Unit 2 Part 1 Flashcards
What are the four conditions that need to be met in order for something to be considered a crime?
- The action must be considered to be immoral.
- The society must cause harm to society/individual harm.
- The harm caused must be serious.
- The person must be punished by the criminal justice system.
___and___dictate what is considered illegal and the penalties change over time.
Morals and society
What is the difference between an illegal act and a criminal act?
A criminal act is an offence described in the criminal code and federally/provincially regulated. (Ex. Murder, theft, assault, drug possession).
An illegal act is an offence not described in the Criminal Code (still breaking the law, but not a Criminal Code law? (Ex. Speeding, drinking in public, selling to a minor).
What are some more examples of an illegal act? What do you receive for committing an illegal act?
- ticket
- selling cigarettes to minors, speeding, drinking in public, cutting down trees in parks
What are some more examples of a criminal act? What do you receive for committing a criminal act?
- jail or penitentiary time
- theft over $5000, assult, marijuana possession, kidnapping
Who are laws created by?
Both the federal and provincial gov’ts
Who creates/Amanda the Criminal Code of Canada and who regulates and upholds these laws?
- the federal gov’t
- the RCMP
What kind of laws can the provinces create/amend? Who upholds these laws?
- the laws for their provinces, such as traffic laws
- the RCMP
Who makes municipal laws and who upholds these laws?
- made by cities and towns
- upheld by the RCMP
What is the only real fairness in the Canadian Justice System?
Procedural fairness, meaning an accused is treated justly by police, courts, etc.
WHat do principles in procedural fairness include?
Fairness: trial process has to be impartial to the accused and it has to follow precedent.
Efficiency: timely court process
Clarity: accused has to understand charges against and the process
Restraint: officers of the court have to show restraint (police, prosecutors, jail guards)
Accountability: gov’t officials accountable for actions
Participation: accused has to be allowed to contribute to defense/public trial
Protection: from harm by officials
What are the seven clear purposes for why we have certain laws in Canada (the purpose of criminal law)?
- Protect people from harm
- Enforce moral standards of Canadians
- Maintain order in society
- Protect property
- Provide retribution (pay back to balance justice) consequences for crimes
- Provide rehabilitation (help criminals and reintegrate them)
- Deter people from committing crimes
What are the two things that he criminal code of Canada does?
1) describes the offences
2) sets the penalty
What are the penalties for breaking the criminal code?
Fine, community service, or imprisonment
Is the criminal code the same across Canada?
Yes
Who can amend the criminal code?
The federal government
Who makes decisions that influences the parliaments decisions about the Criminal Code?
The Supremem Court of Canada
What is the power to make federal law given by?
The Constitution Act of 1982 (section 91)
Can or cannot criminal law infringe on Charter rights (legal rights)
It cannot
What does criminal code involve (who vs who)?
Government of Canada against the individual accused
What conditions must exist for an action to be a crime?
1) Actions or behavior of the person must be considered immoral by most Canadians.
2) Action must cause harm to society/individual victims.
3) The harm caused must be serious.
4) The person must be punished by the criminal justice system.
What influences the government when it decides what behaviours to criminalize, decriminalize, or legalize?
1) Criminalize- when new actions threaten individuals or when social values change. Ex. Online suicide counselling.
2) Decriminalize- removing an action from the criminal code. No longer considered to be a threat to society as values have changed. Ex. Homosexuality, suicide.
When the government decides that crimes are to be added, deleted, or changed in the Criminal Code, why is it important to have a free and open debate about the proposed changes?
Democratic country, majority vote, open debate, freedom of expression.
What is the balance of limits, duty, and rights?
Limit- we cannot do things in order to protect society.
Duty- follows the rules/do what we are obligated to do.
Right- right to our own beliefs without eing bullied
What is the conflict between individual rights and the rights of society?
In the legal system of Canada, there is an attempt to balance society’s needs with the needs of individuals. At times, though, the individual suffers because the “good of Soceity” is of more importance.
What are two aspects of the Charter that Sue Rodriguez felt were violated by assisted suicide being illegal?
1) To be denied the assistance she needed to end her pain, she felt was “cruel and unusual treatment”. (Charter of Rigts: Section 12).
2) She cannot take her own life because of her disability (Equality). (Charter of Rights: Section 15).