Unit 4: Scots Criminal Law: Introduction and Investigation Flashcards
Principles of Suspect Interviewing
Preparation and planning Rapport building Information gathering Clarifying and confirming account Evaluating - Challenges
Definition of…
Abettor
A person who invites, instigates, encourages, or counsels another to commit a crime or offence
Definition of…
Accessory
Anyone who aids the perpetrator with advice or assistance, before or at the time of the crime, or who acts in concert by watching whilst the crime or offence is committed
Definition of…
Assault
A crime at common law, and is every attack directed to take effect physically on the person of another, whether or not actual injury is inflicted
Definition of…
Attempt to Pervert the Course of Justice
A crime at common law, which can described as any overt and intentional action calculated to interfere with either the normal investigation of a crime, or the bringing of an offender to justice
Definition of…
Breach of the Peace
A crime at common law, and is constituted by one or more persons conducting himself or themselves in a riotous or disorderly manner, where such conduct is severe enough to cause alarm to ordinary people and threaten serious disturbance to the community
Definition of…
Culpable and Reckless Fireraising
Is committed when property is set on fire as a result of a reckless act by the accused
Definition of…
Forgery and Uttering
A crime at common law, and consists in the making and publishing of a writing feloniously intended to represent and pass for the genuine writing of another person
Definition of…
Fraud
Falsehood - False representation by word of mouth or writing or false conduct
Fraud - Intention to deceive and defraud
Wilful Imposition - What is required is that there is a practical result, i.e. inducing a person to do what they would otherwise not have done
Definition of…
House
Includes any dwelling house or other roofed building, finished or unfinished, or any part of a building used as a separate dwelling, which is secured against intrusion by unauthorised persons.
Definition of…
Malicious Mischief
A crime at common lase constituted by wilful, wanton, and malicious destruction of, or damage to the property of another.
Definition of…
Offensive Weapon
Includes any article made or adapted for the use of causing injury to the person, or intended by the person having it with them for such use by either themselves or by some other person
Definition of…
Perjury
Perjury is a crime at common law, committed by any person who wilfully makes a false statement under oath or any affirmation equivalent to oath.
Definition of…
Principal
The person who actually commits the crime or offence
Definition of…
Subornation of Perjury
Crime at common law, committed by any person who counsels or induces, by any means, a person to give false testimony in judicial proceedings
Definition of…
Reset
A crime at common law committed by any person with intent to deprive the owner, to receive and keep property, knowing that it had been appropriated by theft, robbery, embezzlement or fraud.
Definition of…
Robbery
A crime at common law committed by any person who feloniously appropriates property, by means of violence or threats of violence.
Definition of…
Theft
A crime at common lase and is the taking or appropriating of property without the consent of the rightful owner or other lawful authority
Definition of…
Vandalism
An offence for any person to wifully or recklessly destroy or damage the property of another without reasonable excuse
Definition of…
Wasting Police Time
A crime at common law, committed by any person who maliciously makes a false statement to the police, with the intention and effect of causing unnecessary police investigation
Definition of…
Wilful Fireraising
Committed when a person intentionally sets fire to any form of property
1: Crimes of Disorder
Define the crime of Breach of the Peace
A crime at common law and is constituted by one or more persons conducting himself or themselves in a riotous or disorderly manner, where such conduct is severe enough to cause alarm to ordinary people and threaten serious disturbance to the community
1: Crimes of Disorder
Essential elements for Breach of the Peace
- Breach of the Peace is a common law crime
- It can be committed by one or a number of people
- The conduct of the person, or persons, must be riotous or disorderly
- The conduct must be serious or severe enough to cause alarm to ordinary people, and threaten serious disturbance to the community
- It can occur anywhere, but there must be a public element to it, or a real risk of such behaviour in private being discovered, i.e. shouting and screaming in your own home in the middle of the night may disturb neighbours.
1: Crimes of Disorder
What is riotous conduct?
Where there is an element of noise, rowdyism, wild or violent behaviour.
1: Crimes of Disorder
What is Disorderly Conduct?
Actions or behaviour that would place an ordinary person in a state of alarm, or cause them to be seriously disturbed. Behaviour that is outwith what is ‘normal’ and acceptable.
Context is important, however. Fans shouting and swearing at a football match would not be outwith the bounds of ‘normal’ for that environment. The same behaviour in a school car park, or at a funeral, probably would be.
1: Crimes of Disorder
Effect on the public
Conduct of the accused must be severe enough to cause (or threaten to cause) genuine alarm or serious disturbance (not just irritation).
Such conduct on its own would be unlikely to cause alarm to a police officer, and would likely not constitute Breach of the Peace. If other witnesses are present, however, that may be enough to qualify.
1: Crimes of Disorder
What constitutes a Public Element?
Any public event or place where the public are present, or any private place where the behaviour may be overheard or discovered by the public in a public place.
