Trusts, Wills, Estates Flashcards
What are the requirements for a valid trust?
SIT PA: Settlor/grantor/trustor, Intent to create a trust, Trustee, Property, Ascertainable Benefits
What are the considerations - both mandatory and optional - raised when creating an express trust?
- Subject to SOF?
a. Testamentary?
b. The property is real estate?
c. By its terms set to last more than 1 year? - Created by a trust agreement/instrument
- Trustee given specific, binding directions
- Optional:
a. Distinguish between initial income and remainder
i. Then if trustee fucks it up, may be liable to the beneficiary entitled to more
b. Wide can be given to the trustee in how to/whether to make a distribution to beneficiary
i. Trustee can also “sprinkle” distributions to members of the beneficiary class
ii. Just requires good faith/reasonableness
What are the two main reasons a court would imply a trust?
(1) a good faith effort is made to create an express trust that fails, (2) constructive trust is implied by the court to prevent unjust enrichment/inequity
How might a constructive (implied) trust be created?
a. Court implies a trust to mitigate inequity/avoid unjust enrichment
i. Trustee orally promised to hold property for beneficiary and then failed to do so – again, court may imply a trust to protect the harmed party
ii. Legal interest is obtained in property via theft, fraud, duress, breach of fiduciary duty… wrongdoer is legally considered a trustee for the properly-intended beneficiary
When does an inter vivos trust take effect? And is it revocable at death?
- Takes effect immediately upon funding
- Irrevocable upon the grantor’s death
- Provisions actually trump a will designation to the contrary!
What are the laws governing the revocation of a trust?
- Common law: requires express reservation by grantor of the power to revoke
- UTC: trust is revocable (default) unless express provision otherwise
- Can be terminated by mutual agreement if
a. Donor/grantor and all beneficiaries agree AND
b. Would not defeat a material purpose of the trust
Why are trusts useful? What’s the utility behind creating one?
- Reduce estate taxes – appreciation of a trust’s assets is not taxed at death
- Living trust – transfers assets when donor dies w/o a will (wills can be contested)
- Protects assets: out of the reach of creditors or Uncle Sam
a. “Spendthrift” provision = extra protection! - Avoid probate – more privacy and quicker way to devise property
What is the Uniform Trust Code?
i. The Uniform Trust Code (2005)
1. Attempt to update/standardize common law of trusts
2. Not binding, but influential
What are the key elements of the Uniform Transfers to Minors Act?
a. Irrevocable custodian trusts for the benefit of minors
b. Ownership vested w/minor but controlled by custodian/trustee
c. Minor’s creditors can access
d. Custodian/trustee not liable to 3rd parties in contract unless custodial relationship concealed
How would the court treat provisions of a trust that violate the Rule Against Perpetuities?
- If RAP violation exists, courts will strike the portion that offends the rule:
a. So, if conveyance’s conditional wording is “but if” (e.g. ‘but if liquor ever sold’), then the original person gets fee simple absolute
b. If the wording was “so long as” (e.g. “so long as operated as a school”) then the previous interest gets a fee simple determinable, grantor gets possibility of reverter
What is the trustee’s role?
Trustee is a fiduciary of any assets in the trust and is directed by the trust instrument’s directions and descriptions. Notice to beneficiaries is often key. PIN CALL = basic duties
What are the PIN CALL basic duties of a trustee?
ii. PIN CALL = basic duties
1. Properly administer
a. Prudent business person investment standard – how would such a person safeguard her own investments
b. Preserve the principal
c. Attempt to maximize productivity of assets
2. Inform beneficiaries
a. When transaction involving more than 25% of assets – require notice to settlor AND beneficiaries
3. Not delegate decisions
a. Can’t delegate decisions pertaining to judgment/discretion
b. CAN delegate basic admin/ministerial work with supervision
4. Commingling of assets not allowed
a. Of separate trusts
b. OR of the trustee’s personal assets with the trust
5. Account to beneficiaries
a. Annual written statement to all adult beneficiaries
i. Including trustee’s compensation
b. Beneficiaries can request additional info and trustee has to get it too
6. Litigate on behalf of trust
a. May sue on behalf of the trust
b. Must defend the trust
7. Loyalty to the trust
a. Fiduciary duty is KEY
i. Breach = SOB
1. Self-dealing
2. Opportunity of trust
3. Borrowing from trust
On what grounds can a trustee be held liable by the beneficiaries of a trust?
