Weak Areas Flashcards
What are the 3 purposes of inspections?
Valuation, Property management and agency.
What things are you looking for when undergoing an inspection for valuation purposes?
factors impacting value such as location, condition, aspects, defects, form of construction
What things are you looking for when undergoing an inspection for property management purposes?
if occupied: lease compliance, statutory compliance, need for decoration and repair, defects, repair and condition
if unoccupied: statutory compliance, state of building, repair and maintenance, defects, obsoletion, vandalism and building damage
What things are you looking for when undergoing an inspection for agency purposes?
buildin condition
repairs and maintenance
services
presentation and flexibility of accommodation
MARKETABILITY
What things are you looking for when undertaking an external inspection?
method of construction
defects and repair/condition
car parking
access
loading
structural movement
What things are you looking for when undertaking an internal inspection?
layout and specification –> flexibility and obsolescence
repair and maintenance
defects
age/condition of services
statutory compliance e.g asbestos, H&S, equality act 2010, fire safety
F&F
What is the institutional specification of retail units?
if new: constructed of steel or concrete frames
services capped off
concrete floor
no suspended ceiling
no shop frontage
effectively in shell condition for retailer to fit out
What is the institutional specification of industrial units?
Steel portal frame
Plastic coated profiled steel cladding
c.2m brick or block work walls elevations
Min 8m eaves height
Min 10% roof lights
Full height electric loading doors
3 phase power supply
Main services capped off
LED lighting
5-10% office areas
What is the institutional specification of office units?
BCO (British Council for Offices) provides an institutional spec including:
full accessed raised floor c.150mm void
ceiling height 2.6-2.8m
2.50-3 kn/sqm floor loading capacity
A/C and double glazing
passenger lifts
1 cycle space per 10 staff
1 shower per 100 staff
8-10m2 occupancy density
3 common causes of defect?
Water, movement and deterioration of/defective building materials
Types of movement causing defects
Subsidence = vertical downward movement of building foundation. can be from changing underlying ground conditions
Heave = expansion of ground beneath part/all buiding, can be due to tree removal and subsequent moisture build up
OR
Horizontal cracking = in brickwork and may indicate cavity wall tie failure
shrinkage cracking = in new plasterwork when drying out
thermal expansion can also cause crakcs
Purpose of snagging
to meet standards and specification
Types/causes of damp?
Wet rot
Dry rot
rising damp
condensation
leaking plumbing / AC / pipework
What is wet rot and what are the signs?
Caused by timber decay and damp.
Signs = wet/soft timber, high damp meter reading, visible fungal and musty smell
What is dry rot and what are the signs?
Caused by fungal attack
signs = fungus, known as mycelium with white fluffy strands across wood
large and often organ mushroom like bodies
strong smell
red spores
cracking paintwork and timber
can destroy masonry and timber
What must you do regarding defects for all inspections?
You must look for defects during all inspections by starting at the roof and working downwards
what are the causes of condensation?
lack of ventilation and heating
signs = mould and streaming water on windows and walls
typical defects for period resi/office/shop building
dry rot
wet rot
roof tile slippage
damp penetration at roof and ground level
water ingress on windows and doors
structural movement
typical defects for modern industrial buildings
leaks around roof lights
cut edge errosion
spalling/efflorescence/cracking on brick work
damaged cladding
blocked valley gutters
water damage from poor guttering
typical defects for modern office buildings
damp penetration at roof and ground level
water damage from burst a/c, water pipes
damaged cladding
cavity wall tie failure
efflorescence
Key legislation regarding contamination?
Environmental Protection Act 1990
Who pays for remedial works if contamination occurs?
Typically landowner pays for remediation works
Why can contamination exist?
because of heavy metals, radon and methane gas and diesel/oil/chemicals
Signs of contamination?
bare ground
evidence of chemicals, oils, oil drums
subsidence
underground tanks
what are the typical phases of investigation of contamination?
Phase 1 - review site history (desktop) and site inspection/investigation
Phase 2 - investigation to identify nature and extent of contamination. With detailed soil samples using bore holes
Phase 3 - remediation report to set out remedial options and monitoring
**suggest specialist reports if concerns the site has contamination
What would you do if you were instructed to value a site with contamination?
- DO NOT provide val advice until specialist report is comissioned
- Caveat advice with disclaimer highlighting the issue OR special assumption
- Deduct remediation costs from gross site value
Signs of deleterious materials?
brown staining on concrete or concrete frame
Example of a deleterious material?
Reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (RACC)
Used in many public buildings in 60s-90s and deteroriorates over time - esp in harsh conditions - leading to structural issues
High alumina cement
calcium chloride
woodwoll shuttering
Examples of hazardous materials
asbestos - always check asbestos register
radon gas
lead piping
Recommend specialist report
What is Japanese knotweed?
invasive species of plant that can damage hard surfaces ie foundations and tarmac
Hard to control and costly to eradicate - specialists must remove and dispose
purple/green stem with large green leaves (spade like shape)
chemical treatment / digging out / removing to licensed landfill –> in accordance with Environmental Protection Act 1990
professional standard on knotweed called Japanese Knotweed and residential property
What is the RICS Guidance on property measurement available?
RICS Prof Standard: RICS Property Measurement 2018
Code of Measuring Practice 2015
IPMS All Buildings 2023
IPMS Data Standards
For all building classes except offices and resi, bases of measurement in COMP may still apply BUT application (ie part 1) of the professional standard applies to all e.g. what should rics members consider when evaluating the level of accuracy
What does the RICS Prof Standard: RICS Property Measurement 2018 set out?
Application of the PS
Technical definitions
IPMS: Office Buildings
IPMS: Residential Buildings
what should RICS members and firms consider when evaluating the level of accuracy expected from a measured survey?
What is the purpose of the measurement exercise?
What are the client’s requirements and expectations
what are the building/site conditions at time of the survey
what are the time/cost elements
what are ramifications for inaccuracy
considering above will mean correct equipment and procedures can be adopted
IPMS 1 Definition
measuring the area of a building
including external walls
on floor-by-floor basis
IPMS 2 Definition
used for measuring the interior of an office to include
all areas available for direct use
measured to IDF
on floor-by-floor basis
IPMS 3 Definition
the floor area available
on an exclusive basis to an occupier
measured to IDF
excluding standard facilities
on floor-by-floor basis
IPMS 1 exclusions
upper void levels of an atrium
open external stairwells
patios
refuse areas
external parking at ground level
IPMS 2 exclusions
upper levels of void atrium
open light wells
patio and decks at ground level
external parking
equipment yards
refuse areas
IPMS 3 exclusions
standard facilities providing shared or common facilities e.g
stairs
lifts
WC’s
cleaner cupboards
plant rooms
IPMS 1,2 and 3 all include but state seperately
Covered galleries
balconies
generally accessible roof terraces
What things must RICS members do/comply with and keep information in a file on / in report with work that includes the measurement of buildings?
purpose of measurement instruction
date of measurement instruction
date of measurement
name of RICS M/F responsible for instruction
measurement standard adopted
measurement methodology / tool
reasons for departure of IPMS
floor area / scaled plans
unit of measurement and conversion factor
What are the differences between IPMS 3 and NIA?
IPMS includes pillars/columns
IPMS measures to IDF, NIA is to internal face
IPMS includes areas with heights of less than 1.5m
Where multiple occupiers on one floor, IPMS takes to midpoint of the partition
IPMS includes but states seperately: covered galleries and balconies and generaly accessible roof terraces
IPMS includes area occupied by reveals of window if they are the IDF, NIA does not but NIA does go to glazing if full height glazing unless window structure/design render space unusable ie at 6 Ramillies.
Define Internal dominant face (IDF)
the surface area of each IDF wall section comprisig 50% or more of the FTC height
*if this doesnt occur, the finished surface is the IDF
define Internal face
the brick/block work or plaster coat applied to the brick/block work, not the surface of internal linings installed by the occupier
define finished surface
the wall area directly above the horizontal wall/floor junction
IGNORES skirting, perimeter trunking, pipework or heating/cooling units.
define limited use area
an area whereby legal occupation is not possible e.g height restrictions or poor day light
define internal dominant finish wall section
each individual finish of an external wall that is either recesses or protrudes from the adjacent section
What are the aims of IPMS all buildings
- Establish consisent methodology for all building types around world
- promote international collaboration
- harmonises all buildings into single set of standards
- provide high level overarching standards on best practice in regard to property measurement
What is good about / useful about the COMPS 2015
Best practice for all asset types except for office and resi (as are in prof standard)
provides precise definitions - ensures a common and consistent approach
When is GEA used (COMPS 2015)
town planning
resi building cost estimations
council tax vals
When is GIA used (COMPS 2015)
estate agency
rating
building cost estimation for commercial assets
valuation of industrial warehouses
When is NIA used (COMPS 2015)
estate agency
rating
building cost estimation for commercial assets
valuation of industrial warehouses - is this true?
what does the GIA for industrial units include?
stairwells
lifts
permanent access mezz floors
loading bays
what does the GIA for industrial units exclude?
canopies
fire escapes
covered ways
If you are measuring a shop with full height partitioning what would you do?
