Week 6 Punishing Women Offenders Flashcards
Incarcerated Women
- Invisible, among incarcerated people
- Unless we focus only on women
- Then, responses are sometimes paternalistic
- We regard female inmates in childlike ways
3 Reasons for Invisibility
- Women are a small proportion of the incarcerated population (7%)
- Women are incarcerated for less serious and less dangerous crimes
- Imprisoned women are less likely to demand reform, relative to men
- But, their proportion is growing
History of Institutionalization
- Pre-custodial punishments
- Early prison housing
- Co-ed, but gendered work for women
- Extremely high risk of rape for women, seen as women inviting the rape and were flogged to death
- Women were seen as sexual deviants that placed guards at risk
- The system was designed to meet the needs of the majority
- Sex/rape in early prisons
- Contradiction in understanding rape in prison
Reforms to Women’s Confinement
- Early recognition of social context of women’s crime
- Elizabeth Fry a voice for Difference gets 3 reforms and argues that men and women are different
- Sex Segregation
- Female guards
- Decreased hard labor
- Reforms in the U.S.: Magdalen Home (1830)
- Sex segregated
- Rehabilitation of prostitutes
- Restore the moral compass of prostitutes
- 3 Religious instruction
Reforms Continue
Ambivalence
- Purifying women was a priority
- But sexual abuse during incarceration was common
“Fallen women” and “fallen men”
1880s Quaker feminism
- Were women victims of male judges, wardens, and guards?
New Confinement Options
Custodial placements held men and women
New idea: REformatories
- Women only
- Net widening
- Indeterminate sentencing
More reform
- Sex-segregated Custodial Placement (Prisons)
- Worst of both worlds for women
- punitive, indeterminate, non-rehabilitative
Incarceration during the 1960s-80s
Cottage style housing
Became more like men’s housing
- because it often is men’s housing leftover
Geography is a problem
Programming is a problem
These problems remain important concerns today
Incarceration during the 1960s-80s
Cottage style housing
Became more like men’s housing
- because it often is men’s housing leftover
Geography is a problem (too far away from home and women are often the caretakers)
Programming is a problem (intense profound need for psychological counseling that relates to physical, sexual, and domestic abuse)
These problems remain important concerns today
Women’s prisons
Becoming increasingly similar to men’s
- less reform-oriented and more punitive than ever
Institutionalize sexism: (policies that restrict opportunities for women)
- Within prisons, these policies are justified by women’s smaller numbers
Three areas of institutional sexism right now
- Women are incarcerated farther from home
- Fewer educational, vocational, and other programs
- Little or no specialization/segregation
Women’s imprisonment is rising
Women’s proportion among the incarcerated is growing
- Behavior change?
- Policy change?
With the growth, women comprise around 10% of the incarcerated population
- Criminalizing help-seeking behavior
Incarcerated Women
Race is the key factor
Most are poor
More likely than other women to
- Have been abusively disciplined
- Have been drug involved
- Have worked as prostitutes
- Have witnessed domestic violence
Incarcerated women often believe that these factors are related to their criminality
Girls’ Correctional Facilities
Status offenses vs delinquency
Conditions are harsh
- Rule strictness
- Sexual assaults
- Few programs
Psychological Aspects
Self-destructive behaviors
- Internalzaied anger, self-mutilation
- History of sexual abuse
Access to mental health care
- “Inundated” with requests for care
- Yet, little or no trained, clinical care
- 17% of women in jails and 23% of women in prison receive psychotropic meds
Impact of psych meds
- On fetuses
- On trial outcomes
Psychological Aspects
Self-destructive behaviors
- Internalzaied anger, self-mutilation
- History of sexual abuse
Access to mental health care
- “Inundated” with requests for care
- Yet, little or no trained, clinical care
- 17% of women in jails and 23% of women in prison receive psychotropic meds
Impact of psych meds
- On fetuses
- On-trial outcomes
The Drug War
The biggest explanation for women’s increased incarceration
Lack of treatment out and inside of prisons is a problem, recidivism is high for drug offenders
Gender-specific drug rehab (stop the trauma from the gendered violence and you stop the drug use)