1. Democracy and Participation Flashcards
What is democracy’s literal meaning
Rule by the people
Term: Direct Democracy
Democracy in a literal sense where people directly make decisions.
Term: Representative Democracy
Also known as indirect democracy.
People choose representatives (politicians) to make decisions on their behalf.
Representatives are elected through free and fair elections and should be responsive to voters’ needs.
Strengths of Direct Democracy:
Real Democracy: People choose policies/laws directly, making decisions more legitimate.
Reduced Political Influence: Politicians have less influence compared to representative democracy.
Educational Benefits: Encourages political awareness as people become more informed about issues they vote on.
Weaknesses of Direct Democracy:
Impractical in Large Societies: Difficult to implement in modern societies with large populations.
Low Voter Turnout: No guarantee of high voter participation or informed decision-making.
Potential for Poor Decisions: Lack of expertise and information may lead to suboptimal decisions.
Strengths of Representative Democracy:
Expertise and Knowledge: Decisions made by representatives with more knowledge and expertise.
Encourages Compromise: People are less emotionally attached as decisions are made by representatives.
Practical for Large Societies: Suitable for modern societies with large populations and complex issues.
5 Types of Direct Democracy
- Referendums
- Electronic Petitions
- Consultative Exercises
- Open Primaries
- Election of the Leadership of Political Parties
Direct Democracy - Referendums
- Referendums allow the public to directly express their views on single issues. For example the 2014 Scottish Referendums. 44.4% voted for Scottish Independence where as 53% voted to stay within the UK
Direct Democracy - Referendums Advantages
Providing the public with a direct choice can help settle controversial issues. Since the public has voted directly, the result has greater legitimacy.
Direct Democracy - Referendums Disadvantages
- Critics note that referendums require a detailed understanding of issues which the public may lack.
Direct Democracy - Electronic Petitions
If the petition on the government reaches 100,000 signatures. It will be considered for debate at Westminister Hall or the Chambers of the house of Commons. This means that Parliament has to engage with issues that the public feels strongly about
Direct Democracy - Electronic Petitions Advantages
In 2020, England footballer Marcus Rashford’s #EndChildFoodPoverty gained 1.1 million signatures which generated high public enthusiasm to commit to free school meals for low income families during the holidays.
Direct Democracy - Electronic Petitions Disadvantages
Can create false expectations and consume parliamentary time
Issues in which Parliament cannot do - 1 million signatures to revoke Sir Tony Blair’s Knighthood, as they are bestowed upon the monarch.
Direct Democracy - Consultative Exercises
When governing bodies want to assess the likely reaction to their proposed policies. Communities that will be affected were consulted over the expansion of Heathrow and the HS2 Rail LINK.