try to remove ceiling tile or get behind the partitioning via gaps/holes
use scale floor plans
what is included for NIA for office buildings in COMPS 2015 (REMEMBER BUILDING NOT SINGLE FLOOR)
Notional lift lobbies
notional fire corridors
kitchens
built in cupboards etc occupying usable area
ramps/steps within usable areas and stated seperately
areas occupied by ventilation/heating grills
areas occcupied by skirting/perimeter trunking
areas occupied by non-structural walls subdividing accommoation in SOLE OCCUPANCY
what is excluded for NIA for office buildings in COMPS 2015 (REMEMBER BUILDING NOT SINGLE FLOOR)
WC’s
stairwells
areas less than 1.5m head height
cleaners rooms
plant and lift rooms
service cupboards and risers
areas rendered unusable with 0.25m gap to opposite face (ie 0.25m gap between column and wall)
if glazing is full height but renders space by it substantially unusable
space occupied by permanent A/C or heating and cooling apparatus
what is internal eaves height
clear height between floor and lowest point on underside of roof - ie at the eaves
how would you measured land?
trundle wheel
promaps - but check boundaries on site with OS Map or Land Reg prior. Promaps doesnt take into account elevation of land ie hillls
use trigonometry
what is a appropriate scale for A4 floor plan?
1:50-1:200
what is a appropriate scale for location/street plan?
1:1,250 - 1:2,000
Drawbacks of a disto / laser measure
can be distorted by sunlight and cant measure reflective surfaces
but is accurate to 1.5mm up to 200m away
What is NIA?
the usable area withing a building measured to the internal face of the perimeter walls at each floor level
includes:
- base of atria with clear height above
- entrance halls
- notional lift lobbies and fire corridors
- kitchens
- built in cupboards occupying usable area
- ramps, sloping areas and steps within usable area
- areas occ’d by ventilation/heating grills
- areas occ’d by skirting boards/perimeter trunking
- areas occ’d by non-structural walls subdiving accommodation in SOLE occupancy!
Excludes:
- WC’s
- lift and plant rooms
- staiwells and lift wells
- common area corridors
- internal structural walls
- columns
- areas with headroom less than 1.5m
- areas rendered substantially unusable with 0.25m distance between opposite faces
What is GIA?
the area of a building measured to the internal face of the perimeter walls at each floor level.
includes:
- area occupied by internal walls and partitions
- columns, stairwells, lift wells
- mezz floors with permanent access
- atria and entrance halls with clear height above (measured at base level ONLY)
- internal balconies
- structural or stepped floors (treated as level)
etc
Excludes:
- perimeter wall thickness
- external open-sided balconies
- external covered ways
- external fire escapes
- canopies
**so basically includes everthing but those 5 exclusions above
What is GEA?
The area of a building measured externally at each floor level.
Information required from client before commencing instruction (L+T)
Agreed TOE
understand client strategy/objectives
Get copy of lease and lease plans
copy of licenses e.g for alterations/improvments/sub lettings/deeds of variation
copy of RR memoranda
contact details to arrange inspections
L&T Fee structure types?
Fixed ie stage 1,2,3 et
Incentivised - ie % of saving / increase
Define without prejudice / what does it do and the benefits etc
Means during negotiations the opposing party CANNOT rely upon any document labelled without prejudice
the information is privileged and cannot be used as evidence to show to arbitrator / independent expert
Define subject to contract
means exactly that, it is subject to the contract
What is a tenancy at will?
form of licence
for unspecified time
LL can evict T at any time
NO legal interest in land
No right to renewal
example: allows a tenant early access to undertake fit out works
What is a licence and some of their featurea?
‘passes no interest in the land but makes legal what would otherwise be illegal’
e.g car park, pop-up shop in shopping centre
4 Features
- a right to enter property
- personal arrangement between licensor and licencee
- does not acquire any interest in the property
- can be terminated at any time
What are the 4 requirements of a lease?
Exclusive occupation
specified period of time
payment of rent
if over 3 YEARS terms must be in writing and signed as a deed
Differences between a lease and a licence?
Leases can be assigned - licences cannot
Leases terminated at lease events e.g breaks or RR or expiry - licences can be terminated at any time
Leases provide an interest/estate in the land - licences only allow the right to use it
What is case law surrounding Lease vs Licences?
Street vs Mountford (1985)
Deeming provision definition?
In older leases, some RR clauses required the LL to specify the rent in the trigger notice.
If the T does not serve a counter notice within specified time frame - the T will have deemed to accepted the new rent
what is a wayleave?
A temporary right
receives an annual payment
is personal to the company
cannot be transferred to new owner
e.g provides a right for a electricity company to install and maintain apparatus
What is an easement?
A permanent right
receives a capital payment
capable of being registered on land reg
A prescriptive right of way or prescriptive easement can be obtained due to:
continuous and uninterrrupted use proven over at least 20 years
A permissive right can be granted by landowner to allow access over the land
E.g. utility company allowing them to service pipes etc underground
What is adverse possession?
when someone who is not the legal owner of land can qualify to become the legal owner
through possession of the land over a specified period of time without landowners consent
If after 2003, is 10 years of occupation if the land is registered, if not, its 12 years
**this happened after land registration act 2003 where before it was 12 years for registered land
Headline clauses/RENT for RR?
uncommon as hard for LL to achieve a HLR at RR - UNLESS lease wording is explicit
Contents of a RR clause?
