1.4: Validity, Truth, Soundness, Strength, Cogency Flashcards
This section introduces the central ideas and terminology needed to evaluate arguments—to distinguish good arguments from bad arguments.
Deductive argument to…
Inductive argument to…
Validity, Strength
What two characteristics are associated to deductive and inductive arguments?
Think: “V and S…”
validity and strength
What is a valid deductive argument?
it’s impossible for the conclusion to be false since the premises are true
What is an invalid deductive argument?
it is possible for the conclusion to be false since the premises are true
What is a sound argument?
a deductive argument that’s valid with all true premises
valid argument + true premises
What is an unsound argument?
an invalid deductive argument with false premises
invalid argument + false premises
For an argument to be unsound, the false premise or premises must actually be needed to support the conclusion
What is a strong inductive argument?
the conclusion follows from the premises, assuming they’re true
What is a weak inductive argument?
the conclusion doesn’t follow from the premises, assuming they’re true
What is a cogent argument?
a strong inductive with all true premises
What is an uncogent argument?
a weak inductive argument without all true premises
fails to meet total evidence requirement (TER)