Unit 4 Flashcards
FPTP / SMDP / Winner takes all
SMDP is a system of elections where a candidate is chosen by their party to show up on the ballot. FPTP is when Candidates win if they receive the MOST votes. (either SMDP FPTP or SMDP majoritarian)
What are the pros of SMDP?
Encourages regional representation and a stable and effective government that keeps the representatives accountable as they represent their constituents.
They also prevent extremist group coming to power.
What are the cons of SMDP?
It does not maximize voter participation and does not guarantee fairness within elections. There is no representation of the minorities of the state and no gender balance. It is expensive as each candidate running for office needs a campaign.
Proportional Representation
A system of elections where political parties recieve seats in proportion to their percentage of national vote.
What are the pros of PR?
It faithfully translates the votes into seats meaning a fair and accurate representation of the supporters. Minor parties can still gain seats and provides gender balance. It is less expensive than SMDP because each party only need to campaign for their party.
What are the cons of PR?
There is no regional representation because the percentage of votes would be too little compared to SMDP. It is not stable as it leads to multiparty systems with coalitions. It does not keep the reps accountable because they are only responsible to the party and its beliefs. Very few legislation can be passed due to diversity in opinions.
What electoral system is Mexico?
Mixed SMDP and PR plurality. This guarantees that minor parties gain seats.
Gender quotas in Mexico
A percentage of candidates in SMDP or PR have to be women.
What electoral system is Nigeria?
FPTP / SMDP system majority (due to the 25% of votes in 2/3 of states). This makes it impossible for minorities to win presidential elections. Number of representatives based on population.
Nigeria’s Senate
Has 3 members directly elected from 3 districts in each of the states. (SMDP) Allows for different parties to be one of those three.
What electoral system is Russia?
Mixed system SMDP and PR. The PR has a threshold of 5%, higher than most and make it difficult for minor parties to win.
What electoral system is Iran?
SMDP with MMD and SMD where the winning candidate has the most votes but must have at least 1/4 of the votes.
What electoral system is UK?
SMDP.
What electoral system is China?
The election process is indirect through a series of local and regional elections.
Mexico’s presidential system election rules?
The President is voted for by a plurality.
Nigeria’s presidential system election rules?
PRESIDENT (not regional reps) Majoritarian due to the 75% of the votes in 2/3 of states. This encourages candidates to not outwardly run as the North or South or an ethnic group. Prevent the perception of Nigeria being one religion or ethnic group.
Russia’s presidential system election rules?
Majoritarian but Putin often gets well over the majority of the votes as support for him is high. There are no legitimate challenger since he eliminates opposition. Major restrictions for independent candidates so there is no basis for support.
Iran’s presidential system election rules?
Majoritarian but there is a history of rigging to avoid a runoff of incumbents. (Previous president)
Mexico’s INE?
Reduces voter fraud, increase competition, approves of coalitions, IS independent from the government. INCREASES democracy.
Iran’s Guardian Council
Vets all election candidates to make sure they are aligned with the theocracy. NOT independent from government.
Nigeria’s INEC
Reduces voter fraud, ensure electoral integrety, competition, monitors parties, can postpone elections. IS independent and INCREASES democracy.
INEC, INE, and Guardian Council, what are they?
Electoral regulatory organizations.
Appointment systems in Legislative bodies and what do they do?
Used to bypass democratic options and place people in power who will maintain status quo. Can be used to carry out the executive’s wishes (corruption) OR provide diverse viewpoints which help decision making.
Guardian Council and the appointment system
GC vetoes legislation by the Majles if they believe it does not adhere to sharia law.
Federation Council and the appointment system
Upper house of Russia, govenors and regional legislatures decide who will represent their region. These regions are under Putin and carry out his wishes by imposing his will onto regional governments. Prevents rivals from emerging power at the regional level.
House of Lords and the appointment system
Appointed by the PM and independent commission to be approved by the monarch. Serves as a consulting party that has less power.
China’s One party system
CCP is the only party allowed to function BY THE CONSTITUTION.
8 Political “satellite’ parties
These parties predate the CCP and are highly monitored by the CCP. No impact on policy but provide a preception of multi-party system in China and CCP being tolerant to other viewpoints.
Russia’s dominant party system
The United Russia dominates all parts of government and controls the 3 branches of government. NOT a strict ideology party and is pragmatic which appeals to voters. This is why UF is often well over majority. No party has such mass appeal as UF. Heavy restrictions placed on growth of rival parties.