4.0 Legal Flashcards
Stop/Detention and pat down procedures
Consensual Contact
- Encouraged to initiate consensual contacts with individuals in the communicty
- gain beat knowledge and community information
- do not involve the “seizure” of persons (4th amend purposes)
- do not need “reasonable suspicion” or P/C
- officer has a right to be in place where contact is initiated.
- conversation which does not imply detention or arrest
- reasonable person test: would a reasonable person under teh same or similar cicrumstances beleive that he or she is ree to leave?
Reasonalbeness:
- It is not what the person conacted beleives or should believe-it is what a reasonable person in same circumstances would beleive
- if UNREASONABLE, then the person contacted is being detained and absent sufficient legal cause to detain the person, it is an illegal detention.
Officer Conduct:
- conduct during consensual contacts= person my not be halted, detained, or frisked against their will.
- may not be required to answer qustions or to coperate in any way if they do not want to
- refuse to dcooperate, must be permited to go on their way, unless officer has reasoalbe suspicioun or p/c
- the person my be kept under surveillance, if necessary
- since the contact is consensual, the persons contacted amy be innocent of wrogdoing, officers should act courteous
Reporting:
- reporting consensual contacts-documented on ODJ if no enfocement
- if enforcement - JCR<,arrest, det report, FI TW, Cite
Stop/Detention and pat down procedures
Detention
- aka “stop”
- officers using authority to comple a person to halt, remain in certain place, or perform some act
- investgative stop = detention
- allowed so an officer amy have reasonable time to investgate a person’ possible involvement in acutal or perceived criminal activity
- allows to make an informed decision to arrest or relaease
- if the officer told the person they are not free to leave = detention
- if officer reasonalby suspects person has committed, is committing, or is about to commit any criem = authority to detain exists
-both ped and persons in eh may be detained
Reasonable Suspicion:
more than a hunch not probable cause
Stop/Detention and pat down procedures
Factors to consider when determining stop/detention
Factors to consider:
appearance-
fits the desc, suffering from recent injur, UTI,
Behanivor/action-
-fleeing from acutal or possible crime scene
-behanving in a manner indicating poss criminal conduct
-overheard making incriminating statemetns
associateing him/herself with someone officer -detmeirnecd to be reasonably suspiciou
Prior knowledge:
- arrest or conviction record
- known to have committed an offense similar to the one that just occurred or is about to occur
Demeanor:
-answers are evasive, incriminating, excessively nervous during consensual encounter
location of the detntion:
near the location of known offense soo after its commission
-area known for a particular cirminal activity type of activity that person is thougth to have committed is committing or is about to commit.
CANNOT BE BECAUSE OF “HIGH CRIME AREA”
time of day:
- unusal for people to be int hat area at tha t particular time
- time of day or night druing whih the suspected criminal activty usuallly occurs
Police training and experience:
- similar tot he pattern follwed in particiular criminal offenses
- emergency cicurmstances : public safety may be endangered if inv action is not taken
source of Information:
- reliabiltiy of source
- if oficer knows the informatn
- supplied accurate info in the past
- how they came by this info
- corroborated?
BE PREPARED TO DOCUMENT factors that led to reasonable detention
Stop/Detention and pat down procedures
Detntion v Arrest
-least intrusive means should be used during a detention
Ccould be arrest and not detention if:
- numerous officers involved
- display of weapons
- use of handcuffs
- person is placed in back of patrol car
- encounter is in non public setting
- officers authooritative manner and actions imply that compliance is complelled
- officer did not advise the detainee of his right to terminate the encoutner
**use of handcuff or weapons, placing in patrol car do not AUTOMATICALLY make the contact an arrest based on circumstances
Stop/Detention and pat down procedures
Duration of detntion
- a person stopped may be detained for a reasonable amount of time
- length of time necessary to determine if person shuold be arrested or released
Stop/Detention and pat down procedures
Scope of the detntion
-on the scene investigation is authorized by law during a detention
THERFORE- officer should not remove detainee unless
-consent
-p/c to arrest
-v cannot be brought to the scene of detention
-movement is for a reasonable distance to help with investigation
-safety of the officer or the detaineee
Stop/Detention and pat down procedures
Explanation to a detained person
- should act with restraint
- plain clothes shall identify themselves as soon as it is appropriate
- purpose for the stop, unless would jeopardize investigation
Stop/detention and pat down procedures
questioning the detained
- direct questions such as name, date of birth, etc
- subject may not be compelled to answer
- even that of identity
- not necessary to advise of constitutional rights until under arrest or has become coercive and not brief and casual
Stop/detention and pat down procedures
effect of refusal to cooperate
- refusal to answer questions does not establish p/c
- helps to determine if further investigation should be continued
- a person who flees during a lawful det may be arrested for 148pc if it delays/obstructs inv and detainee knew he was being detained by an officer
Stop/detention and pat down procedures
use of force during detention
-comply with dep 1.04
Stop/detention and pat down procedures
reporting detentions
-“contact” officer shall complete the FI and enter into ODJ
-if detained away from the scene, later released without booking, contact officer = “detention only”
report documenting pc, consent, or reason for movement
-if need photographs/fingerprints -person may be detained for a reasonable amount of time to obtain equipment to facilitate photographs/fingerprints
-to move a person for photo/fingerprints, must get consent
-if no consent, officers MUST NOT MOVE subject
-if Juv, must notify parents
Stop/detention and pat down procedures
Pat downs
- limited search for the purpose of FINDING WEAPONS
- pat down is not a search for evidence or contraband
- may pat down a person who has been detained if reasonably suspects person has a weapon
Stop/detention and pat down procedures
Factors to consider for pat downs
- person’s appearance - baggy clothes, presence of object
- person’s actions-furtive movement
- prior knowledge-of having weapons
- location-sufficiently isolated to limit imm police response
- time of day-darkness inhibits visibility
- police purpose -detention may be for a suspected armed subject
- companions-multiple subjects detained and at least one of them has weapon
Stop/detention and pat down procedures
Reporting pat downs
- be prepared to articulate facts leading to pat down
- “in fear of safety not sufficient”
Stop/detention and pat down procedures
weapons and other seizable items
- if believe it is a weapon, can retrieve object
- if don’t believe item is a weapon, instead believe the item to be contraband, officer has p/c to believe a crime is being committed in presence,
- 10-16 and retrieve item.
