Week 8 Flashcards
What are examples of cooperative breeding?
Slime mold - Dictyostelium discoideum
Ant colonies
Long-tailed tits
What is an overview of the cooperative breeding of Dictyostelium discoideum?
Single cell eukaryote
Lives in colonies
1 cell becomes spore which produces next generation and another sacrifices itself to become a stalk
What is the evolutionairy paradoc of cooperative breeding?
Individuals help other individuals to reproduce, at a cost to themselves
Contradicts the idea that individuals should maximise their own reproductive success
What are examples of species verterbrate cooperative breeding systems?
Cichilids
Acorn Woodpeckers
Meerkats
How frequent is veterbrate cooperative breeding?
> 200 spp of birds
120 spp of mammals
50 spp of fish
What is cooperative breeding?
Situation where adult individuals, in addition to the genetic parents, stay within a group and regularly aid in the rearing of young
What are examples of types of cooperative breeding?
Helpers at a nest (~80% of CBS)
Plural breeding
What is an overview of helpers at the nest cooperative breeding strategies?
Situation where adult individuals, in addition to the genetic parents, stay within a group and regularly aid in the rearing of young
Seen in scrub jays and jackals
What is an overview of plural breeding?
Several males and females share a nest and raise a communal brood
Seen in Gray-breasted jay Banded mongoose
What is the variation in cooperative breeding strategies?
A spectrum - ostrich is some where in the middle has a couple breeding pairs lay in a nest but also has helpers who arent breeding
What are examples of cooperative breeding systems not in nonmonogamous systems?
Polyandry - Naked mole rat
Polygyny - Moustached Tamarin
Polygynandry - dunnocks
Do helpers benefit dominants?
Increasing the reproductive success of the breeders
Increase breeder survival
What is an example of reproductive sucess of breeders increasing with help?
Jackals - Mooehlman 1979
As number of helpers increases the number of offspring survive
How have additional helpers increase breeder survival?
Scrub jays - annual breeder Mumme 1992
With helpers survival increase from 77% to 85%
Is there a cost to helping?
Individuals that helped most had worse body condition at the end of the season and lower future survival Colonial pied kingfishers (Reyer 1984) and Stripe backed wrens (Rabenold 1990)
What is an example of condition helping?
In Meerkats helping is condition dependent (Russell et al 2003 PNAS)
– Only help when above threshold weight
– Short term cost – lose weight
– Stop helping when drop below threshold
– No reduction in survival
Behavioural modification – reduce long term costs
What is kin selection?
An individual can increase the number of copies of its genes in future generations by helping to increase the reproductive success of close relatives (W.D Hamilton 1964)
What is hamilton’s rule?
A costly action should be performed if:
C < B x R
C = cost in fitness to the actor,
B = fitness benefit to the recipient
R = genetic relatedness between the actor and the recipient
Why do cooperative breeding systems evolve?
Eusocial insects/microrganisms
- consistently high levels of relatedness between sibs
- kin selected benefits do seem to explain altruistic behaviour
What can cause vertebrate cooperative breeding systems to evolve?
Ecological constraints
Benefits of philopatry (staying in a group)
What is the outcome of ecological constraints enforcing cooperative breeding systems?
Individuals join a group (or don’t leave their natal territory) because there are no good breeding opportunities available
What is an overview of the benefits of philopatry for cooperative breeding?
Increased survival
Increased chance to inherit territory
Ability to safely look for breeding opportunites
What is an example of ecological changes resulting in changes in cooperative breeding?
Superb fairy-wrens. Male helpers always leave when an opportunity to pair with an unmated female arises. (Pruett-Jones & Lewis 1990 Nature)
Why does helping evolve?
Indrect (kin selected benefits)
Direct benefits - increase an individuals own lifetime reproductive success
What is an overview of indirect (kin selected) benefits?
In many systems, young individuals delay dispersal and help parents raise subsequent offspring
So kin selection has been the favoured explanation
What are examples of direct benefits of cooperative breeding?
Pay to stay - kicked out if not helping - seen in Neolamprologus pulcher (cichlid)
Acquisition of a mate
Group augementation - whole group does better and you may be able to benefit if you take over group
Gain breeding experience
Direct breeding
What are the direct and indirect benefits of cooperative breeding?
Direct present - Increased survival
Direct future - Increased probability of breeding improved reproductive success as breeders
Indirect present - increased production of non-descendent kin
Indirect future - increased survival and production of kin + increased production of future helpers
What is an example of cooperative breeding?
Seychelles warbler which live on a small island in the Seychelles
What is an overview of cooperative breeding in the seychelles warbler?
A dominant pair with suboridinates that are typically female
What are the constraints placed in the seychelles warbler?
Limited breeding territories available
When translocated – independent breeding – until the new island was saturated
What are the benefits shown for cooperative breeding on Seychelle warbler?
Direct benefits - Acquisition of parental experience
(Komdeur 1996)
Indirect kin benefits - Subordinates appear to improve the reproductive output of the territory (Komdeur 1994)
What does previous work on cooperative breeding in Seychelle Warbler suggest?
Suggested that indirect (kin) benefits = main benefit but assumed relatedness!
What is a rough status of the Seychelle warbler on Cousin Island in 1997?
> 96% of birds individually colour ringed and blood sampled
All territories mapped and monitored
Breeding attempts followed
Status of adults in cooperatively breeding territories (30%) was determined
All chicks blood sampled (1 or 2 chicks/nest)
How did they determine parentage in the Seychelle Warbler?
30 microsatellite loci used for genotyping
Parentage – Assigned using CERVUS; Marshall 1998
Relatedness – Based on genotype similarity
What was the overview of cooperative breeding in Seychelle warbler?
30% of territories were cooperatively breeding
44% of subordinate females layed an egg = 11% of nestlings
15% of subordinate males fathered an egg = ~1% of nestlings
Female subs more likely to gain parentage than males
What was the extra pair paternity of inthe Seychelles warbler?
40% Extra-pair paternity
What does the high levels of extra pair paternity mean for cooperative breeding?
High levels of extra pair paternity may explain why there is high levels of sneaking eggs in. As there is a high chance that chick will be a half sibling which has a lower genetic relatedness than offspring
What is the relatedness between subordinates and nestlings in the seychelle warblers?
Previously expected R = 0.5
Female subordinate-nestlings = 0.13
Male subordinate-nestlings = 0.07
How many offspring are produced by dominant and subordiante seychelle warblers?
Dominant breeders only produce ca. 1.00 per year
Female subordinates 0.46 ± 0.63
Male subordinates 0.14 ± 0.35
What are the benefits of cooperative breeding in seychelle warbler?
Benefits = Increase in offspring produced by dominants as a result of helping (b) x relatedness between helper and helped offspring (r)
What is the quantifiable genetic benefit of cooperative breeding in Seychelle warbler?
Extra offspring produced due to the presence of a subordinate, excluding
subordinate parentage = 0.18 ± 0.50 x Subordinate-nestling relatedness