Wrong Rules Flashcards
4 Categories of activities which Congress can constitutionally regulate under the Commerce Clause
- channels of interstate commerce
- Instrumentalities of interstate commerce
- Articles moving in interstate commerce
- Activities having a substantial effect on interstate commerce.
If a law creates a classification then use
Equal Protection, not Due Process
Commercial speech, if not misleading or concerning unlawful activity is under what scrutiny?
Intermediate Scrutiny
So Substantial governmental interest that is reasonably tailored to achieve that objective.
Congress’ Spending Power is linked to its
General Welfare and has plenary power to spend so long as their choice can reasonably be said to serve the general welfare and not violate any prohibition in the Constitution
Taxpayers generally don’t have standing except
When the challenged federal spending violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment
Intentional and Reckless infliction of emotional distress:
- Intentional or reckless disregard for the consequences
- Extreme and outrageous conduct
- Which caused severe emotional distress.
Public nuisance can be raised by a private party if
The public nuisance causes a unique harm to the P that differs from the general harm to the public. Remedy is usually damages
Even with vicarious liability can still be indemnified if:
You are found 0% negligent and your employee was 100% negligent
A party is not entitled to depose what kind of experts?
Consulting experts- those who are retained in anticipation of litigation, but will not testify at trial.
Under a notice statute, who prevails over a prior grantee who failed to record?
A subsequent BFP- a person who gives valuable consideration and has no notice of the prior grantee
Reformation is a proper remedy when
The writing incorrectly summarizes the parties’ joint understanding (ex. clerical error), not when the parties fundamentally disagree on what the deal is.
A witness cannot be compelled to provide potentially incriminating testimony unless
The witness is granted use and derivative-use immunity.
Battery is caused by an intentional harmful or offensive touching of a person or ____ without consent or privilege.
an extension of the person
Defenses which must be presented in the first pre-answer motion, or if no pre-answer motion then in the answer are:
Lack of personal jurisdiction, improper venue, insufficient process, and insufficient service
A Doctor’s license is _____
property within the meaning of the 14th amendment
Assignment of contractual rights are effective even if the contract prohibits assignments unless
- The clause makes assignments “void” or
2. The assignee had notice
State courts are courts of ____ jurisdiction
General jurisdiction and have concurrent jurisdiction to decide federal questions
Admission of a party opponent is admissible to:
- impeach the defendant AND
- as substantive evidence
Definition: a statement made by a party cannot be excluded as hearsay when offered against him by the opponent if the statement is probative.
In a notice jurisdiction, will a Subsequent bona fide purchaser prevail over an unrecorded interest, even if the BFP also didn’t record?
Yes.
Estoppel by Deed –
If grantor conveys title to real property before he owns it, the title will automatically vest in the grantee as soon as grantor acquires title.
Race-Notice Statute Jurisdiction→
a subsequent bona fide purchaser (no notice + pays value) is protected ONLY IF he records before the prior guarantee.
Race Statute Jurisdiction→
whomever records first prevails (notice is irrelevant).
Notice Statute Jurisdiction→
a subsequent bona fide purchaser (no notice + pays value) will prevail over a prior grantee that failed to record.
Sub-lessee
when a tenant (sublessor) transfers ONLY SOME of his remaining lease interest.
− Tenant may freely sublet UNLESS a provision in the lease states otherwise.
-Sublessee is NOT liable to the landlord for rent or other covenants (there is no privity of estate).
− Sublessor (original tenant) remains liable to landlord for rent (privity of contract).
Assignment of a Lease
– when a tenant transfers ALL of his remaining lease interest to a third-party.
− A lease may be freely assigned UNLESS the lease states otherwise.
Liability for Rent / Breach:
− Assignee→liable to the landlord for rent and all
other covenants that run with the land (privity of
estate).
− Assignor (Original Tenant)→also remains
liable for rent to the landlord (privity of contract).
Nonexclusive Profit-
The grantee of such a profit cannot convey any profit rights to a third party unless agreed to by grantor.
A cotenant who makes ____ repairs to property usually may recover from a non-contributing cotenant
Necessary repairs. Cannot recover if it was just improvements even if it raised the value of the land.
Easement Repairs
Holder of easement has the right to repair and improve it whenever reasonably required for use. Liable for any negligent damages.
Overburdened Easement
An easement is overburdened any time that it is used to benefit land other than the dominant parcel.
Profit
Easement right to come onto land and remove property. Not a license because there are no limitations on the right to remove property.
When personal property/equipment is affixed to real property in a leasehold it becomes real property but,
It is presumed that the parties did not intend for the easily detachable fixture to be incorporated into the property
Encumbrances and foreclosure
Take free of junior encumbrances to the mortgage after foreclosure, but still subject to any encumbrances senior to the mortgage.
Murders are:
- Murder with intent to kill
- Murder with intent to inflict serious bodily harm
- Depraved-heart murder
- Felony murder
FIGS
What is never sufficient alone to be sufficient provocation?
Words
Obtaining money by false pretenses
(1) obtain title, (2) to personal property of another, (3) through an intentional false statement of material fact, (4) with intent to defraud.
Larceny by Trick
obtain possession (not title) of the personal property of another by trick or deception
Kidnapping –
is the (1) confining, restraining, or moving of a person, (2) without authority of law. − MPC→abducting another person: (a) for ransom; (b) to facilitate a felony; (c) to inflict bodily injury or terrorize; OR (d) to interfere with a government/political function.
At common law what crimes are sufficient for burglary?
BRAKERS AND Larceny
Subcontractor/Contractor
- Offers, even those supported by no consideration can be irrevocable where there was ddetrimental reliance.
