W6 Flashcards
The shift to the family as a locus of pathology
If serious problems cannot be
explained by a prevailing paradigm, efforts are made to expand or replace the
existing system.
This sort of scientific revolution and perspective shift occurred in the mid-1950s as
some clinicians were dissatisfied with slow progress when working with individual patients, or
frustrated when change in the patients was undermined by other family members.
They began to look at the family as the locus of pathology. Breaking away from the Traditional Focus on
individual Personality Characteristics and Behavior Patterns, they adopted a new perspective - a
family frame of reference - that provided a new way of conceptualizing human problems (especially the initial development of symptoms and their alleviation)
Organization and Wholeness in Systemic Therapy
Systems are composed of units that stand in some
consistent relationship to one another. Thus, we can infer that they are organized
around those relationships.
Units or elements, once combined, produce an entity (a
whole) that is greater than the sum of its parts.
Circular Causality
Family therapists prefer to think in terms of circular causality:
reciprocal actions which occur within a relationship network by means of interacting loops.
Any cause can be considered an effect of a previous cause, and becomes in tum the cause of a later event.
There is no use in figuring out how it started – we prefer to focus on interrupting the circle.
Feedback Loops
Families use feedback mechanisms to either maintain balance or instigate
change.
Negative feedback has a weakening effect (restoring equilibrium) whereas
positive feedback leads to further change by accelerating the deviation.
Familial Subsystems
Families are comprised of several coexisting subsystems in which members group
together to carry out certain family functions or processes.
Each family member is likely
to belong to several subsystems at the same time (i.e., siblings, parents, daughters, etc.,)
System Boundaries
Boundaries are invisible lines that separate a system, a subsystem, or an individual from its outside surroundings.
They serve protect the system’s integrity - distinguishing
between those considered insiders and those viewed as outsiders.
The Living Systems Perspective in the Present Day
Contemporary systems theorists rely on a living systems perspective (not mechanistic models) to
understand families.
Adopting systemic “habits of the mind” allows the family therapist to think using systemic concepts when working with families - in order to socially construct an understanding of that
family’s dynamics.
The Influence of Gender and Culture on Family Dynamics
Family therapists today examine how gender, culture, and ethnicity shape the perspectives and behavior patterns of family members. Men and women develop distinct behavioral expectations due to early indoctrination into gender-role behavior in their families, leading to different socialization experiences and different life outcomes.
Changes in work roles and family roles over the past 30 years have necessitated new male-female interactions and family adaptations (Barnett & Hyde, 2001).
Gender, cultural background, ethnicity, sexual identity. and socioeconomic status are intertwined, with each influencing and being influenced by the others. For instance, what it means to be male or female is shaped by factors like socioeconomic status, race, and ethnicity (Kliman. 2015).
Therapists must be cautious
not to reinforce stereotypical sexist and patriarchal attitudes or class differences. In the present day, there is greater focus on power, status, and position differences within families and society (Sue & Sue. 2016).
Understanding the
cultural context (race. ethnicity. social class. religion. sexual identity) and family organization
(stepfamily. single-parent family. LGBT couples. etc.) is essential in order to comprehensively assess family functioning. A multicultural framework acknowledges that attitudes and behavior patterns
are often deeply rooted in a family’s cultural background! (Sue & Sue. 2016).
Developing culturally sensitive therapy requires
therapists to move beyond the typical white, middle-class outlook and recognize that not all ethnic groups embrace values like self-sufficiency. independence. and individual development Therapists must understand how ethnic values influence child-rearing practices, intergenerational relationships.
and family boundaries (Prochaska & Norcross. 2014).
Culturally competent family therapists will be aware of
their own cultural filters, and avoid misdiagnosing or mislabeling unfamiliar family patterns as
abnormal! They should also avoid Overlooking or Minimizing deviant behavior by attributing it
solely to cultural differences (Madsen, 2007).
