Trusts Flashcards
Who holds which interests?
Legal interest: trustee
Equitable interest: bfy
Settlor: person who causes trust to come into being
Role of trustee
Fiduciary (reasonable care/ loyalty)
- Personally responsible if conduct falls beneath
How does trust move upon death of settlor
Inter vivos trust passes outside probate
Types of express trusts
Private – private bfy Charitable – charitable bfy (indefinite class or general public) Honorary/purpose – pet/ maintain memorial
Types of trusts created by operation of law
Resulting – arise from presumed intention of owner of property
Constructive – equitable remedy to prevent unjust enrichment
Elements of a valid trust
To form a valid trust, the settlor must intend to create a trust for a valid trust purpose, and delviers trust property to the trustee to hold for the benefit of one or more identifiable beneficiaries.
- Intent to create trust relationship (split legal/equitable title)
- Proper purpose
- Identifiable corpus
a) Capacity to convey - Trustee
- Ascertainable bfy (Private trust: definite beneficiaries)
- Mechanics and formalities
Result of no identifiable corpus
If no corpus then trust will arise when funded with assets if:
- if no valid consideration: Remanifest intent to create trust when funded
- If valid consideration:
Testator - Capacity
Same as capacity to make a will.
Understand:
- Nature of act (executing will)
- Nature & extent of property
- Natural objects of their bounty (family members)
- Able to formulate orderly scheme of disposition
Trust - What renders trust unenforceable
Lack of legal capacity, undue influence, fraud, duress
Trust - Technical Requirements
Written (sometimes oral) but no specific words
Delivery of property to trustee (no communication to bfy)
- Not necessary if self-trustee but must seperate
Trust takes effect immediately
Trust - Precatory expressions
Hope/wish/ suggestion does not create (must impose legal obligation not moral), inference of non-creation overcome by:
- Definite & precise directions
- Directions to fiduciary
- Unnatural disposition if no trust imposed
- Extrinsic evidence shows settlor previously supported bfy
Corpus – Result of no corpus on trust
Trust fails for lack of/ insufficient trust property
Corpus - Types of future interests that can be corpus
Future interests may be held in trust
Mere expectancy is not
Corpus - Requirement for trust corpus
Identifiable
Segregated
Corpus - Debt
Debtor cannot hold own debt in trust // other can hold debt in trust
Debtor can declare themselves trustee of property from which debt is to be paid
“Mechanics” – when is oral trust permitted
Established by clear & convincing evidence
- Trust of land must usually be in writing
“Mechanics” – If fails for lack of writing
Usually must be in writing - invalid trust may be valid through constructive trust
How to resolve Statute of Fraud issue
Holder of legal title acting like trustee will preclude SoF defense
Use of Parole evidence?
Most states allow
Requirement for Beneficiaries in private trust
Mut be identifiable (not so with charitable trusts) Trustee may select members in its discretion as long as class is reasonably definite
Qualified beneficiary
Has additional rights compared to other byf – must receive notice and get to decide re: certain things.
Is a bfy who, on the date trust becomes functional:
1. Is a Current bfy (not a contingent remainder) OR
2. First-line remainderman (is eligible to receive distributions were the event triggering term of bfy’s interest/ the trust itself to occur on the qualification date)
Contingent remainders are not qualified bfy
Requirement of bfy
- Capable of taking/ holding title
- Must accept to become bfy (express/implied – generally presumed)
Need not be competent
No notice necessary – lack of notice implies no trust
How to disclaim
- File signed & written instrument
- Usually within 9 months (time doesn’t start until 21 years)
- Has not exercised domion/control
- Irrevccaoble
- Sometimes affidavit
Treated as if bfy predeceases
Date of disclaimer relates back to defeat creditor’s liens but not tax liens
Applcaiton of Anti-lapse to trusts
Some states/ UPC – applies anti-lapse to future interests created in trusts even if expressly conditioned on survival
Effect of divorce
Revokes all beneficial gifts/ fiduciary appointments in favor of former spouse
Definite Bfy – Unascertained
May be definite even if not ascertained (ie unborn children)
Must be ascertainable by the time their interests come into enjoyment
Definite Bfy – Class gift
Class closes when member of class can call for distribution of share of gift. Description can be generic if ascertainable at time of benefit CL: description of class must be reasonably definite (thereafter settlor can pick) UPC: settlor may empower trustee to choose bfy from indefinite class Where bfy is born after trust made but gift is to “surviving children” consider class but determine that ok.
Remedy for lack of bfy
Resulting trust is created in favor of the settlor and their successors
Invalid purposes
Illegal
Contrary to public policy
Impossible
Intended to defraud settlor’s creditors
Remedy if for lack of public policy
Settlor’s alt. desire
If illegal condition is condition subsequent, condition is invalidated
If illegal condition is condition precedent, hold interest valid unless evidence that settlor would wish it to be void
Rule against perpetuities
Nonvested property interest is invalid unless it is certain to vest or fail no later than 21 years after the death of a life in being
OR wait and see
OR 90 year vesting period
OR abolished
Will a trust fail for lack of a trustee?
No
However, lack of trustee may cause attempted inter vivos trust to fail for lack of delivery
How to accept to be trustee
Sign trust/ separate acceptance
Substantially comply with acceptance terms
Accept delivery of trust property
Trustee may still act to preserve trust property without acceptance if they send notice of rejection first
Relation back of acceptance
Testamentary trust treated as in existence as of settlor’s death; trustee’s acceptance “relates back” to the death.
Resignation
Either:
- 30 day notice to qualified bfy/settlor/ co-trustees OR
- Obtain court approval
Qualification of trustee
Capacity to acquire & hold property and administer
Removal of trustee
Breach of trust
Serious lack of cooperation between co-trustees
Unfitness, unwillingness or persistent failure to administer
Substantial change in circumstances
Intervivos trust
Created while settlor alive by either
- Settlor declaring self trustee for another OR
- Transfer of property to antoher as trustee
Intent is show by:
- Conduct (delivery)
- Words (declaring self trustee)