4 Cost Management Flashcards
What are the 8 main factors influencing cost?
1 - Economic + Political 2 - Env. 3 - Building Type 4 - Owner / Client 5 - Proj. Rqrmts 6 - Proj. Delivery 7 - Owner Timetable 8 - Other
What about an economic / political climate might influence costing? (4)
1 - Inflation (follow trends / carry allowance)
2 - Market Conditions (ex: low demand = high cost)
3 - Other (unions, exchange rates..)
4 - Political and Social Climate (ex: approval often affected by election timing)
How might Environmental factors influence cost? (3)
1 - Site Characteristics (ex: adj. buildings, odd topo or soil, contamination or removal)
2 - Weather / Season (ex: Hoarding = $$$)
3 - Location (ex:urban = $$$ vs suburban and remote=$$$)
How might Characteristics of client owner influence cost? (2 examples)
- Expert clients (COMMERCIAL / INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPERS)
- expect at or below budget targets $ - INSTITUTIONAL & GVNMTS
- they impede competition, which drives prices up $$$
- bureaucratic, long payment time to contractor
- high standards for long life, insurances, bonds
The architect should consider adjusting the estimate based on the type of organization the client represents.
How might the functional program influence cost? (5)
- If client changes idea & modifies the scope of project.
- Technological evolution, new laws.
- Lack of information.
- Changes in employees, users of building, etc.
- New stakeholders.
The client must confirm program and clarify any unclear requirements. The Arch. must make client aware of additional fees after review
How might the type of construction delivery influence cost? (main 4)
Some construction methods are longer, more expensive, etc.
1 - Stipulated Price Contract (Design Bid Build)
• price known before build but many ‘extras’ (changes)
2 - Construction Management
• adds $ for another consultant (and redundancy in services may occur)
• but provides careful monitoring of costs
3 - Design Build
• cost benefit analysis done early
• owner commits to program early
4 - Public Private Partnership (P3)
• ‘best value’ not always achieved (low cost = driver )
• shifts risk to private sector
What sort of REGULATIONS might influence cost? (3 examples)
- Bureaucratic requirements
- planning / zoning regulations - Multiple occupancies in same building (Bldg Code)
- REMEDIATION standards for hazardous material (asbestos)
- Recycling & evacuation of debris fees (LEED)
What are the 4 CLASSES of Cost Estimates and at what phase of an architectural project would each occur?
D - Pre-design (Pre-D)
C - SD
B - DD
A - CDs
Define (2) this method of costing and list pros/cons:
CLASSES of COST ESTIMATES
Class A - Construction Documentation
Class B - Design Development
Class C - Schematic design
Class D - Functional program
- arranged by MASTERFORMAT
- used by CONTRACTORs for tenders
+ easy to retrieve info
+ info CURRENT / RELIABLE
- rqrs estimator with DESIGN+CONST. experience
Define the ELEMENTAL COSTS method of costing and list pros (2) / cons (1):
Tries to give initial cost of building, based on different building structures (foundations, walls, structure). The costs are established from previous jobs. The building structures can be seen as “assemblies” that represent unitary costs more or less equivalent once evaluated over the total cost of the building.
+ process can proceed without drawings
+ useful during DESIGN
- hard to VERIFY
What is AREA costing?
Who uses the AREA (cost/m2) method of costing? What stage of design?
List pros (4) / cons (2)
Calculate based on area of building. Each component’s cost is easy to calculate.
• used by architects for general costing at Pre-design phase
+ floor area EASY for all building types
+ EASY for all to understand
+ easy to calculate
+ simplified historic info
- does not account for unique conditions
- simplistic, can be misinterpreted
What is the VOLUME (cost/m3) method of costing used for (3):
Calculate based on volume, rarely used. Used as double check against other costing.
- warehousing / refrigeration
- multi-storey buildings where area calculations are not adequate
What is and when is the UNIT (cost/bed, seat, etc) method of costing used:
Calculate based on bed /seat etc. Uses simplified historic values. Use at early design stages (preliminary budgeting) as quick reference.
Only to use if projects are similar. The circumstances, location & date of construction can change the historic value, even if projects look identical.
What are the 6 steps of value analysis? Should the architect perform it? When should it be done?
1 - COLLECT data 2 - functional ANALYSIS (how is it performing) 3 - ALTERNATE options 4 - ASSESS feasibility of options 5 - RECOMMEND 6 - IMPLEMENT + monitor
This is NOT a basic architectural service. It should be done EARLY in the design process - schematic design phase.
When using Hanscomb Yardstick for Costing Estimates, what can you assume about construction type and the labour force?
It excludes residential construction, and the labour force is unionized.
(unit pricing typically 20-30% less for residential)
Is Hanscomb Yardstick for Costing a good resource for contractors when bidding?
No, it is best for estimating costs during design.
The costs and rates in Hanscomb yardstick for Costing reflect the following factors if compared between the different locations: (4)
- Building code requirements
- Local market conditions
- Differential labour productivity
- Supervision and management costs
When referring to the GROSS building costs in Hanscomb Yardstick for Costing, do the numbers define local or national conditions?
While the Current Market Conditions are represented for 8 major cities across Canada, the gross building costs are based on the Toronto market + must be adjusted for local conditions.
When should composite unit rate be used?
During early design phases for Elemental Cost Estimates. Much faster than current market pricing.
The CIQs (Canadian Institute of Quantity Surveyors) List of Elements for Composite Unit Rates are grouped into A, B, C, D, and Z. What type of elements or group of pricing information is in each of these 5 groups.
A - SHELL (A1 Substructure, A2 Structure, A3 Exterior Enclosure
B - INTERIORS (B1 Partitions + Doors)
C - SERVICES (C1 Mech, C2 Elec)
D - SITE + ANCILLARY WORK (D1 Site Work)
Z - GEN RQRs + ALLOWS (Z1 Gen rqrs + fees, Z2 Allowances)
Which method of estimating is best suited to the current market rates found in Yardsticks?
Classes of Estimates - arranged into Masterformat divisions.
What do the solid and dotted lines in the current market rates of Yardsticks represent?
……….supply only
____install only
When using the current market rates found in Yardsticks is it safe to assume that provincial and federal taxes are included?
Provincial taxes are included where applicable (not Quebec) but GST/HST are EXCLUDED.
Who might use the Gross BLDG. Costs found in Yardsticks?
Architects typically use the Area Cost method with Gross BLDG. Costs for very quick estimates.
What 3 costs are shown for each building type in the Gross BLDG. Costs found in Yardsticks.
Low
Ave
High
In Yardsticks, how is the information in the Gross BLDG. Costs organized?
By type and then by element
A shell, B Interiors, C services, D Site+Ancillary
What type of elements has been excluded from Gross BLDG. Costs in Yardsticks?
Site work - due to wide variation.
When critiquing a client’s budget VS the PROGRAM what should the architect consider? (5)
(enough $?) 1 - cost/m2 2 - SME systems 3 - Proj. Delivery Method 4 - Unusual Site Conditions / Location / Weather 5 - Client's Vision + Aspirations
When critiquing a client’s budget VS the CONDITIONS OF COMPLETION what should the architect consider? (4)
1 - Pre-Design / Programming
2 - Coord of SME
3 - Commissioning
4 - Post Project Evaluation
What is the CPI and who typically publishes it?
Cost Price Index, published by Gov. Agencies + Private Companies
(shows trends)
Define Construction Costs.
HARD Costs: materials / labour (excl. land purchase)