2 - Social Influence Flashcards
Define social influence.
scientific study of the ways in which people’s thoughts, feelings & behaviours are affected by other people.
Define conformity.
change in behaviour or belief as a result of a real or imagined group pressure
What are the 3 types of conformity? Can you put them in order of superficiality.
- compliance (most superficial)
- identification (moderate form)
- internalisation (deepest level)
Define compliance.
to appear to agree with others, while disagreeing in private
Define internalisation.
to agree with other both in public & in private
Define identification.
to want to be perceived to belong, as to share groups’ values.
change of belief or behaviour is only temporary
Is compliance private or public acceptance?
public
Is compliance permanent or temporary?
temporary
What explanation of conformity explains compliance?
normative influence
Is internalisation public or private acceptance?
both
Is internalisation permanent or temporary?
temporary
What explanation of conformity explains internalisation?
information influence
Is identification public or private acceptance?
both
Is identification temporary or permanent?
temporary
What explanation of conformity explains identification?
normative influence
What are the 2 explanation of conformity?
- normative influence
- information influence
What is normative influence?
where we want to be liked & accepted by a group
What is informational influence?
where we aren’t confident of our ideas & beliefs
What research supports normative influence?
- Schultz found that hotel guests were exposed to normative mssg that “75% of guests re-used their towels each day”
- guests reduced their own towel use by 25%
What did Schultz’s study suggest?
ppl shape their behaviour out of a desire to fit in with their reference group
What research supports information influence?
Asch’s conformity study
What limitations were found after carrying out research for normative influence?
What did McGhee & Teevan in regards to this?
- does not affect everyone’s behaviour in same way
- McGhee & Teevan found that students who are highly in need of affiliation are more likely to conform.
social desirability to be likely is what leads to conformity
For evaluation, what was found from research on information influence?
- Lucas found students conformed to an incorrect answer when they found a maths problem difficult.
showing people conform in situation where they don’t know the answer - Individual differences – Perrin and Spencer found very little conformity and were less likely to seek information from others.
Define confederate.
not a real prtcpnt
What were the 2 aims of Asch’s conformity study?
- to find out how people would behave w an unambiguous task
- would prtpcnts be influenced by the behaviour of others or would stick to what they believed was right?
How many participants were there in Asch’s study? Who were they?
123 male American undergrads.
How was Asch’s study carried out?
- prtpcnt was in a group of confederates
- each indvdl was asked to state which ‘standard’ line was the same as the other 3 lines
- confederates were asked to give the same incorrect answer on 12 critical trials out of 18
What were the results of Asch’s study?
- on critical trials, 36.8% of responses from real prptcpnt conformed to confederates, by stating wrong line
- when prptcnts asked in private, they were right 99% of time
When asked, why did the participants conform with the confederates? Which explanation of conformity is this?
to avoid ridicule - normative influence
What were the 3 ways that Asch varied his study?
- group size
- unanimity
- task difficulty
How did the change in group size affect the results of Asch’s study?
increase in group size
2 confeds. = prtpcnts conform 13.6% of time
3 confeds. = prtpcnts conform 31.8% of time
How does the change in unanimity affect the results of Asch’s study?
adding a truthful confed. or dissenting, inaccurate confed.
truthful = conformity drops to 5.5%
inaccurate = conformity drops to 9%
How does a change in task difficulty affect the results of Asch’s study?
make the lines more similar in length
this increases conformity
(information influence)
What are 4 weaknesses of Asch’s conformity study?
- lack of ecological validity
- deception, informed consent & psychological harm are issues
- susceptible to demand characteristics
- conformity is not a fixed thing, Asch’s findings may only be relevant to this study
What are 2 strengths of Asch’s study into conformity?
- lack of influence from extraneous varibles, due to it being a controlled lab experiment
- Support from other studies for variation of task difficulty (eg. Todd Lucas (2006))
Give an outline of Todd Lucas’ study into task difficulty & conformity
- asked participnats to solve ‘easy’ and ‘hard’ maths problems
- Participants were given answers from 3 ‘students’ (confeds)
- Participants conformed with confeds more when problems were harder
Where did Zimbardo’s study take place?
Stanford University
Who were the participants in Zimbardo’s study? How many of them?
24 American male students
What were Zimbardo’s participants screened for?
emotional stability