Systemic Therapy and Other Therapeutic Systems
Object relations family therapists search for unconscious relationship seeking from the past as the primary determinant of adult personality formation, whereas most family therapists deal with current interpersonal issues to improve overall family functioning.
Adlerian psychotherapy’s efforts to establish a child-guidance movement, as well as Adler’s
concern with improving parenting practices, reflect his interest beyond the individual to
family functioning. However, the individual focus of his therapeutic efforts fails to change
the dysfunctional family relationships that underlie individual problems (as achieved in systemic therapy)
Client-centered therapy’s humanistic outlook was particularly appealing to
experiential family therapists such as Satir and Whitaker, who believed families were stunted in their growth and would find
solutions if provided with a growth-facilitating therapeutic experience. Experiential family therapists are usually more directive than Rogerians, however, and in some cases they act as teachers to help families open up their communication processes.
Existential psychotherapies are phenomenological in nature, emphasizing the here and now. Considered by most family therapists
to be too concerned with the organized wholeness of the single person, this viewpoint has found a home with Kempler; who argued that people define themselves and their relationships with one another through their current choices and decisions and what they choose to become in
the future rather than through their reflections on the past.
Behavior therapists traditionally take a more linear view of causality in family interactions than systems theory advocates. A child’s tantrums, for example,
are viewed by behaviorists as maintained and reinforced by parental responses. Systems
theorists contrastingly view the tantrum as an interaction, including an exchange of feedback information, within a family system. Most behaviorists now acknowledge that cognitive factors (attitudes, thoughts, beliefs, expectations) influence behavior, and cognitive-behavior therapy has become a part of mainstream psychotherapy. However, rational emotive behavior therapy’s view that problems stem from maladaptive thought processes
seems too individually focused for most family therapists.
Three Key Precursory Theorists for Systemic Therapy
Sigmund Freud: Began early efforts to uncover and mitigate symptomatic behavior in
neurotic individuals. Freud acknowledged the impact of fantasy and family conflict on the individual, but he did avoid
involving the family in treatment
Alfred Adler: Emphasized the relevance of the family context for understanding neurotic behavior. Specifically, he highlighted the
importance of family constellation on personality formation (e.g., birth order, sibling rivalry)
Harry Stack Sullivan: Argued that people were the product of their
“relatively enduring patterns of recurrent interpersonal situations.” Hence, emphasized the role the family plays in interpersonal relations, particularly
in one’s formative years, and its enduring impact on current relationships (recurring interactive patterns)
General Systems Theory
Developed by von Bertalanffy and others.
A theoretical model which embraced all living
systems, and challenged the reductionist view in science at the time (that phenomena can be broken down into linear cause and effect reactions)
General systems theory posits that Interrelations
between parts assumes a far greater significance. A recognition of this is seen in family systems
concepts like circular causality
Group Therapy (Family Therapy)
John Bell developed family group therapy.; applying social psychological theories to the
family as a naturally occurring group.
Family therapists involve entire families in therapy, believing that kinship groups provide more real
situations which can incite powerful and lasting system changes.
Early Research on Schizophrenia and its Relationship with Family Therapy
Researchers began in the 1950s to study schizophrenia as a disorder where family influences might relate to psychotic symptoms. Early efforts focused on linear views of causes, but later expanded into a broader systems point of view. These efforts laid a foundation for systemic analysis of family functioning.
Current views on schizophrenia emphasize genetic predispositions which can be exacerbated by environmental
stressors.
> Bateson and colleagues identified double-bind communication patterns within families which lead
to confusion and withdrawal in children. Double-bind situations exist when an individual, usually a child, habitually receives simultaneous contradictory messages from the
same important person, typically a parent, and is forbidden to comment on
the contradiction (no matter how you react you will have made some sort of mistake - lose-lose - naturally produces conflict). Bateson also explored communication process and the importance of context in assigning meaning to information (“differences that make a difference”)
> Lidz and colleagues hypothesized that schizophrenics
did not receive the nurturing they needed necessary as children, leading to autonomy conflicts in adulthood. The marital discord often responsible for this was marital skew; extreme domination by one emotionally disturbed partner that is
accepted by the other - implying to the children that the situation is normal. In the marital schism scenario, parents undermine their spouses, threats of divorce are common, and each parent fights for the loyalty and affection of the children.
