2a.3 Flashcards
Similarities of the 3 conferences?
-They all failed.
Differences of the 3 conferences?
- the number of delegates had dropped in the third.
-The second was the most well attended.
-Congress only goes to second.
-
Who attended the first round table conference?
who did not
Lord Irwin opened the conference and was chaired by Ramsay Mcdonald.
- 16 delegates from all 3 British political parties.
- 58 Indian political leaders representing every shade of opinion.
- 16 representatives from the princely states.
-NO CONGRESS
Who attended the second round table conference?
Similar mix of delegates to the first.
- Due to the Gandhi-Irwin pact, Gandhi was the sole representative of congress.
- Muslim league represented by Iqbal, Aga Khan, and Muhammad Jinnah.
- Master Tara Singh represented the Sikhs
- Dr Ambedkar represented the untouchables.
When was the first round table conference?
November 1930
What did they discuss at the second round table conference?
-They all demand separate electorates (Muslims vote for Muslims).
What did they discuss at the second round table conference?
- They all demand separate electorates (Muslims vote for Muslims).
- As they were dominated by these minorities nothing was achieved.
When was the Third Round Table Conference?
Held in Nov-Dec 1932
What was discussed at the Third Round Table Conference?
They discussed franchise, finance and the role of princely states.
Why did the round table conferences happen?
One of the recommendations of the Simon Commission was that a conference of all interested parties should be held in order to discuss possible constitutional reform .
Why did the Round Table Conferences fail?
- The situation in Britain- In Aug 1931, the Labour gov, resigned and were replaced by the Tory coalition Gov. The coalition Gov was facing problems they thought were more pressing than India.
-New individuals- The new secretary go State for India, Sir Samuel Hoare (Adapt the National Gov) has more reservations about self-governance for India than his predecessor.
These reservations were shared by many tories eg Churchill who set up the Indian defence league (50mps) who made no secret of the fact that Indians should remain subordinate.
Congress- Not represented at the 1st conference. At the 2nd conference, Gandhi succeeded in Alienating Muslims and other minority groups.
Disagreements between Indian groups- eg over separate electorates.
How did Britain respond to the failure of the ROUND TABLE CONFERENCES.
4 Jan 1932- Gandhi was imprisoned.
Congress outlawed.
All members of Congress Working committee were rounded up and imprisoned.
Youth organisations were banned.
Over 80,000 Indians (mostly members of Congress) were imprisoned within 4 months.
The communal Award (16 August ) Sikhs Christians
How did Gandhi respond to the Communal award
Boycott of British goods.
Responded to the Communal-Award with fast-unto-death . Therefore blackmailed Britain.
Met with British at Yervada (Poona) late 1932. Here they agreed that in essence, separate electorates would end. However, voting would be for everyone .
Everyone got the option for each electorate but separate seats would still exist.
Gandhi declared hat untouchability should be abandoned by law (took 20 years).
Who was Joseph Rudyard Kipling?
He worked as a journalist.
Vice-president of the Indian defence league.
He had an antipathy
Who was Sir Samuel Hoare?
Secretary of State. (Link between British Raj and Monarchy).
Suggested that India had not done enough to push for Indian independence since government of India act.
who was Lord Willingdon
Governor of Bombay,
Did not like Gandhi, became Viceroy 1931-1936.
Thought that Gandhi’s ideas of independence were ‘dangerous’.
Who was Winston Churchill.
Did not accept equalities between races.
Mocked Gandhi
Member of the India defence league.
What were 3 things that were decided at the 1st Round Table conference?
- India would be run as a type of dominion.
- The dominion would be run as a type of federation that would include the princely states as well as the 11 British provinces.
- There would be Indian participation at all levels of government.
What was the impact of the princely states representatives?
- They supported the concept of dominion status on the same basis as Canada and Australia which strengthened the case of the labour government.
- This freed the Labour Party from opposition against the dominion status.
What was the result of the second round table conference?
Nothing- they could not agree on a workable constitution.
Who attended the third round table conferences?
46 delegates
None from British Labour Party or congress.
What are the three ways that the 3 round table conferences failed?
- The situation in Britain
- Congress
- Divisions over separate electorates.
How did the situation in Britain cause the round table conferences to fail?
- In August 1931, the first labour government resigned and Britain was facing a depression, unemployment and the collapse of the economy. So they had more pressing issues.
- The new Secretary of State for India Sir Samuel Hoare, had more reservations about self-government and India than his predecessor.
-Winston Churchill campaigned around Britain against Congress. He set up the India defence league, with support from 50 MPS.
He outwardly suggested that Indians were totally unsuited to democracy.
How did congress cause the round table conferences to fail?
- Congress was only present at the second conference and Gandhi was the sole representative.
- Gandhi suggested that he could speak for all Muslims but this alienated groups seeking separate representation, especially the Muslims.
How did divisions over separate electorates cause them to fail?
- Jinnah supported separate electorates as he wanted the muslim voice to be heard in a new India. In this he was supported by other minority groups like untouchables.
- The British government agreed with the idea of separate electorates.
What stance did Lord Willingdon take after the round table conferences?
(with Gandhi and in general)
- The situation was deteriorating in India and Lord – Willingdon took a hard line.
- not willing to enter discussions with Gandhi.
- Only willing to conciliate those who worked with the administration.
How did Lord Willingdon take a tough line with India?
- 4th Jan 1932 Gandhi was imprisoned
- Congress was outlawed.
- All members of Congress’s working committee were rounded up and all imprisoned. (80,000 imprisoned)
- All youth organisations were banned.
What was the Indian reaction to Lord Willingdon’s hard line?
What was a weakness to this?
- British goods were boycotted.
- Non-payment of taxes
- although banned more joined youth groups
- terrorist activity increased.
- As Gandhi and other members of Congress had been imprisoned opposition was haphazard and disorganise .
- Authorities kept control of the situation and never lost control of the streets and rural areas for very long.
What did Prime Minister Ramsay McDonald announce?
Why did he announce it?
- 16 August 1932 announced the communal award.
- Ramsay McDonald wanted to show himself as a ‘friend of the people’ in India and resolve issues.