Unit 3 Flashcards
Historians of Traditional School
A.M. Schlesinger
Herbert Fies
Historians of Revisionist School
William Appleman Williams
Gar Alperovitz
Loloyd Gardner
Joyce and Gabreil Kolko
Historians of Post-Revisionist school
John Lewis Gaddis
Daniel Yergin
Historians of New Cold War History
Zubok and Pleshakov
Melyn Leffler
John Lewis Gaddis again
3 Traditionalists key approaches
Relied on personal exp, interview with friends
Relied on Soviet publication
Interested in Great men
4 branches of Revisionists
Williams: Open Door Policy
Capitalist expansion
Neither US nor USSR solely to blame
Gar Aleprovitz: Atomic diplomacy to intitmadate Stalin
Failed policy
Kolko: U.S. exaggerate Soviet threat to pass laws
Defeat revolutionary left, not just USSR
Fear of economic depression
Lloyd Gardner: U.S. shhould have shown more understanding as it had greater opportunities
Fear of Great Depression
2 Revisionists key approaches
Declassify foregin policy documents
No Soveit archivew
2 Branches of Post Revisioninsts
John Lewis Gaddis: - Neither US USSR at fault
- Truman under congressional public pressure but Stalin didnt have it
- Economics didnt determine politics and Stalin was merely opportunistic
- Mutual blame and national security paraignm
Daniel Yergin:- Riga and Yalta axiom
Eventually Truman shifted to Riga
2 Branches of Post Revisionists
John Lewis Gaddis: - Neither US USSR at fault
- Truman under congressional public pressure but Stalin didnt have it
- Economics didnt determine politics and Stalin was merely opportunistic
- Mutual blame and national security paraignm
Daniel Yergin:- Riga and Yalta axiom
Eventually Truman shifted to Riga
2 Key Post Revisionist approaches
Psychology studies
Drew on declassfied documents
New Cold War history
Gaddis:
- USSR was much more amoral to U.S.
- Both US and USSR tried to build empires
- CW inevitable as long as Stalin is in charge
Melvyn Leffler:
- Concern of national security
- USA core values, fusion of goal and ideology
- ideological and security concern connected
Sovietish New Cold War historians
Zubok
Pleshkov
Sovietish New Cold War history
- Revolutionary imperial paradigm
- Joined imperialism with communist revolutionary aspirations
- Role of ideology neither servant nor master
- No masterplan
- Stalin not totally to blame
Key New History Approaches
Used Soviet archives