- Genearl contractor is not free to delay acceptance after awarded teh general contract. Cannot reopen bargaining with he subcontractor, will lose thhe power to accept the sub-contractor’s bid
Silence cannot equal an acceptance of a contract unless
The offeror grants the offeree power to accept by silence.
Promissory Estoppel (2)
- Substitute for consideration
2. Rarely applied absent an unconscionable result.
JMOL standard:
Find that no reasonable jury could reach a result different from that reached by the judge. i.e. reasonable minds could not differ as to which party should prevail.
If a Jury verdict is inconsistent
If the answers are inconsistent with each other and on or more is also inconsistent with the general verdict, court must direct the jury to further consider its answers and verdict, or must order a new trial.
In order to show that there is a genuine dispute of material fact ___ is not enough for summary judgment standard
Mere re-assertion of a denial of facts contained in the answer.
Filing for a motion of a new trial standard:
1) OUTSIDE prejudicial information was improperly brought to the jury’s attention,
2) outside influence was improperly brought to bear on the jury,
OR
3) a mistake was made in entering the information on the verdict sheet
A renewed motion for judgment as a matter of law may renew the motion after the verdict but____
… only on the grounds made in the motion for judgment as a matter of law during the trial.
Harmless error rule
Permits an appellate court to deny relief, despite finding error unless the error had an impact on the outcome of the proceeding.
In disclosure, there is a duty to correct a statement made in a _____ but no duty to correct a statement in a _____
Answer….. Deposition.
Privilege against self-incrimination extends only to
testimonial or communicative communications.
The standard for restricting commercial speech:
The law is narrowly tailored to serve a substantial government interest.
Can a judge testify in a trial over which he is proceeding over?
No
Who is liable under a mortgage assumption?
Assumption of a Mortgage → may be express or implied.
If a buyer “assumes” the mortgage, he is primarily and personally liable on the mortgage.
− Seller remains secondarily liable.
− Express Mortgage Assumption – occurs if there is an express agreement for grantee to (1) take the real property, AND (2) continue making mortgage payments.
− Implied Mortgage Assumption (only allowed in a few states) – occurs if: (1) no express agreement exists; (2) grantee/buyer pays the seller only the equity in the home; AND (3) grantee continues to make payments to the lender on the balance of the mortgage.
Assumption with novation is when the new buyer is the only one liable.
Can’t introduce evidence that a person was insured is generally not admissible to prove they acted negligently or wrongfully but for other purposes is ok.
Other purposes include motive. Past conduct cannot be admitted to prove a propensity to engage in such conduct u can be admitted on the issue of motive.
Invasion of privacy tort:
Someone intentionally intrudes into the solitude or seclusion of another’s life in a highly offensive manner.
Does not require publication (as defamation does) nor is truth a defense.
Declarations against interest does not permit the testimony about statements implicating____ only _____
others only those remarks that are self0incriminatory.
Contradictory evidence (CRIB PIC_ is not admissible where its sole function is to contradict testimony on ________
collateral issues instead of a material issue in the case.
UCC generally an assignment under a sales contract also operates as a delegation of duties except for ___
When the purpose of the assignment is a financing arrangement, only the assignor’s rights are transferred and there is no intent for a delegation of duties.
Options for purchase of real property are enforceable if there is _____
CIA Notice
There is no constructive notice if the recording was _____
in the wrong chain of title
A _____ defendant may introduce character evidence to raise an inference that his character was inconsistent with the crime charged
Criminal (not civil)
Generally, evidence of a person’s character or a trait of his character generally is not admissible for the purpose of proving that he acted in conformity therewith on a particular occasion but this is one of those exceptions.
If trespasser can demonstrate unintended trespass was _____ then she will not be liable for any resulting damages
reasonable under the circumstances
Lost profits of an unestablished business are:
too speculative and uncertain to be measured.
Any party who shares control of the premises or item to be searched may provide valid consent to search, however when the two parties who share such control are both presents at the time the state actor requests consent,
both must consent for the search to be valid.
In other words, one party’s consent cannot trump the other’s when both are present.
In an IIED claim physical injury is not required if the conduct causing it is____ and the conduct must be substantially certain to result in ______
Conduct is extreme or outrageous
Severe emotional distress (not mere embarrassment)
SAD CEO
Common law kidnapping requires:
Asporation (transporting)
In UCC if the price is left blank then
a reasonable price will be implied by the courts.
Unenforceable if it is common law because it is an essential term.
In an Impleader must have
derivative claim, not an independent claim.
Improper impleader is when you try to shift liability over to a third party.
State tax will survive a Commerce Clause if:
it is applied to an activity with a substantial nexus within the taxing state, is fairly apportioned among states that might levy a tax on the same business activity, does not discriminate against interstate commerce, and is fairly related to the services provided by the state.
Guest statute-
protects the guest’s hosts from claims of ordinary negligence, but does not protect the negligence of other drivers or defective manufacturers.
Clergy privilege protects:
the person seeking spiritual advice
Larceny by trick
he fraudulently induced the person to surrender possession but not title.
Independent contractor
generally not liable for the torts of an independent contractor unless he actively oversees the operation
Exception: whether the IC undertakes a non-delegable duty, such as the duty of a municipality to keep its streets in repair, duty to afford lateral support to adjoining land, and duty to refrain from obstructing or endangering the public highway.
Exception: Can be negligent in hiring
Modern Restatement of Unilateral K acceptance and revocation
when offeree begins performance, the offer becomes an option which the offeror cannot revoke for a reasonable period of time
Common Law: Unilateral contract offer invites an acceptance of that offer only by a completed act
Assignment vs. Delegation –
assignment is a transfer of a right or benefit; a delegation is the transfer of a duty.