Stop/detention and pat down procedures
photographing guidelines
- must be connected to an inv of crime or an arrest
- may with take photo with consent in conjunction with FI
- if Juv, notify parents
- Officers ARE NOT TO KEEP photographs for the purpose of personal intelligence files or for personal use
4.02 Eyewitness identification
Definitions
- Curbside line-up (show up)
- line up
- photographic line up
4.02 Eyewitness identification
Attorneys at line-ups
- subject entitles for lawyer at live line-up whether charges filed or not
- advised of right to an attorney present (etc.)
- one day before line-up, re-contact s to see if he secured an attorney. If not, contact office of pub defender
4.02 Eyewitness identification
To contact public defender
- notify the need of a defense attorney for the live line-up
- contact DA liaison
- if suspect’s lawyer does not appear, contact DA handling case before proceeding with live line-up
- s may waive right to an attorney at line-up
4.02 Eyewitness identification
Role of Public Defender at Live line-up
- permitted to observe, but not control or obstruct
- permitted to be present at time witness’ conclusion statement
- attorney should be instructed to remain silent
- attorney may speak with any witness after the line-up, if witness agrees to speak with attorney
- witness should be told no obligation to speak with def attorney
4.02 Eyewitness identification
live Line-up Procedure
- all line-ups should consist of at least four persons in addition to suspect
- similar physical characteristics
- clothing should wear similar contact
- don’t make s distinguishable
- all should utter same words if needed
- photographs/videotapes should be taken of all line-ups
4.02 Eyewitness identification
Photographic line up
- except in rare occasions-should be conducted by investigators only
- at least 4 photographs in addition to S
- record of each photograph for reconstruction at trial
- mug book is appropriate when no particular suspect
- if suspect is selected, a record of all pictures w viewed mst be made and included in report
- NO RIGHT TO AN ATTORNEY at any pictorial id procedure at any time
4.02 Eyewitness identification
Curbstone show up line up
- vic/wit SHOULD ALWAYS be brought to view suspect
- THREE EXCEPTIONS:
1. prob cause to arrest
2. Consent
3. Impracticality-wit injured/availability of officers is limited
4.02 Eyewitness identification
Suggestibility
Never tell witness-
- you think you have the person who committed the crime
- v’s property ws in su’s poss
- s made admissions or confessed
- person observed is suspect
Always tell witness
- keep an open mind
- person may not be among those present
- -not to talk to any other witnesses
4.02 Eyewitness identification
Officer’s conduct/witness conduct
- do not say or do anything during the line-up that would draw attention of any witness to suspect
- if more than one wit is to view the line-up, must view separately
- don’t permit a witness to hear the other’s statement
ONE ON ONE CONFRONTATION
-automatically suggestive, but courts have allowed due to precedents
4.02 Eyewitness identification
NOT ALLOWED
-not upheld if too suggestive
-the amount of time witness viewed s
-degree of attention at time of crime
-amount of time lapsed between crime and lineup
-physical set up of line up
-accuracy / detail of wit description prior to line up
-certainty of wit id at lineup
-
4.02 Eyewitness identification
suggestiveness after ID
- must avoid any conduct after id that might be ruled suggestive
- do not tell witness picked the right or the wrong one
-
4.02 Eyewitness identification
Curbside line up for / arrest report
- include in report:
- lighting, location, how is was conducted
- victim was driven,
- victim’s statement during line-up
4.03 -Admonishment Procedures
CUSTODY
- Miranda only applies to being questioned in custody
- s deprived of freedom-not free to leave
- personally aware of lack of freedom or reasonably believe that it exists
-formally arrested Custody without an arrest if: where questioning take place when questioning take place how many officers present lack of suspect's friend/relatives how long questioning lasts how accusatory - questions are more custodial than intended to clear up situation info the officer has-the more pc to arrest, the more the inv has focused on s
objective indications of custodial
- handcuffing, moving, firearm, locking them inside interview room
- if officer says he is being detained and free to leave, may not be custodial
- during detention, not free to leave, but not under arrest
4.03 -Admonishment Procedures
Admonishment NOT REQUIRED
- person stopped under suspicious circumstances (detention)
- traffic citations
- over the phone
- from those who volunteer statements (except if officer questions to bring out further statements)
- when engaged in “on the scene” questioning -fact finding process
- no interrogation
**if not going to question, DONOT ADMONISH
4.03 -Admonishment Procedures
Admonition of felony suspects in custody
- should not be warned of rights (except juveniles) unless an interrogation I to follow immediately or in the vey near future
- if admonished and not interrogated, report should indicate why
- if suspect is likely to waive their rights, questioning should begin as soon as possible
- questioning should be deferred as well as admonishment if officer is unfamiliar with case.
