4A: Predestination Flashcards
Who was St Augustine?
An influential early Christian theologian. A powerful person in the hierarchy of the early Catholic Church
Why did Augustine state his theological view on predestination?
In response to the teaching of Celtic monk Pelagius. He was horrified by his free will theology because it seemed to diminish the power of God and make God something less than omnipotent
What does predestination suggest?
our final judgement has already been decided (it doesn’t say our actions are determined)
Latin for free will
Liberum arbitrum
What did Augustine say caused our desire to sin?
The corruption of our freedom by original sin
Augustine: “Our will can only …”
“do and desire evil”
Augustine says because the original human beings did wrong, human now find themselves born into …
a mass of sin (“massa peccati”)
What is concupiscence?
our uncontrollable urge to sin
When does Augustine say our sin is passed on to human offspring and why?
Conception: because of the uncontrollable lust that the parents experience for each other during sex
Who coined the term ‘liberium arbitrium’?
Tertullian
How did Augustine understand free will (scales analogy)?
- weakened or wounded by sin but NOT ELIMINATED
- Before Adam’s sin, man was capable of choosing freely, but after our free will is like a pair of scales that have been loaded on the side of evil
- When we weight up good and evil to make decisions, we are biased towards making evil decisions
- Only God’s grace can restore our free will to its original freedom
Why does Augustine say we can’t escape concupiscence?
Because Adam’s sun was so serious that it definitively corrupted human nature, and this corruption was inherited by all subsequent humans
How are we corrupted by the original sin?
- “All humans were seminally present in the loins of Adam”
- Adam’s fall away from God towards material temptations brought concupiscence into his nature; even into sex
- Sex became concupiscent, meaning all humans are created in concupiscence
What did Augustine believe God wanted to do with our human nature?
heal and restore it to its original holiness and full freedom; he wanted this for no reason other than His loving will
How did Augustine view grace?
As a gift, not a reward: humans can never deserve it
If grace is up to God, what does this imply?
- It is up to him whether or not to bestow it
- Those chosen to receive the grace of having their sinful secondary nature erased as the “elect”
- The not chosen are “reprobates” and remain in the massa peccati; but this doesn’t necessarily mean God has predestined them to damnation
What are the problem’s with God being the sole decider of who receives grace?
- He isn’t obliged to save anybody, only who he wants to save
- Therefore there are some people who God doesn’t wish to save
- This means Christ died only to save those God wills to save
- If Christ died for everybody, and God doesn’t want to save everybody, we could all expect His grace just by the fact we are human
Why does Augustine believe God’s grace is irresistible?
- Because his grace rebalances the scales and removes the bias towards evil, freeing the liberum arbitrium
- Heals human nature from concupiscence
- God doesn’t force anyone to be good; grace doesn’t influence choice but the experience of His grace is irresistible so it is impossible to turn away
- Having a healed and free liberum arbitrium means the person will now make good choices
- The elect will resist sin and be saved because this is what their healed human nature will direct them towards doing
What did Pelagius believe about original sin and free will?
- Believed the original sin was a cop out
- We have the power and free will to obey God or not all by ourselves
How did Pelagius say we need to mature into God’s image?
by accepting the responsibility of our free will
What does Pelagius say is the only purpose of God’s grace?
To show us what the law that we have the freedom to obey is, and then help us to do it: it can’t make the choice by us
How did Pelagius disagree with Augustine?
- Argued that Adam and Eve’s sin had not caused punishment for humanity
- Augustine’s argument leaves no room for moral choice and responsibility
What did Pelagius say about the Original Sin?
- He says God is fair; it is unfair for humans to be punished for what Adam did
- Adam’s sin only affected himself; human nature was only MODIFIED by sin
- “They themselves had to make a free will decision whether to eat or not to eat”
What did Pelagius say about the Fall?
- Claimed deeds rather than faith can lead to salvation
- Baptism is not needed for purity
- Evan pagans can go to heaven
What does Pelagius say about the Gospels?
- Matthew 5:48 suggests we have a natural capacity to seek God
- God created us free; we have the freedom to not sin
How did Pelagius define grace?
A gift from God given to everyone at birth
What is grace of revelation?
- shows us the way to follow
- God’s guidance for us
What is the grace of pardon?
- God grants forgiveness to those who freely repent and do their best to act well
- Knows who will receive