VLE Flashcards
What defines expectations and obligations of participants in the doctor patient relationship?
Social roles which change over time
Shaped by culture
What natures of the doctor patient relationship are important?
Qualitative and subjective nature
What are the 3 types of Doctor patient relationships?
Paternalistic - doctor led
Shared - partnership
Informed - patient led
In the paternalistic doctor patient relationship, what is the patients role?
Passive, answers questions and expectation that they will agree with doctors decisions as doctor knows best
In the paternalistic doctor patient relationship, what is the doctors role?
Makes systematic enquiry
Information flow from doctor to patient
Makes decision about what is best for patient
Doctor knows best
When is a paternalistic model appropriate?
In a medical emergency
If patient wants this model
What are the social roles in a shared doctor patient relationship?
Two way sharing of info at all stages
Both participants bring expertise and have limitations to knowledge
Reach decision together
What could be challenging for a doctor in the shared doctor patient relationship?
Creating environment in which patient feels able to share preferences
Negotiation if there is a disagreement in the best options for the patient
Patient access to information eg can they access the Internet?
Patient ability to process complex information
Communication difficulties
What is the doctors role in the informed model of the doctor patient relationship?
Communicate all relevant information about treatment options, risks and benefits. Must be sufficient for patient to make informed decision
What is the role of the patient in the informed model of the doctor patient relationship?
Patient is active and expects to make the decision
Sole prerogative of patient is decision making
When might the informed model of doctor patient relationship be most common in the UK?
Private healthcare
Which model of doctor patient relationship is key to person centred care?
Shared decision making
What may guide the choice of doctor patient relationship that you choose to adopt in a given situation?
Patient preference
Clinical situation
Why is the choice of doctor patient relationship style important?
Fits with ethical stance emphasising patient autonomy and respect for persons
What ethical principle underpins the paternalistic model of doctor patient relationship?
Beneficence
What ethical principle underpins the informed model of doctor patient relationship?
Respect for autonomy
How can information decrease autonomy?
Information overload
Autonomy requires that the patient is able to use the information to make a choice
Why is there a potential for increased psychological harm of living with poor outcome in the informed model of doctor patient relationship?
Responsibility for consequences of the decision rests solely on the patient
How could the informed model of doctor patient relationship result in doctor making the decision?
Patient may make informed choice that the doctor should make the decision on their behalf
How can the information presented, influence decisions made by the patient in the informed model of the doctor patient relationship?
Manipulation of decision by the order or way in which they are given the information. Can a decision ever be truly free from interference?
Risk of persuasion or coercion, even if accidentally
What are the main pros of the shared model of the doctor patient relationship?
Facilitates autonomy
Shared responsibility for decisions
Includes both experts perspectives
Involves dialogue
What does the ethical principle of justice say about shared decision making?
Must ensure it is available to everyone, even if it may be difficult
What is contemporaneous treatment refusal and what caveats does it require?
Anyone aged 16 or over is assumed to have capacity to give or refuse consent and a doctor must demonstrate lack of capacity before treating without consent
An adult with capacity may refuse life sustaining treatment and continuation of life sustaining treatment without consent is unlawful
In what circumstances may a contemporaneous refusal of treatment be overridden?
Mental Health Act 1983 (2007)
Children under 16 years
? Young people aged 16-18 years