6/C - Fiduciary Duty and Ethics Flashcards
Fiduciary Duty
The Adjuster’s Responsibility: Fiduciary Duty
Adjusters have a fiduciary duty toward their employers
Fiduciary Duty: a legal relationship of confidence and trust, requiring honesty and good faith
Adjusters’ Fiduciary Duties:
- Uphold the financial interest of the principal (usually the insurer)
- Be truthful in all representations of the principal
- Ensure that the claimant receives accurate indemnification
Liasion
The adjuster is a liasion between the insurer and the claimant
- Insurers don’t want to pay more than is necessary
- Claimants want to collect as much as possible
Ethical Behavior
Adjusters must always act ethically.
Ethics: a system of moral values
Ethical Behavior: acting in accordance with these values so as to make good decisions
Ethical behavior involves:
- Honesty
- Integrity
- Fairness
- Loyalty
- Thoughtfulness
- Compassion
- Care for the rights of others
The Adjuster’s Ethical Situation
Adjusters frequently make decisions involving large amounts of money
- Even small changes in damage assessments can make a big difference in claim amounts
- These changes can affect the adjuster’s income
Adjusters looking for a long career:
- Always determine a fair and equitable settlement that abides by the insurance contract
- Avoid even the appearance of unethical behavior
Bias Towards Insurer
Ethical Challenges: Bias toward the insurer’s interests
As an employee, you want to:
- Please your boss
- Keep your job
- Perform well for people you know and may like
As an independent adjuster you want to:
- Please client insurers
- Build up your company with repeat customers
Unruly Claimants
Ethical Challenges: Dealing with unruly claimants
Traumatic events that cause losses mean that claimants are often:
- Desperate for money
- Needy
- Rude
- Insulting
Adjusters may be tempted to let the claimant’s behavior affect their job.
Always determine a fair, equitable settlement that abides by the insurance contract, without letting your opinion of the claimant get in the way.
Bias Towards Claimant
Ethical Challenges: Bias in favor of the claimant
An adjuster may want to settle a claim in favor of the claimant because of:
- The emotional appeal of catastrophic losses
- Emotional manipulation, bribes, or kickbacks offered by the claimant
- Commissions: adjusters are sometimes paid a percentage of the settlement, meaning that larger settlements make more money
Unethical Behavior
Adjusters must avoid unethical behavior.
Unethical behavior
Pursuing self-interest over the interests of others, leading to:
- Dishonesty
- Disloyalty
- A lack of concern for the feelings of others
- A disinterest in the consequences of one’s actions
- Selfishness or self-serving behaviors
Some unethical behavior is also criminal:
- Theft
- Fraud
Note: it doesn’t have to be a crime to be wrong.
Inducements
Unethical Behavior: Inducements
Inducement An action, item or promise made to someone to motivate him toward certain desired actions, including: - Cash or in-kind bribes - Kickbacks - Favors - Gifts - Trades - Sexual favors
NEVER ACCEPT INDUCEMENTS Consequences include: - Losing license - Reputation loss - Lawsuits - Jail time
Kickbacks
Money or favors offered to the adjuster in exchange for referring business to specific repair shops or contractors
- Contractors may want the adjuster to refer customers to them, in return for a kickback or commission
- Never accept kickbacks for side business deals related to adjusting
Settlement Padding
Increasing the settlement amount dishonestly in order to increase commissions
- When adjusters are paid a commission based on settlement amounts, they may be tempted to pad settlements
- Padding is unethical and criminal, and is usually discovered
Misrepresenting Coverage
- The adjuster may be aware of coverage or policy provisions that the claimant is not considering
- The adjuster must never withhold material information or misinform a claimant regarding his rights in order to save money for an insurer
Salvage Misappropriation
After a loss, salvaged property usually goes to:
- The insured
- The insurer, to recoup losses paid
Adjusters must never misappropriate salvaged property for their own use or the use of others
The Adjuster’s Responsibility
The adjuster’s job is to:
- Investigate the damages
- Evaluate the claim
- Provide a fair and equitable settlement based on the insuring contract
- Never let unethical self-interest affect behavior in any way
Fiduciary Duty and Ethics
The insurance adjuster owes both the claimant and the insurer a just outcome.
A good adjuster will:
- Not be swayed by emotions, greed or pressure
- Listen to the claimant and other witnesses and research in the claim honestly
- Base decisions on a thorough understanding of the facts