10: The Medical Profession Flashcards
What is a profession?
An occupation that can make distinctive claims about its work practices an status
What is a professional?
A member of a profession
Member of a community and sense of professional identity
What is professionalisation?
The social and historical process that results in an occupation becoming a profession
What are the 3 steps to professionalisation of medicine?
- Asserting exclusive claim over body of knowledge
- Establish control over market, exclude competitors
- Establish control over professional work practice
Describe the historical professionalisation of medicine
- Doctors only used to care for the wealthy
- GMC in 1858 by the medical act - power over registration and med schools
- Traditional model of self regulation
How did the GMC control the registration of doctors in the past?
Assumed any individual admitted to the profession was of good character and competence
Describe traditional self regulation
Doctrine of clinical autonomy. Only doctors had enough expertise to monitor and control the work of other doctors
What is professional socialisation?
The process through which new entrants acquire their professional identity, through interaction with others
- Gain technical competence
- Norms and values
What is formal curriculum?
- Acquisition of technical knowledge and expertise
- Tested through examination
- Lay person to professional through medical education
What is informal curriculum?
- Acquisition of attitudes and beliefs
- Performance noted, not formally examined
What are the arguments for self regulation?
- Unusual degree of skill in professional work, non-pros not equipped to evaluate
- Responsible enough to work without supervision
- Trusted to take action on rare occasions when an individual is incompetent or unethical
What are criticisms of the rules on professional propriety?
- Doctors discouraged from raising concerns about each other
- Etiquette - no close monitoring of each other
- Informal control - quiet chats. Social norms powerful corrective influence
What are the criticisms of self regulation?
- Self serving
- Favours agents over principles
- Monopoly rent
- Promotes self deceiving vision of objectivity and reliability of knowledge of members
What were the bad apple enquiries?
A series of medical scandals that undermined the ability of self regulation.
Resistance of external scrutiny resulted in a lack of external monitoring, and the NHS failed to detect unacceptable or incompetent professional behaviour and take action
Difficult to act
Patients and whistleblower not believed or discrefitied
What was the historical approach of the GMC to problems with professionalism?
- Refined its remit to serious professional misconduct
- Admin systems were unclear who was in charge and on what authority
- Insufficiently responsive