexity organisations?
high: nuclear power, oil exploration
low: consumables, retailing, PTs
what is orchestration?
depicts the extent of an organisation’s influence over others within an ecosystem, formality of ecosystem interactions and the degree of enforceability and compliance
tight:
- ability to influence
- e.g. regulators in finance industry
loose:
- no individual has significant influence
- absences of regulation
where is the Ecosystem Archetypes matrix found?
in the IBM Report ‘The new age of ecosystems:Redefining partnership in an ecosystem environment’
What us a high complexity, loose orchestration ecosystem?
Hornet’s Nest
- fragmented competition
- low loyalty, high demands
e.g. media and entertainment
What us a low complexity, loose orchestration ecosystem?
Shark Tank
- turbulent environment
- fend for themselves
e.g. retail
What us a high complexity, tight orchestration ecosystem?
Lion’s Pride
- winner-take-all mentality
- formal orchestration
e.g. healthcare industry
What us a low complexity, loose orchestration ecosystem?
Wolf Pack
-collaboration
e.g. utilities
What are some participants in Apple’s ecosystem?
software developers: employed and those who app develop externally
suppliers: components, organisations that assemble, accessories
retailers:Apple & 3rd party
competitors
customers
governements
etc
what are the risks and costs associated with creating value in the ‘New World’ of business ecosystems?
- boundaries and constraints have traditionally determined the evolution of business
- these boundaries are now blurry, options to create value increase rapidly
- less need for ownership and directly controlling capabilities, can share
what are the risks and costs associated with capturing value in the ‘New World’ of business ecosystems?
- now requires creation of new business models
- must be flexible and capable of rapid adaptation
- need to set clear objectives, make well-informed and integrated choices
- adopt new approaches due to tech advancements
- emphasis on designing and renewing business models
what are the risks and costs associated with creating value and society in the ‘New World’ of business ecosystems?
- participating in evolving ecosystems will necessitate new alliances to address major pressing societal challenges or ‘wicked problems’ through new solutions, generating both profits and social value at the same time
- need businesses to be concerned about social issues
- requires investors open to tackling challenge
what is an Unilever’s example of using ecosystems?
promote hand washing during spread of cholera
- knew product could save lives
- poverty issue
- NGOs, banks and schools created market for products
- marketing program with social benefits
what are the risks and costs associated with regulation in the ‘New World’ of business ecosystems?
- protect public interest
- don’t stifle innovation
- depends on regulators’ understanding of the solutions being offered
- use expert advice
- evolving regulations
what are the risks and costs associated with delivering value- supply chains in the ‘New World’ of business ecosystems?
- supply chains are increasing referred to as ‘value webs’ which span and connect whole ecosystems of suppliers and collaborators
- can reduce costs, improve service levels, mitigate risks of disruption
- reduction of corporate dependence on ownership of key assets allowed new actors to contribute
- global networks
what are the risks and costs associated with delivering value-assets in the ‘New World’ of business ecosystems?
- previously used M&Ss to accelerate entry into new businesses and markets and to build their competitive strengths
- now increased options to make use of assets without owning them
- IP protection, market transparency
- lower transaction costs
- more due-dilligence reviews
what are the risks and costs associated with delivering value-building platforms in the ‘New World’ of business ecosystems?
-can be a delivery channel
-switch to pull based so less focus on forecasting demand accurately
-cost of three core digital tech capabilities (computing power, data storage and bandwidth) relative to their performance has been decreasing exponentially and at a faster rate than previous tech
-Deloitte’s ‘The Big Shift’:period of time where foundations are reshaped and potentially changed
-
what is a platform?
help make resources and products more accessible to each other on an as-needed basis
key elements:
- governance structure, protocols
- additional set of standards to facilitate connection, coordination and collaboration
global digital tech infrastructures are enablers, not prerequisite for platform
what are the risks and costs associated with delivering value-transforming business in the ‘New World’ of business ecosystems?
- rethinking fundamentals of how a business creates and captures value was not a priority
- is now essential
- Deloitte Center for the Edge’s Shift Index suggests that they are experiencing intensifying competition, an accelerating pace of change and a growing uncertainty stemming from the increasing frequency of unanticipated extreme events
- risk of fast, large scale change