- basis of valuation ie UO / RPI or CPI linked or turnover rents
- 4 assumptions
- 3 disregards
- hypothetical lease term
- Time of the essence
what are the 4 ususal assumptions?
Property is available to let on open market between willing LL & T for term as stated in hypothetical lease term
Property is fit and available for immediate occupation
All covenants have been observed by the LL or T
The property may be used for its purpose set out in the lease
what are the 3 usual disregards?
Effect of goodwill with tenants occupation
Goodwill attached to the property
Tenant improvement (if LL consent granted for it)
what is the hypothetical lease term
the lease term assumed for RR purposes
can influence rental value
how do you know the hypothetical lease term / what if it isnt mentioned?
will be in the RR clause
unless the wording is explicit then ‘assumption of reality’ - ie you the residual of the term is the assumed hypothetical lease term
Case law regarding hypothetical lease term?
Canary Wharf (Three) Vs The Telegraph Group ltd (2003)
Ritz Hotel vs Ritz Casino (1989)
What is time of the essence?
the presumption that time is not of the essence UNLESS there are sufficient contradictions stating otherwise
It will say in the lease if it is or isnt of the essence
key case law surrounding time of the essence?
United Scientific Holding vs Burnley Borough Council (1978)
More recently
Bello vs Ideal View (2008)
- LL initiated RR 13 years after RR date but court held time was not of the essence so was fine
Post rent review date evidence case law?
Segama vs Penny Le Roy Ltd (1984)
- transactions can be used as comps if after RR date
BUT
post rent review events (ie covid 19) cannot be taken into account
What is the order of the hierarchy of evidence and wh coined in?
Reynold and Fenshaw in the ‘handbook of rent review’
open market letting
lease renewal
rent review
independent expert
arbitration
court determination
hearsay evidence
etc
What is without prejudice save as to costs?
without prejudice = as mentioned before cannot be used as evidence for other party
save as to costs = if you go to 3rd party and it was decided your opinion/valuation should have ben accepted, the costs incurred in that time frame goes to the other party who didn’t accept that Calderbank originally
Which terms of the lease effect the rent review?
- Lease term
- Breaks / RR frequency
- Alienation
- User clause – if restrictive which means restricted to a certain use. This decreases rental value as restricted on type of occupier – by how much….it depends
Functions / purposes of without prejudice save as to costs?
gives my client some protection against the costs of dispute resolution
can focus attention of parties to reach an agreement
what is a calderbank letter?
Written letter open for unconditional acceptance
is used for dispute RR’s - either party can serve one
what must be included in a calderbank?
genuine offer to settle (rent)
clear terms set out
a reasonable time frame for the opposing party to consider their proposal (normally 3 weeks)
must be capable of unconditional acceptance
clear client approval
do you label calderbank letters with subject to contract
No
calderbank case law?
calderbank vs calderbank (1975)
can calderbanks be used for lease renewals and what other options do parties have for lease renewals?
Yes - generally drafted by solicitors (but not always/dont have to be)
BUT ONLY FOR PROTECTED TENANCIES
or party can use Part 36 from Civil Procedure Rules
Must get legal advice on which to use and should be drafted and served by solictor as more prescriptive - to win you also need to win on all the terms whereas calderbanks you just need to win on the rent
can you serve more than one calderbank offer?
yes, can send as many as you want
calderbank benefits over Part 36
- part 36 more legal and Calderbank is more flexible
- part 36 you have to win on all of the terms not just some of them
- potentially carry greater cost sanctions
how do you know what dispute resolution is for each instruction?
it will be stated in the lease and so will the role of the dispute resolver ie arbitrator or independent expert
how much does it cost to appoint an abritrator/indep ex via RICS DRS?
£425.00
Arbitrator vs independent expert
Costs
Legislation
Evidence
Appeal
Negligence
Disclosure
CLEAN’D
Both should be experts in the given field/area
what role can a surveyor have in dispute resolution proceedings?
can act as an advocate or expert witness
How do you know if the arbitrator has the right to award costs
Stated in the arbitration act 1996, so ALWAYS has power to award costs
What is the difference between advocate and expert witness?
advocate can provide an opinion on value, BUT the expert witness can
advocate duty of care to client (and tribunal) whereas expert witness is to the tribunal
expert witness cannot work on a success related fee basis, advocate CAN
advocate must be independent, unbiased, within expertise, truthful
advocate must act properly and fairly and not let integrity be compromised