US Supreme court Flashcards
How many justices are their in the SC?
9 One chief justice and eight associate justices
Who nominates supreme court justices?
By the president but need to be confirmed by a simple majority vote of the senate
How long are justices appointed for?
Life, usually leave voluntarily, resignation or on dying
If necessary they can be impeached, and if found guilty removed the office
Who’s the chief Justice?
John Roberts Appointed by George Bush in 2005
Is the supreme court in the US more established than the UK Supreme Court?
Yes, as UK was only founded in 2009
What are the 2 main strands of judicial philosophy?
Strict constructionists/originalists
Loose constructionists/living constitution
Originalism tends to:
- interpret the constitution in a strict, literal fashion
- favour state government rights over federal government power
- lead to an outcome that is often seen as being ‘conservative’
- Try to interpret the constitution in line with its or final meaning and intent
- Be appointed by republican presidents
Loose constructionists tend to:
- interpret the constitution in a loose fashion
- favour federal government power over state government rights
- read elements into the document that they think the framers would have approved of
- see the constitution as a living, dynamic document, which should be adapted to take account of the views of contemporary society
- Seen as liberal justices
- appointed by democratic presidents
A loose constructionist appointed by a liberal justice?
Sonia sotomayor
Obama
A strict constructionist appointed by a republican president?
Brett Kavanaugh Trump
What’s a swing justice? and example
a justice that’s quite liberal
Justice Anthony Kennedy
Define strict constructionist
A supreme court justice who interprets the constitution, strictly or literally and tends to stress the retention of power by individual states
Define originalism
Where a supreme court justice interprets the constitution in line with the meaning or intent of the framers at the time of enactment
Define loose constructionists
A supreme court justice who interprets the constitution less literally and tends to stress the broad grants of power to the federal government
Define living constitution
The constitution considered as a dynamic, living document, interpretation of which should take account of the views of contemporary society
Define liberal justice
A SC justice who is usually a loose constructionist and generally interprets the constitution in ways that give people more freedom
Define swing justice
The pivotal justice in an otherwise evenly balanced court, who will often be in a position of casting the deciding vote
What’s the appointment process?
- A vacancy occurs
- The president instigates a search for possible nominees and interviews shortlisted candidates
- The president announces their nominee
- The Senate judiciary committee holds confirmation hearings on the nominee and makes a recommendatory
- The nomination is debated and voted on in the full senate. A simple majority vote is required for confirmation
What are the factors that affect a presidents choice of nominee?
- Shares a similar judicial philosophy to the president
- Is quite young, meaning they are likely to remain on the court for longer
- is likely to be acceptable to a majority of the senate (especially important if the presidents party is in the minority)
- has an uncontroversial background - from both a judicial and personal point of view
- if going to be highly rated professionally
- has relevant experience
How has the confirmation process changed over recent years?
supreme court nominees used to be approved mostly by overwhelmingly bipartisan votes
Nowadays although rejections are still rare, confirmation votes are much more likely to be along party lines
Criticisms of the appointment process? Political nominations
Presidents have tended to politicise the nominations by attempting to choose justices who share their political views and judicial philosophy
EXAMPLE obama with Kagan
Criticisms of the appointment process? Senate political
The senate has tended to politicise the confirmation process by focussing more on hot button issues eg womens rigjts than on qualifications
What are some criticisms of the appointment process?
Senate judiciary committee
Members of the senate judiciary committee from the presidents party tend to ask soft questions of the nominee
Criticisms of the appointment process? Opposition senate judiciary committee
Members of the senate judiciary committee, from the opposition party attempt, through their questions, to attack or embarrass the nominee rather to elicit relevant information
Criticisms of the amendment process?
Party Lines and media
Justices are now frequently confirmed on party line voted
Eg Kavanaugh
The media conduct a feeding frenzy often connected with matters of trivia
Why are judicial appointments often regarded as the most important nominations?
- they occur infrequently
- they are for life
- just one new appointee to a 9 member body can significantly change its philosophical balance
- the SC had the power of judicial review
- their decisions will profoundly affect the lives of ordinary Americans for generations to come