White Collar Crime Flashcards
White Collar Crime
A crime committed by a person of respectability and high social status in the course of his or her occupation - Edwin Sutherland
Can be committed…
Occupationally or Organizationally
Occupationally
” illegal activities among business and professional men”
Organizationally
“a violation of law regulating business, which is committed for a firm by the firm or its agents in the conduct of its business” (aka Corporate Crime)
Occupational Crime
Committed by a group of individuals for their own benefits, does not represent everyone
○ Unprofessional Conduct and Malpractice
- Investment and Securities Fraud
Occupational Crime Examples
• Internet Fraud • Tax Fraud • Political Corruption • Blue Collar Crime • Employee Fraud - White-collar Crime and Legal Sanctions
Churning
making unneccesary trades to generate higher commission
Organizational or Corporate Crime
white-collar crimes committed with the support and encouragement of a formal organization, and intended to advance the organization’s goals (active support, machinery or an entire corporation)
Is all White Collar Crime committed by Upper-Class?
NO!
- (for ex.,) your garage mechanic may defraud you by changing for work that has not been done and it may be difficult to separate the organization and occupational components of many white collar crimes
- A key element of social class is the power to commit major white-collar crimes that only ownership and authority positions in occupational and organizational structures can make possible
Costs of White-Collar Crime
- The financial costs are enormous, far exceed cost of ‘street’ crime
- Formal organization allows crimes of great magnitude compared to person acting alone
- Also causes many deaths/injuries, outnumbers murder (ex: 1/3 due to asbestos that no one informed the workers of)
- However, most offences are not dealt with under criminal law, and penalties may be very light even if they admit to the them
“Corporate Homicide”
–> Swartz argues that these should be recognized as murder - “corporate homicide”, although small fines are the most anyone is held accountable for
Social Class and Crime
- Corporate Homicides may occur more frequently among particular employers in particular industries
- Common acts of delinquency are positively related to class while more serious forms of delinquency are negatively related
Street Crime vs. Corporate Crime
- An average of more than two deaths a day occur as a result of work place injuries
- Manufacturing, construction, transportation & storage and mining are responsible for 63% of all fatalities
- The study finds that sexual assault and other sexual offences cost $4.8 billion
- Over 90% of the victims were females
- Victims bore most of the costs for all five types of crime: $10.6 billion
- Criminal justice system and third-party costs far behind.
Overall, the five types of street crimes cost $12.7 billion
5 Categories of Violent Crime
assault, criminal harassment, homicide, robbery, sexual assault and other sexual offences
Cost of Criminal Justice
In 2011-2012:
- The federal, provincial and territorial governments spent $20.3 billion (1.1% of GDP) on criminal justice, comparable to the budget of National Defence
- Expenditures split 27/73 between the federal government and the provinces ($5.5 billion and $14.8 billion).
- Provincial security $7.9 billion
- White collar crime costs us more than banks
Street Crime vs. Corporate Crime in the US
- Robberies accounted for an estimated $409 million in losses in 2011.
- The Worldcom scandal involved at least $175 billion
- An average of 16,000 Americans are victims of homicides every year while 56,000 die annually on the job or from occupational diseases
Why do higher Status People Commit Crimes?
3 Factors:
- ) Competitive spirit (Competition for prosperity, wanting to do well)
- ) Arrogance (Excessive sense of self)
- ) Sense of entitlement
What Sociological Factors enable WCC?
- Major white collar crimes are highly complex and secretive schemes that require expertise.
- Existing criminal law focuses on street crimes rather than white collar crimes
- The effects of white collar crime are often indirect
- Public and political leaders are often preoccupied with violent crimes
- Drug offences also receive significant law enforcement attention thus diverting valuable resources
- Suspects are well-resourced and highly placed; therefore, prosecution is often lengthy, expensive and difficult
- Middle and upper class bias in the criminal justice system
- The conventional “elements of crime” are often missing, therefore, there is difficulty in establishing that a crime has been committed
- Widespread public perception of white collar offences as moral failures rather than criminality
- Hard to prove mens rea with corporate crime. Cannot prove the person who died (if someone did) was intended “target”, hard to even prove actus reus as no action necessarily caused it
Ex. of WCC
Case of Doctor in the US who tried to have his partner assassinated, he was involved in a deal with his childhood friend but his friend cheated him, he hired a hitman who was an undercover FBI, he was sentenced to house arrest because he was well respected in the community and they supported him, as well he lost his entire lifes savings unfairly
Examples of Corporate Crimes
- Hyundai and Kia (US), Nov. 2014: Fined $100 mil. For false advertising regarding fuel economy of their vehicles
- HSBC (Belgium), Nov. 2014: Accused of “Fraud, money laundering, criminal association and illegal exercise of the profession of financial intermediary”
- BP (US), 2012: Find $1.256 bil. For environmental and related offences
- GlaxoSmithKline - $956 mil. (marketing offenses) 2012
Pfizer (US), Sept 2009: Fined $2.3 bil. For illegally promoting its Bextra painkiller and other drugs