U1T2 3 marks 5 khandas Flashcards
The three marks of existence
anicca - impermanence
anatta - no permanent self or soul
dukkha - suffering
nature of the three marks of existence
characteristics of all HUMAN life that are always present
purpose of understand the three marks of existence
remove attachment to existence by removing delusions, the misunderstanding that existence is permanent, is pleasant, and has something to do with the self
the Buddha’s Deer Park Sermon
birth is suffering, ageing is suffering … association with what is loathed is suffering, dissociation from the loved is suffering … the categories affected by clinging are suffering
the idea of anicca and its relationship with dukkha
idea that everything is dependent on causes and conditions, therefore everything changes
causes dukkha as we become attached to things we expect to remain unchanged, and then struggle to accept when they do change
the only permanent rest from change
nibbana
The Ship of Theseus
a ship preserved by the Athenians by taking away the old planks as they decayed and replacing them with new planks. If it is fully replaced in this way, is it still the same ship? At what point does it stop being the same ship?
sankhara-dukkha
dissatisfaction with life rather than a distinct problem; sense that life is meaningless; frustration at limits of being human; existential suffering and angst
dukkha-dukka
suffering we see around us all the time - things that are directly painful - physical pain, death, watching others suffer
viparinmana-dukkha
mental suffering from pleasant situations due to inability to accept change and impermanence
theistic criticism of Buddhist doctrine of impermanence
God or other spiritual things such as the soul are permanent
materialistic criticism of Buddhist doctrine of impermanence:
point of life is to struggle against changing material things rather than accept it. too much acceptance of death is passive or morbid
poet Dylan Thomas: materialistic objection to Buddhist doctrine of impermanence
do not go gentle into that good night, but rage, rage against the dying of the light
the Buddha: what are humans
the coming together of the kandhas, all of which are changing
origination of anatta
based on rejection of the Hindu belief humans have an atman which is permanent and unchanged which moves between lives, but is affected by the karma - the Buddha said this belief does not make logical sense
materialist
person who supports theory that nothing exists except matter and its movement and modifications
monist
person who supports theory that denies the existence of a distinction or duality in a particular sphere eg between matter and mind or between god and the world
dualist
person who supports theory that regards a domain of reality in terms of two independent principles, especially mind and matter
why you cannot be enlightened without accepting anatta
belief in a separate self means you seek your own good rather than that of others and remain ignorant of the true nature of existence
relationship discovered by the Buddha during period of asceticism
our physical, mental, spiritual aspects all affect one another
Buddhist definition of ‘self’
simply a label to describe the current state of our psychophysical unity
Nagasena and the chariot
analogy used to explain anatta. the wheels, axels, and all other parts of a chariot are not the chariot. ‘chariot’ is a designation for something conceptual - a combination of different parts and functions
Huntington Jr: how to ‘see things as they are’
unearth our hidden assumptions about existence, and notice how they contradict the reality of actual experience
Huntington Jr: what anicca means
there are no stable, well-defined ‘things’ or ‘people’, only a ceaseless, ungraspable stream of events’
Huntington Jr: why things appear stable
most change happens slowly, below the level of normal perception
Huntington Jr: death as the paradigm of all change
people are dying constantly, everywhere, but we don’t notice it (or try not to), however a sense of relief comes from encountering and accepting it as a universal truth
Huntington Jr: what anatta means
appearance of an unchangeable, individual agent is the construction of a mind infused with desire and fear. I too am nothing but a mental construct, a phantom’s mask covering the reality of change
Huntington Jr: errors with the assumption that ‘I am the agent of my thoughts and actions’ (3)
- if control of body, why susceptible to ageing, death, disease
- if control thoughts, why dwell on painful things
- do not consciously control internal functions eg respiration
Huntington Jr: comparing things inside vs outside ‘me’
line between them ultimately false. all things inner and outer are simply happening without my assistance, spontaneously arising and passing away
‘avidya’ as defined in the Dhammacakka Sutta
ignorance, disillusioned understanding of the world and happiness
what dukkha stems from
Huntington Jr definition of dukkha
no english word captures the full range of meaning of dukkha. dukkha is a subtle, all-pervasive dis-ease.
Huntington Jr with reference to Freud on denial of cause of dukkha
humans deny things that make us happy will end and cause suffering. this denial exacts a psychological toll (Freud).
Huntington Jr: the essence of Buddhist wisdom
seeing that underneath all pleasures, the dark current of dukkha flows polluting everything with the stench of an insatiable hunger and fear
Mahayana Lotus Sutta parable of the burning house
father lures his children out of a burning house (symbolic of samsara and suffering) by promising them three carts full of toys (symbolic of the three poisons). the children push and shove each other out but find only one jewelled cart pulled by a white ox (symbolic of the dhamma) and learn all forms of desire are a dead end
Huntington Jr translation of karuna
love - ‘more complex and intimate than a simple feeling of compassion’; ‘surrendering to our dharma’
Huntington Jr: the Buddha’s giving voice to the dhamma
reminded us of a fundamental truth and helped us adjust our lives accordingly - found a ‘new idiom for an ageless, universal law of self sacrifice’