4.03 -Admonishment Procedures
Procedural Steps in Admonishment
-read PD_145
Waiver of these rights with Q1 and Q2
-answers should be exact words
4.03 -Admonishment Procedures
Non-waiver
- if wans to remain silent-stop questioning
- if wants attorney - stop questioning
- if Juv requests attorney or parents-stop questioning
4.03 -Admonishment Procedures
Waiver
- if they now want to speak or does not want an attorney, READMONIS
- reluctance to answer particular questions does not constitute invocation to remain silent
- right needs to be clearly exercise
- avoid coercive questioning
- spontaneous, voluntary statements -they should be allowed to continue
4.04- Domestic Violence
Procedures
Property Crimes
- area stations will handle all dv prop crimes (594, 459, 487, 10851) EXCEPT:
- v/w observed the s commit the prop crime and documented history of dv involving the s and v
- prop crimes committed n conjunction with a dv incident that included threats of violence
Juvenile S’s:
- area stations will handle all DV crimes involving juv suspects
- DV unit will handle all other f/u investigations
- arrests for DV inc
- SDPD encourages physical arrest if pc and legal authority
- Dual arrests are DISCOURAGED
- if felony has occurred, physical arrest shall be made
- if misd has occurred in officers presence, a physical arrest shall be made
PC836 - amended to allow officers to arrest for selected misd not in officers presence
- Offcers SHALL make arrest for misd DV, TRO violations, when pc exists eve if not in officer’s presence
- must arrest as soon as P/C arises
- when officer is called a dv call - it is mandatory that the officer make a good faith effort to inform v of right to make a citizens arrest
- advisement should be made out o sight of s and not dissuade a v from making a private person’s arrest.
-The following factors SHALL NOT influence officer’s course of action in DV incidents:
-relationship or marital status of s and v
-whether or not the s lives on the premise
-existence of lack of tro
(ETC.)
- NO CITATIONS will be issued for misd DV
- if it I necessary to release suspect with M Cite-supervisor must be contacted and must approve the issuance (ex: admitted in hospital for serious injury)
4.04- Domestic Violence
Investigation of DV Cases
- complete thorough investigation
- if no other violation of law, complete 13730PC DV Incident only
Firearms:-requires office to ask about firearms if necessary
-12028.5 = authority to take f/arms into temp custody
-give receipt
-held for at least 48 hours
-be made available for return after 48hours, unless held as evidence
-if 10-16 for 422, weapon can be impounded as evidence
-firearms not recovered aftr 12mos shal be treated as a nuisance
-PD is allow to destroy weapons if reasonable cause to believe the weapon would likely endanger V
-Gun desk has the responsibility to notify the gun desk
-
4.04- Domestic Violence
Submission of DV cases
- All reports are to be submitted BEFORE EOS
- all suspect n custody cases will be submitted prior to the EOS
4.04- Domestic Violence
DV Unit
- DV Unit Shall be contacted n all cases involving 664/187, 245, firearms,
- On call sgt SHALL be contacted if:
- serious injury, v admit to hospital, firearm was used, deadly weapons used, v was raped, 207 or extortion, child abduction, v or s employed by law enforcement , v or s employed by the City, case has media potential,
ANY OTHERSITATION, THE OFICER WILL CALL SGT FIRS BEFORE CALLING HTE ONCALL DV SGT.
4.04- Domestic Violence
Victim Assistance
- 415 pp for reasonable amount of time
- if tro in place, restrained will not be taken to property, in this situation, release of property is a function of the court
- shall assist in arranging to transport v to alternate shelter
- Marsy’s car, vic assist pogram
- be familiar with types of court ordered prot orders and enforcement procedure