9/11 notes Flashcards
what is an argument
a series of statements that try to prove a point
what is a point the argument is trying to prove called
conclusion
what are the statements that try to prove an argument called
premises
type of argument where you prove points by providing decisive evidence for truth of their conclusion
sound deductive evidnce
arguments that dont prove their points but provide some evidence although not decisive for truth of their conclusions
cogent indcutive
provide no evidence for truth of their conclusions. have false premises or commit a fallacy
unsound/uncogent
modus ponens
1)if p then q
2) P
Therefore q
modus tollens
1)if p then q
2)not q
therefore not p
disjunctive syllogism
1) p or q
2)not q
therefore p
hypothetical syllogism
1)if p then q
2)if q then r
therefore is p then r
constructive dilemma
1)p or q
2) if p then r
3) if q then s
therefore r or s
denying the antecedent
replicates modus tolens, this is a fallacy
incorrect:
1)if p then q
2)not p
therefore not q
affirming the consequent
superficially resembles modus ponens
fallacy
mistake in form of reasoning
fallacious arguments
-promises if true is still completely irrelevant to truth of the conclusion
arguments that are based on probabilistic reasoning are called
inductive
inductive statistical argument
N% of A’s are B (where 50<N<100)
x is on A
Therefore x is B
Inference to best explanation
1)P
2)the best explanation for P is theory T
Therefore T
argument from analogy
x is F
Y is like x
therefore Y is F
appeal to authority
Inductive:authority claims make us think the conclusion is true
1)s says that P
2)s is an authority figure regarding the truth or falsity of P
therefore P
inductive generalization
every A is observed so far is F
therefore all A’s are F
strength concerns (i) sample size (ii) the likely homogeneity of all the members of the kind.
hasty generalization
fallacy
-small sample size, group is not homogenous in relevant aspects then such generalization = fallacy
small sample size is not enough to cause fallacy if the group is
homogenous