Week 3 Flashcards
what are the 5 main ethical theories in healthcare
- goal or consequenced based
- duty-based
- character based (virtue)
- relationships based (ethics of care, feminist)
- principles
what is the most prominent ethical theory? what is another name for this?
- goal or consequence based
- utilitarian
what is another name for duty based ethical theory
- deontological
describe consequence based theories (3)
- rightness or wrongness of actions depends on the goodness or badness of the consequences of actions
- considers the ripple effect –> what could happen as a result of this decision
- goal is to maximize utility –> greatest good for the greatest number
by the consequence based theory, what makes a choice good/ethical? (3)
- good outcome = ethical choice
- choice is good/ethical if it results in more good/happiness than harm/unhappiness
- even if some unhappiness results, it is still ethical if good > harm
what are concerns with consequence-based ethics (2)
- majority can overrule individual rules
- may create injustice
what is considered w consequenced-based ethics (5)
- what could happen if we do this action?
- what could happen if we dont?
- what is the worst case scenario?
- best case scenario?
- what choice would produce the greatest benefit and minimize possible harms?
- consider the ripple effect
describe duty-based ethics (3)
- involves adherence to duties/rules
- about the duty of obligation “to act according to particular rules or principles”
- little consideration of the consequences of an action –> consequences may be considered but right or wrong is not exclusively related to consequences
based on duty-based ethics, what is considered a good/ethical choice
- an action is ethical if it is based on ethical rules, regardless of the consequences
duties considered w duty-based ethics includes (5)
- confidentiality
- veracity (truthfulness)
- preventing harm
- fairness
- duty to care
these are often written down as laws or policies or Codes of Ethics
what are concerns w duty-based ethics
- duties can & do conflict, some are even mutually exclusive
- may ignore consequences
ex. what if telling the truth would cause harm to someone?
what may be considered with duty-based reasoning (5)
- what standard laws do we need to follow?
- does the Code of Ethics say anything about the topic?
- is there a facility policy to consider?
- do we have consent?
- right to refuse
describe character-based theories
- involves thinking about a person you admire, or an exemplary nurse and what they would do
- aka virtue theory
what are virtues
- character traits that predispose a person w good intentions to act w practical wisdom
what virtues may be considered w character-based theories (6)
- honesty
- kindness
- loyalty
- fairness (moral virtues)
- intelligence
- prudence (practical virtues)
what is considered w character-based ethics (3)
- what would a good nurse do?
- is the action consistent w values like honesty and kindness?
- what would someone you consider a moral exemplar choose?
describe relationship-based theories (3)
- focuses on preserving relationships, improving communication, enhancing cooperation, and minimizing harm to everyone involved while promoting an ideal of caring
- recognizes the web of relationship that health and health care exist within
- ethics of care