> Bowen studied symbiotic mother-child bonds which had been hypothesized to lead to schizophrenia - observing
emotional intensity and reciprocal functioning in families (family emotional system)
> Wynne studied blurred, ambiguous, and
confused communication patterns In families with schizophrenic members - describing
pseudomutualilty as a false sense of family closeness.
The Early Contributions of Ackerman
Nathan Ackerman argued for family sessions to untangle interlocking pathologies; endorsing the systems view that problems of any one family member cannot be understood apart from others.
Ackerman’s work demonstrated the applicability of family therapy to less disturbed patients and contributed to the founding of the
journal “Family Process”.
Minuchin and Delinquent Families
Salvador Minuchin led a project at the Wiltwyck School for Boys; developing brief, action-oriented therapeutic procedures to help reorganize unstable family structures for delinquent youngsters from poor, fatherless homes.
Current Trends in Family Therapy
Eclecticism and Integration: Due to the recognition that no single technique fits all clients
or situations. there is a trend toward eclecticism and integration of therapeutic
approaches.
Multisystemic Evidence-Based Approaches: Therapists are using research-based approaches; borrowing from each other’s theories to treat a variety of behavioral and emotional problems in adolescents and families.
Family Therapies for Delinquency and Recidivism
Sexton’s Functional Family Therapy: Aimed at treating delinquency and reducing recidivism, this approach offers systems-based, cost-effective programs.
Henggeler and Schaeffer’s Multisystemic Therapy: Also aimed at treating delinquency
and reducing recidivism. This approach has garnered considerable research support.
Eight Theoretical Viewpoints and Approaches to Family Therapy
O.N.E S.S.S C.T
- Object Relations Family Therapy
- Experiential Family Therapy
- Transgenerational Family Therapy
- Structural Family Therapy
- Strategic Family Therapy
- Cognitive-Behavior Family Therapy
- Social Constructionist Family Therapy
- Narrative Therapy
Object Relations Family Therapy (+ Personality Perspective)
The need for satisfying relationships with others is viewed as a fundamental motive of life.
This approach focuses on how introjects (memories of loss or
unfulfillment from childhood) affect current relationship - with the aim of helping family members gain insight into their own internalized objects from the past.
[PERSPECTIVE ON PERSONALITY] = (Hughes and Scharff)
> Emphasizes the role played by attachment needs and unresolved conflicts from childhood.
Believes that people seek emotional bonding based on early experiences.
> Investigates “object loss” and its impact on adult relationships. If one’s relational needs are unmet
by parents or other caregivers, then the child will internalize both the characteristics of
the lost object and the accompanying anger and resentment over the loss. The resulting
unresolved unconscious conflict develops into frustration and self-defeating habits in
the adult, who continues unconsciously and unsuccessfully to choose intimate partners
to repair early deprivation.
> Addresses unconscious conflicts leading to self-defeating habits
Experiential Family Therapy
Believes troubled families need growth experiences derived from
intimate interpersonal experiences ,with therapists.
Focuses on being real or authentic to help family members learn to be more honest and expressive of their feelings and needs.
Transgenerational family therapy
Argues that family members are tied in thinking, feeling, and behavior to the family system; leading to individual problems arising and being maintained by
relationship connections.
Emphasizes the importance of differentiating the self from the family to resist being overwhelmed by emotional reactivity.
Structural Family Therapy
Focuses on how families are organized and what rules govern members’ transactions.
Challenges rigid and repetitive transactions within a family to help unfreeze them; and allow family reorganization.