US pressure groups Flashcards
What is political pluralism?
A political philosophy that emphasises the benefits of many different groups including the decision-making process.
Government takes into account the views of people from across the whole of society, many of whom are represented by pressure groups
What is the traditional motto displayed on the Great Seal of the United States?
‘e pluribus unum’
meaning ‘out of many, one’
It illustrates the USA’s fundamental challenge: How to forge a united nation and a coherent government from such a diverse range of people, states and ideas
How has the USA become more pluralistic since the framers?
Framers were white, wealthy and protestant - only voices that were heard
Over time a broader range of female, WC, minority ethnic communities and diverse religious voices began to gain an audience
YET their struggle to be heard on equal terms continues today
Which amendment includes ‘the right of the people to peacefully assemble’?
1st Amendment
Give two pressure groups that are diametrically opposed to each other:
Americans United for Life (pro-life) vs Planned Parenthood (pro-choice)
PP although not a pressure group it is a major health provider that operates as an interest group
What do pluralists argue about democracy?
That it is healthy for democracy as it allows the people and the government to hear both sides of the argument and reach the best decisions after public debate and consideration
What 2 major social changes would not have happened without PGs?
Legalisation of abortion
Desegregation (NAACP)
What is a key issue with pressure groups needing money to spend on advertising, legal challenges, professional lobbyists and electoral campaign spending?
It means in effect the country is still run by a powerful elite (e.g. the NRA is the most influential PG)
What are the four typologies of PGs and give an example for each:
- Insider - AMA, US Chamber of Commerce and NRA
- Outsider - Climate Direct Action
- Promotional - Greenpeace USA, Everytown for Gun Safety and ACLU
- Interest - US Chamber of Commerce, NAACP, AFL-CIO and Christian Coalition of America
What is the term ‘interest group’ also sometimes applied to?
Large corporations if they are acting in a similar way to pressure groups by lobbying the executive and funding electoral campaigns
What is a social movement, and give some examples:
Much less formalised PGs with no clear hierarchy of formal membership
Began in the 19th century
Women’s movement, labour movement, ‘new social movements’ such as the environment movement and anti-nuclear movement
Social media: BLM, #MeToo, #Cecilthelion
What are the 5 main methods and tactics used by PGs to influence decision-making?
- Electoral campaigning
- Lobbying
- Using the courts
- Grassroots campaigning
- Direct action
Which PG in 2018 spent $85 million on electoral campaigning, more than any other single-issue group? Did it achieve its aim?
League of Conservation Voters
Yes of winning back the House for the Democrats
How do PGs contribute to electoral campaigning?
Endorsing candidates
Making campaign donations
Releasing voting ‘scorecards’ (League’s Dirty Dozen)
Because the amount of official campaigns can raise is limited, PGs often give to PACs and Super PACS
Which PG aims to ignite change by getting pro-choice Democratic women elected to office, and how much did they spend on digital campaigning for Kamala Harris in 2020?
EMILY’s List (Early money is like yeast)
$5.5 million
What scorecard do the NRA release? Give an example of an A+ ranking:
A-F
Incumbent Mike Kelly
What senator has received $14 million in funding from the NRA?
Rep Mitt Romney
(synoptic link) How did Mitt Romney vote on the Wormn’s Health Protection Act 2021 which would have made it statutory for health providers to provide abortion services?
Against the bill
What is lobbying?
Process where PGs attempt to exert influence onto members of the executive or legislature
Happens more in the USA because of the vast range of access points at both state and federal level
PGs share detailed and up-to-date knowledge of their policy area and therefore are a useful source of info
Where is the right to lobbying protected?
In the Constitution’s 1st Amendment
‘Right to petition the government for a redress of grievances’ (a grievance is a complaint)
Give an example of a PG with insider contacts:
K Street corridor of influence
Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan had 350 meetings with federal agencies from 2010 to 2012 after the 2008/09 financial crisis - wanted to make sure any measures implemented did not disadvantage them
How much was spent on federal lobbying in 2019 vs 2023:
2019 - $3.47 billion
2023 - $4.2 billion
Where are professional lobbyists clustered around?
The ‘K Street corridor of influence’ in Washington DC
Spending for lobbying is often concentrated on the issue of the day. Who did companies and business PGs lobby regarding Trump’s new trade deal with Mexico and Canada?
The government
How much was spent in 2010 over the Affordable Care Act by healthcare companies?
$3.51 billion
What evidence shows that lobbying is effective?
One study estimated lobbying spending by US corporate groups led to $90 million of subsidies for businesses
Give an example of the revolving door taking place where someone used to work within the executive/legislative and then went to work for lobbying firms:
Lawyer Eugene Scalia first worked for the Bush administration before lobbying on behalf of the US chamber of commerce and represented companies such as Goldman Sachs
What 2 acts attempted to regulate lobbying to ensure it wasn’t elitist?
Lobbying Disclosure Act 1995
Open Government Act 2007
Lobbying MUST be disclosed and ‘gifts’ have tight restrictions around them
However how can it be seen as elitist?
US chamber of Commerce has great influence because it spends more on lobbying than any other organisation ($77 million in 2019)
It successfully convinced Congress to pass the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement
However what could the US Chamber of Commerce NOT convince Trump’s administration to do?
Reverse tariffs on goods from China and the EU despite the negative impact of tariffs on US businesses
Although Trump claimed he would ‘drain the swamp’, how many lobbyists did he hire to work in his government (4 times more than Obama hired in 6 years!)
281
Which lobbying firm did Trump have close ties with? Who did they lobby on behalf of Trump?
Ballard Partners - named the most powerful lobbyist in Trump’s Washington
They lobbied the Florida state government - top spender in 2024 with $8.55 million
Successfully lobbied congress with the American Innovation Choice Online Act 2022
Once Trump became president they gained 100 clients in less than 2 years earning more than $28 million
Also an example of revolving door syndrome as many precision worked for the executive or legislature