- Liability:
a. Trustee can be sued by the beneficiaries for breach of duties (financial liability)
b. Also liable for failing to pursue a negligent prior trustee
c. Improper delegation of duties or failure to supervise a negligent agent
On what grounds can a trustee be removed from her role?
a. A beneficiary-approved trustee? Court doesn’t favor removal
b. Cause for removal anyway:
i. Unfitness
ii. Unwillingness to serve
iii. Violation of duties (PINCALL)
What defenses might a trustee assert if being sued by beneficiaries?
a. Instrument contains exculpatory clause
i. Courts don’t like these clauses
ii. BUT if one is on the books – trustee may be shielded from liability for negligence (but not if bad faith, intent, gross negligence)
b. Consent by beneficiary
i. Beneficiary who consents may be estopped from complaining
c. Statute of limitations has run
What are a beneficiary’s ownership rights in a trust?
- Absolute ownership rights to the trust unless the instrument expressly says otherwise
- Transfer rights: can devise or transfer their interest/income
a. Instrument could create a restraint on alienation (transfer) but not enforceable if against public policy
b. And usually only valid to restrict inter vivos transfers
What is it called when a creditor of a trust’s beneficiary asks for income distributions from a trust?
A “charging order” which the creditor delivers to the trustee.
How does a spendthrift trust protect beneficiaries?
- Spendthrift trust
a. Beneficiary is not allowed to assign future income distributions to creditors (charging order is useless)
b. Exceptions: provide for necessities, family support, to pay the beneficiary’s taxes, cannot be used to defraud creditors, not permitted if the settler is also the beneficiary (the you’re just trying to avoid creditors)
What is a support trust?
A support trust is set up to provide for the needs of a beneficiary. The trustee is obligated to pay for the support of the beneficiary out of trust funds. These needs must be limited to providing for food, clothing, shelter, medical expenses
What is a discretionary trust and how does it protect its beneficiaries from creditors?
a. Trustee is given sole discretion to make or withhold distribution
b. Protects from creditors because the beneficiary’s interest in an income distribution is not vested (totes at the trustee’s mercy)
c. Exceptions: provide for necessities, family support, to pay the beneficiary’s taxes
What are the basics of a charitable trust?
i. Must be registered with a state agency
ii. Exempt from the RAP
iii. Cy Pres doctrine:
1. If named charity taker no longer exists?
2. Court can substitute a similarly-purposed charity to effectuate the grantor’s intent
3. Court has to examine intent
4. If grantor only wanted to help a specifically-named charity, then the gift goes into the grantor’s residuary estate (and would pass via will or intestacy)
How could a lawsuit arise between a 3rd party and a trust?
- Contracts
a. 3rd party who contracts with the trust can sue the trust
b. Remember trustee has a duty to defend/litigate
c. Judgment for 3rd party? Can go after the trust’s assets - Torts
a. 3rd party who is damages by a tort of the trust (usually meaning the trustee) can sue
b. Remember trustee has a duty to defend/litigate
c. Judgment for 3rd party? Can go after the trust’s assets
How could a lawsuit arise between a 3rd party and a trustee?
- Contracts
a. Typically, trustee acts as agent for the trust so would not be personally liable for contract
b. If outside valid scope and liable, the trust could still indemnify the trustee - Torts
a. Trustee is personally liable for her own torts
b. Liable for subordinates’ torts if failure to supervise
c. Failure to obtain insurance on trust property may be a breach of duty
How could a 3rd party seek to hold a trust’s beneficiaries legally liable for contract or tort?
Good fuckin’ luck! No rights against the beneficiaries
Can a trust sue a 3rd party?
Totally! If 3rd party screws over the trust, can be liable to the trust and its beneficiaries for money damages. Remember that the trustee has the option to sue on behalf of the trust, but the duty to defend the trust in litigation.
What are the ways in which trust could be terminated?
Consolidation&merger; term expiration; merger; purpose accomplished, illegal, or impossible; income interest terminates (pay out to the sole survivor); donor termination; court petition (rare)
How would a court petition to terminate a trust look?
- Law disfavors trust termination
- BUT possible if
a. All income/remainder beneficiaries petition the court
b. Moving party can show termination would not defeat a material purpose for which the trust was created
i. Almost impossible standard to meet
c. During the court petition:
i. Minors should be appointed guardian ad litem
What are the essential elements of a valid will?
i. Comply with the laws where testator domiciled at the time of death? (think conflicts of laws)
ii. Contains all the SIT MA requirements?
1. Signed in front of two witnesses (or direct someone to sign for you/acknowledge a previous signature)
2. Intent
3. Testamentary age: gotta be 18+
4. Mental capacity
a. Upon execution, must remember & understand:
i. Property nature/extent
ii. Objects of her bounty (in other words, kiddos)
iii. Testamentary effect of the devise
5. Attested two by 2 competent witnesses
a. Common law: witness cannot be interested party
b. Modern rule: okay if witness is interested party so long as no evidence of undue influence