Week 6 Flashcards
What is sexual selection?
= Adaptations generated by intraspecific interactions and competitions
= Adaptations associated with the struggle to reproduce
What is the quote by Darwin about sexual selection?
‘the advantage which certain individuals have over other individuals of the same sex and species, in exclusive relation to reproduction’
What is the relationship between sexual and natural selection?
Sexual selection and natural selection can be distinct
Traits that are attractive to mates because they constrain survival and only occur in the competing sex
What is an example of sexual selection trait increasing risk of extinction?
Megaloceros giganteus (Irish Elk)
Increase in male horn length increases risk of extinction
What is an example of sexual selection trait being aligned with natural selection?
Black grouse
Male (sexually selected) mating success on the lek correlates with (naturally selected) survival
So traits associated with enhanced survival can also be attractive to mates
Why does sexual selection occur?
BATEMAN PRINCIPLE
POTENTIAL REPRODUCTIVE RATE VARIANCE
Female dominated PARENTAL INVESTMENT
What is the quote by Robert trivers about the occurance of sexual selection?
‘…the sex whose typical parental investment is greater than that of the opposite sex will become a limiting resource for that sex.’
What is an overview about why sexual selection occurs?
THEREFORE (IN GENERAL) SELECTION ON LIMITED MALES TO COMPETE AND LIMITING FEMALES TO CHOOSE
What is intrasexual selection?
INDIVIDUALS OF THE SAME SEX (USUALLY MALES) COMPETE FOR MATINGS eg elephant seals
What is intersexual selection?
INDIVIDUALS OF ONE SEX (USUALLY FEMALES) CHOOSE MATING PARTNERS FROM THE OTHER SEX eg male peacock spiders dancing to attract female spider
Can both inter and intrasexual selection occur?
Males may compete intra-sexually for an inter-sexual result
Red deer stags compete intra-sexually during the rut and establish dominance hierarchy for territories
Hinds choose males and territories inter-sexually
= mate choice dynamics within polygyny
What are direct benefits of mate selecting for females?
Parental care, protection from a predator and access to resource
What are indirect benefits of mate selecting for females?
Improve reproductive success or offspring quality
What is conspecific recognition?
Avoidance of hybridisations which may be less fertile/infertile
What selects for mate chouce and discrimination?
Mate choice & discrimination evolves more rapidly in sympatric (overlapping) than allopatric (isolated) Drosophila species pairs
What is an example of Prunella modularis (dunnock)?
Male dunnocks help with raising chicks
DNA barcoding to identify whether alpha or beta male fathered each offspring. This is a mixed-paternity brood
The more opportunity the beta male had to mate with the female (exclusive access) the more he contributes to feeding brood
What are the pros of polygyny and polyandry in dunnocks?
Polyandry here allows female to increase number and quality of offspring, by ensuring paternal investment.
For ana lpha male, at least 60% of brood need to be fathered by him for cooperative polyandry to be favourable.
Alpha male wins out in polygyny, female and beta male win in polyandry – which may be why polyandry persists, but alpha males chase away beta males.
What is an example of male sacrifice in mating?
Male redback spiders often actively sacrifice themselves while mating
Females benefit from an extra meal
Males feed their own offspring, and achieve greater sperm transfer
Why does male sacrifice occur in male redback spiders?
This strategy may have evolved since males suffer extreme mortality risks while mate-searching 80% of males do not encounter a mate.
Why does male sacrifice persist in male redback spiders?
Rare to find a mate, so although males have physiological capability to remate, it’s unlikely they will have opportunity.
Therefore, they are selected to maximise number/success of offspring in any mating opportunity.
Males that allow themselves to be cannibalized transfer more sperm & provide nutrients for their offspring
Does courtship effort display fertility?
Male display rate reveals ejaculate characteristics in the Trinidadian guppy Poecilia reticulata
What is a direct benefit in males for staying around?
Cuckold: husband of adulterous wife.
Biologically a cuckold is a male who invests in the offspring of others (due to extra-pair paternity)
Seen in house sparrow, Passer domesticus
What are the models for why sexual selection choose when there are no direct benefits?
Runaway sexual selection
Good genes
Parasie mediated
Compatible genes
What is an overview of the runaway selection?
FISHER (1930)
FEMALE PREFERENCES FOR PARTICULAR (NATURALLY-SELECTED / ARBITRARY) TRAITS
GENETIC LINK BETWEEN MALE TRAIT AND FEMALE PREFERENCE
SONS CARRYING THE TRAIT GAIN SUCCESS
TRAITS FIX IN POPULATION AND FEMALE GENES FOR TRAIT CHOICE PERSIST
RUNAWAY EXAGGERATION OF THE TRAIT
What is an overview of the good genes model?
TRAITS ARE COSTLY TO DEVELOP / CARRY – THEY ARE A HANDICAP (ZAHAVI 1975)
CARRYING THE HANDICAP IS AN HONEST SIGNAL OF INDIVIDUAL MALE ‘QUALITY’
HANDICAP IS EITHER ‘STANDARD’ AND ACTS AS A ‘SURVIVAL FILTER’….
….OR HANDICAP IS CONDITION-DEPENDENT AND BETTER MALES CARRY BIGGER HANDICAPS
BEING FATHERED BY MALES THAT CAN CARRY THE HANDICAP WILL CAPTURE BETTER GENES
What is an overview of the parasite mediated sexual selection?
HAMILTON & ZUK (1985)
PARASITE LOAD IS A MAJOR & GENERAL PROBLEM
SIGNAL IS LINKED TO PARASITE RESISTANCE
BEING FATHERED BY MALES WITH EVIDENT SIGNALS WILL CAPTURE BETTER RESISTANCE GENES
What is an overview of the compatible gene hypothesis?
MATE CHOICE BENEFITS IN CHOOSING GENOTYPES THAT COMPLEMENT SELF
GENERAL BENEFIT TO AVOID OUTBREEDING (e.g. similar to self to avoid hybridisation)
GENERAL BENEFIT TO AVOID INBREEDING (e.g. different to self to avoid inbreeding)
SPECIFIC BENEFIT AT PARTICULAR LOCI / COMPLEXES (e.g. the Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) for immunorecognition)
How are all the theories about sexual selection linked?
CO-EVOLUTION OF LINKED FEMALE PREFERENCE IMPORTANT IN RUNAWAY MODELS
COST OF SIGNAL MORE IMPORTANT IN HANDICAP MODELS
SPECIFICITY OF SIGNAL TO IMMUNITY IMPORTANT IN PARASITE RESISTANCE MODELS
COMPATIBILITY FOCUSED ON MALE-FEMALE RELATEDNESS
How do all of these signal good genes?
Sexy sons
General quality
Parasite resistance
Compatibility
What is an example of runaway selection?
Male ornamentation varies across different populations of Trinidadian guppy (affected by predation)
Observational comparison of male trait and ‘naïve’ female preference across 7 different populations
Naïve females prefer their own population’s male ornamentation characteristics
= Evidence that female preference genes co-evolved with male trait
What are naive female trinidadian guppies
Naïve females = separated from males before maturity (and before colour patterns develop), reared in female-only group