Untitled Deck Flashcards
What does conformity mean?
A person changes their beliefs and/or behaviour in response to group pressure from the majority.
- E.g an individual may pretend to enjoy an artist’s music because all their friends like and listen to it.
What are the three different types of conformity?
Compliance, Identification, Internalisation
What is compliance? Compliance is a type of conformity whereby an individual changes their behaviour to fit in with the
Compliance is a type of conformity whereby an individual changes their behaviour to fit in with the majority
Is compliance public or private?
Only public - meaning that they maintain a different private view.
- Compliance is only temporary. Once the majority group is no longer present, they returns back to their original behaviour.
- Compliance is the shallowest type of conformity.
E.g. Teenager smoking when with their friends even though they don’t like it and never smoke when alone.
What is identification?
Individual changes their behaviour and beliefs because they are a member of a group and have a role to play.
Is identification public or private?
- Both public and private as they look to their group for guidance on how they should behave.
- Can be temporary > behaviours and beliefs can change over time if the individual is no longer a member of that group.
- Identification is a deeper than compliance but shallower than internalisation.
EXAMPLE: - An individual changing their football team from Liverpool FC to Manchester United because they moved from Liverpool to Manchester and now identify as a Mancunian.
What is internalisation?
- The majority viewpoint has become a part of their own belief system.
Is internalisation public or private? Both public and private.
- Both public and private.
- Permanent type of conformity as it lasts even if the majority is no longer present.
- Internalisation is the deepest level of conformity.
- EXAMPLE: an individual permanently converting to veganism because they have internalised the belief that consuming meat is morally wrong.
What are the two explanations for conformity?
Normative social influence (NSI) and Informational social influence (ISI).
What is NSI?
- Individuals conform to the majority to be liked and accepted by the group to avoid not fitting it or being ridiculed.
What does NSI result in? It typically results in compliance whereby the individual publicly changes their behaviour despite maintaining a different private view. NSI tends to have a temporary effect.
- An individual continuing to drink even though they feel sick because they do not want their friends to think they cant handle their alcohol.
What’s ISI? Individuals conform to the majority because they lack knowledge of how to behave so look to the majority for guidance because they want to be right when the correct answer or right thing to do is ambiguous.
- The individual conforms to avoid the embarrassment of being wrong.
What does ISI result in? - ISI typically results in internalisation whereby the individual both publicly and privately changes their behaviour and beliefs. ISI tends to have a permanent effect.
- An example of ISI would be a student accepting an answer they initially thought was wrong because the class agreed on it and are more likely to be right.
What is the aim of Asch’s (1951) original conformity research? To see if participants conform to a majority in an unambiguous situation (where the correct answer should be obvious).
What is the procedure of Asch’s (1951) original conformity research? 123 male American college students volunteered to take part in a study investigating ‘visual perception’.
- In the lab room
7 male student participants looked
at two cards: the test card displaying one vertical line
and the comparison card displaying three vertical lines of different lengths.
- The participants called out in turns which of the three lines was the same length as the test line. All of the participants were confederates (accomplices of the researcher) except the one who sat second from last who was a real participant. All
of the confederates gave unanimous wrong answers on 12 of the 18 trials. These 12 trails were called the critical trials.
What is the findings of Asch’s (1951) original conformity research? - On average
participants conformed to the unanimous incorrect answer provided by the confederates on 32% of the
critical trials.
- 74% of participants conformed at least once
meaning 26% never conformed.
In post-research interviews
some participants stated they conformed because they believed the confederates were
correct. In contrast
others stated they conformed because they did not want to risk being ridiculed or excluded by the
group.
What is the conclusion of Asch’s (1951) original conformity research? Even when the situation is unambiguous
people still conform to group pressure. There also appears to be different
reasons for conforming - wanting to fit in and wanting to be correct.
What are the different variables that affect conformity? Group size
unanimity and task difficulty.
What was the procedure of Asch’s variations of his original conformity research on group size? In Asch’s original conformity research
there was a majority of
six (i.e. six confederates). Asch therefore investigated group size by varying the number of confederates.
What was the findings of Asch’s variations of his original conformity research on group size? Asch found that conformity rates increased with group size.
However
this effect was only seen up until there was a majority
of three people. After this
conformity rates plateaued (levelled
off) despite any increases in the size of the majority.
What was the conclusion of Asch’s variations of his original conformity research on group size? These findings suggests that a small majority is sufficient for
majority influence to be exerted.
What was the procedure of Asch’s variations of his original conformity research on unanimity? In Asch’s original conformity research
the confederates gave unanimous incorrect answers on 12 out of the 18
trials. Asch then varied unanimity in two ways:
- Asch instructed one of the confederates to give a different answer to the rest of the group. This answer was the
correct answer.
- Asch instructed one of the confederates to give a different answer to the rest of the group. But this time the
answer was another incorrect answer.
What was the findings of Asch’s variations of his original conformity research on unanimity? In the first unanimity variation whereby the confederate gave the different correct answer
Asch found that conformity rates reduced from 32% (as seen in his original conformity research) to 5.5%. Asch also found that conformity rates still reduced to 9% in the second unanimity variation whereby the confederate gave a different incorrect answer.
What was the conclusion of Asch’s variations of his original conformity research on unanimity? The higher conformity rates in the original research suggests that a unanimous majority exerts the most influence.
However
by breaking the unanimity of the majority (regardless of whether the new answer is right or wrong)
What was the procedure of Asch’s variations of his original conformity research on task size? Asch made the line judgement task more difficult by making the stimulus line and comparison lines more similar in length. This therefore made it more difficult for participant to identify which comparison line was the same length as the stimulus line.
What was the findings of Asch’s variations of his original conformity research on task size? Asch found that conformity rates increased as the line judgement task was made more difficult.
What was the conclusions of Asch’s variations of his original conformity research on task size? Conformity rates increase in ambiguous tasks when naïve participants are more likely to look to the majority for guidance.
What does conformity to social roles mean? Conformity to social roles means changing your behaviour to suit that of the role you are given in a situation or society. It can
therefore be used to explain identification as a type of conformity.
What does conformity to social roles results from? Deindividuation and Situational factors
What does deindividuation mean? When an individual loses their sense of individual identity
their moral constraints on their behaviour are loosened. This makes them more likely to conform to social roles expected of them
What does situational factors mean? Variables in the environment can trigger or cause a change in behaviour e.g. providing a person with a uniform can influence them to conform to the social role that is expected of people who wear that uniform.
What’s the aim of Zimbardo’s research into conformity to social roles? To investigate how readily people would conform to new roles assigned to them.
What’s the procedure of Zimbardo’s research into conformity to social roles? 24 well adjusted
healthy American male volunteers took part in a two-week simulation study of prison life. Volunteers completed psychological evaluations and those deemed most psychologically healthy were randomly allocated to being either a guard or a prisoner. The local police helped by arresting prisoners at their homes without warning. They were then taken to the mock prison which was set up in the basement of Stanford University. Once there
guards who were given a uniform including reflective sunglasses. They were informed they had complete power over the prisoners however no physical aggression was permitted.
What’s the findings of Zimbardo’s research into conformity to social roles? - The prisoners rebelled against the guards after 2 days
however
extinguishers.
- Some of the prisoners became depressed and anxious
causing mental breakdowns.
- The guards harassed the prisoners and conformed to their perceived roles with such dedication (e.g. attempting to