3.6.1- Government intervention Flashcards
What is the name of the department that promotes competition in the UK?
The Competition and Markets Authority
What does the CMA do?
Promotes competition, investigates mergers, enforces consumer protection law and brings criminal cases against individuals who participate in cartels
When is a merger investigated?
If it will result in a market share of over 25% or if its large already (>£70m in assets)
Why should mergers be blocked?
-will increase prices and decrease quality due to decreased competition
-protects choice
-protects pluralism
-stops monopoly/monopsony power
What is pluralism?
Multiple views on society
Why should mergers happen?
-may lead to better R+D and innovation due to combined resources
-economies of scale
-synergy
-more efficient
-smaller firms merging can create challenge to existing dominant firm
-increased availability
-vital expansion strategy for small firms
What is an example of a merger taking place?
Tesco’s takeover of Booker’s in 2017
What is an example of a merger not taking place?
Ryan Air and Aerlingus in 2010 as they would control more than 80% of all Europe flights from Ireland
What is the evaluation of the CMA?
-difficult to detect and prove anti competitive behaviour
-can be regulatory capture
-legal action is expensive and time consuming
-asymmetric info
-CMA staff can be ineffective due to high staff turnover
What is regulatory capture?
When regulators are influenced by the interests of the firm rather than the public
Why do monopolies need regulation?
-high profits
-high prices
-low investment
What is an example of a monopoly with low investment?
BP received £23 million profit in 2022, but paid 14 times as much to shareholders in dividends than it did on low carbon activities
What are the types of price regulation?
-max price
- RPI-X
-RPI +K
What is RPI-X?
A max price is risen by inflation minus the expected efficiency gain
What is RPI+K?
A max price is risen by inflation plus the additional capital spending that the regulator insists must take place
What is an example of an industry that is involved in RPI+K?
The water industry due to burst pipes and leakages
What are the evaluation points of price regulation?
-hard to work out k/x
-asymmetric information
-gov failure if incorrect
-may be regulatory capture
What profit regulation is there?
Rate of return capping
What is rate of return capping?
Allows coverage of a fair rate of return on capital investment, but caps profit past that
How do you work out rate of return capping?
net profit/capital employed * 100
What is the evaluation of rate of return capping?
-firms wont want to maximise profit, so will spend elsewhere like being x-inefficient or increasing wages
-asymmetric information
-incentive to employ too much capital