1: Crimes of Disorder
Outline the offence of Threatening and Abusive behaviour (Section 38 of the Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010)
It is an offence to:
Behave in a threatening or abusive manner, where such behaviour is likely to cause a reasonable person to suffer fear or alarm.
Applies where the accused intends to cause fear or alarm, or is reckless as to whether their behaviour would lead to fear or alarm.
It can be committed by one person, or multiple people
It can be committed anywhere, including a private dwelling
It does not require a public element
1: Crimes of Disorder
What are the Police Powers in relation to crimes of disorder?
Breach of the Peace is a common law offence and is therefore punishable by imprisonment. Arrest under S1 of the Criminal Justice Act 2016.
Threatening and Abusive behaviour is breach of S38 of the Criminal Justice Licensing Act 2010 and is also punishable by imprisonment.
Discretion is available for Direct Means, but must be justified.
1: Crimes of Disorder
What are the statutory alternatives to Breach of the Peace?
Section 127A of the Communications Act 2003 - Dick pics
Section 127B of the Communications Act 2003 - Bullying and Harassment
Section 1-4 Emergency Workers Act 2005 - 999 Hoax Calls
Chapter 7 of the Fire Act 2005 - 999 Hoax Calls
1: Crimes of Disorder
Essentials of Stalking
An offence is committed when a person engages in conduct (on at least 2 occasions):
Intended to case fear or alarm
Person ought to have known action would or could cause fear or alarm
It does cause fear or alarm
1: Crimes of Disorder
Conduct which may constitute stalking
Following the victim Contact/attempted contact of victim Publishing material purporting to originate from the victim Monitoring social media Entering premises associated with victim Loitering Interfering with property Unsolicited gifts Watching or spying
1: Crimes of Disorder
Investigation of stalking (behaviours)
Four distinct behaviours
Fixated
Obsessive
Unwanted
Repeated
2: Crimes of violence
Categories of assault
Direct - Deliberate physical attack
Indirect - Attack with a dog etc
Assault with menaces (threatening gestures/behaviour)
2: Crimes of violence
Aggravating factors of assault
Danger to victim Intent Mode of perpetration Person’s character Locus of assault Extent of injury Statutory Hate Crime
2: Crimes of violence
When is an assault justifiable?
When it is done under authority of the law
Self defence (not property)
Minimum necessary force
2: Crimes of violence
Statutory examples of assault
Section 1 of Protection of Workers Act 2021 - Retail workers etc (Covid)
Section 90 of Police and Fire Reform Act 2012 - Police officers
Section 1 of Emergency Workers Act 2005 - Police, ambulance, fire service, NHS etc (includes non physical, and directed at vehicles and equipment)
2: Crimes of violence
Definition of Culpable and Reckless conduct
Reckless acts which cause, or carry genuine risk of, injury to others
3: Accession
Define principal, accessory and abettor
Principal - the person who commutes the offence
Accessory - someone who helps, advises, or assists in planning or carrying out the crime
Abettor - someone who instigates the crime
3: Accession
The importance of guilty knowledge
Guilt exists where someone has knowledge of a specific crime or offence prior to the act
No accession after a crime has been committed
4: Crimes Against Public Justice
Define the common law crime of Wasting Police Time
Committed by any person who maliciously makes a false statement to the police, with the intention and effect of causing unnecessary police investigation
4: Crimes Against Public Justice
Essential elements of Wasting Police Time
Damage is caused to the public interest by diverting police resources from normal duties due to needless investigation
4: Crimes Against Public Justice
Define the common law crime of Attempting to Pervert the Course of Justice
Any overt and intentional action calculated to interfere with either the normal investigation of a crime, or the bringing of an offender to justice
4: Crimes Against Public Justice
Define the common law crime of Perjury
Wilfully making a false statemeny under oath, or affirmation equivalent to oath
4: Crimes Against Public Justice
Essential elements of Perjury
Falsehood must be made under oath
It must be proved to be false
It must relate to evidence of fact - it is not perjury to misrember or misunderstand
It must be direct an unequivocal
It must be relevant - it is not perjury if the evidence is irrelevant or incompetent
4: Crimes Against Public Justice
Define the common law crime of Subornation of Perjury
Counselling or inducing, by any means, a person to give false testimony in judicial proceedings
4: Crimes Against Public Justice
Define the common law crime of Attemped Subornation of Perjury
The attempt is complete as soon as any incitement or inducement has been made
4: Crimes Against Public Justice
Define Contempt of Court
An intentional disrespect for, or action against, the authority of the court.
4: Crimes Against Public Justice
Examples of Attempting to Pervert the Course of Justice
Active destruction or concealment of evidence
Requesting a witness to refrain from identifying the accused (intimidation or inducement)
Assisting an accused to evade the police
Tampering with blood samples or other evidence
Lying to the police in the course of their investigation
Supplying false details
5.1: Acquisitive Crimes - Theft
Define the common law crime of Theft
The taking or appropriating of property without the consent of the rightful owner, or other lawful authority