Treating viruses Flashcards
How does pathogenesis affect ease of vaccination?
Acute diseases with no animal reservoir are the easiest
Antigenic variation makes it v difficult
Latent infection - immune response isn’t enough to eradicate so difficult
Type of immunity needed (antibody or cell mediated) effects vaccine strategy
What are the different types of vaccine?
Killed vaccines
Live attenuated vaccines (through multiple passages or related species)
Subunits of virus (purified components e.g. surface antigen or VLPs)
Therapeutic vaccines
What are the advantages and disadvantages of killed vaccines?
Safe, may be better in immunocompromised patients, no need to cold store.
Boosters and adjuvants required as not immunogenic, need to be completely inactivated
What are the advantages and disadvantages of live attenuated vaccines?
Broad range of immune responses induced, don’t need boosters (life long immunity), rapid immunity induced
Could revert to virulent phenotype, often have to be stored at -70, often grown in tissue culture so could end up with contamination (e.g. polio with SV40 which could transform cells), could spread from vaccines (increasing immunity? issue with consent), may be problem in immunocompromised
What are the scenarios in which therapeutic vaccines may be administered?
Post virus exposure (e.g. rabies)
Treatment of established disease
Prevention of recurrence
What qualities of smallpox made eradication possible?
No animal reservoir
Acute infection
DNA genome (less mutation from vaccine and virus)
Life long immunity from vaccine
Only 1 serotype
Subclinical cases rare so infections can be isolated
Describe the 2 polio vaccines?
Inactivated vaccine was made first: Salk
Then oral live attenuated vaccine made: Sabin
How is the live attenuated vaccine for polio made?
Many passages and plaque purifications. Has mutations in the 5’ UTR: 3 mutations in loop 5
Why is polio difficult to eradicate?
Failure to vaccinate effectively: has to be between 2/3yrs of age or doesn’t take as well and immunological state is poor
Failure of vaccine uptake
Epidemiology of polio - high density populations, less seasonality (affects timing of vaccine) in tropical climates, poor sanitation
Emergence of revertant viruses from vaccine
Describe the measles vaccine
Protects against measles infection (acute and occasionally persistent in the CNS - serious)
Live attenuated vaccine within the MMR cocktail. Gives life long immunity. Can target vaccine as measles is seasonal - give before peak.
What are the issues with the measles vaccine?
People being idiots - resurgence of measles whenever herd immunity drops because people believe vaccine side effect propaganda (e.g. USA 1989-91 and Swansea 2013).
Describe the hepatitis B vaccine
Subunits vaccine - purified surface antigen from envelope (as can’t culture Hep B in vitro so can’t do inactivated or live attenuated). At first had plasma derived vaccines - purify plasma from asymptomatic individuals and heat inactivate.
What factors effect the response to the hepatitis B vaccine?
Immunological factors (dosage, immunisation schedules, site and rout of vaccination, adjuvant) Host factors (age, weight, immune status (e.g. immunosuppression), gender, genetics)
Describe the Rubella vaccine
Risk of congenital infection (transmission to foetus). Originally targeted adolescent females, then moved to everyone to induce herd immunity. Attenuated live vaccine in MMR
Describe vaccination against rabies
Animal reservoir makes eradication v difficult
Can give a post exposure vaccine
Only need to vaccinate those at risk e.g. vets, animal handlers, some lab workers, people who work with bats/other rapid species, travelling to risk areas
Describe yellow fever vaccination
A flavivirus with an insect vector (so only need to vaccinate in areas where vector is found). Live attenuated vaccine made in hens eggs (was passaged through mice and chickens in the past). Vaccine gives life long protection against all serotypes; neutralising antibody forms. Vaccine is very safe with very rare adverse effects (more in the elderly)
Describe the HPV vaccination
The first vaccine to be genetically engineered - 2 capsid proteins (L1 and L2) that self assemble if grown in yeast/baculovirus - empty shell
Describe the development of the HPV vaccine
GSK trial: virus like particles from HPV16 + 18 made in baculovirus and given to HPV seronegative women (placebo and vaccine). Did 3 doses and a 27 month follow up. Led to a fast track licence
Merck vaccine was also developed in a different expression system. Included more HPV strains (6 and 11)
Why is the HPV vaccine so effective?
In an HPV infection, there are very few virions. In the vaccine there are many empty shells so a stronger immune response occurs
What are the issues surrounding HPV vaccination policy?
At the moment only vaccinate teenage women, but vaccinating men as well would protect them from male HPV cancers and induce herd immunity. Also worth considering vaccinating older women
Have to consider which vaccine to use and what strains it includes
Describe the VZV vaccine
Developed as infection in immunosuppressed patients lead to a severe primary infection. Live attenuated vaccine made by passage through human and guinea pig cells
Describe the policy of VZV vaccination
Policy varies between countries - is compulsory in USA but in UK and Germany use a targeted program as chicken pox isn’t a super bad disease in most people. However, there is a vaccine against shingles available to people over the age of 70 in the UK
Describe the flu vaccine
Is a killed vaccine - HA and NA, sometimes given with adjuvants. The HA is from different virus strains - H3N2, H1N1, Influenza B HA. Vaccine strains are isolated in hens. Vaccine is updated regularly and tested in ferrets.
Describe zoonotic vaccine development in flu
Can clone the HA from H5N1 and apply site directed mutagenesis to the HA cleavage site to attenuate. This can be tested for in ferrets and poultry.
Describe the past rotavirus vaccine
Mixing segments from human and monkey reassortment virus - including a mixture of VP7 (surface protein). Had side effects of bowel disease so was withdrawn
Describe the Merck vaccine against rotavirus
Segmented live viruses, mix of human and bovine. Cocktail of up to 5 strains with various surface proteins (VP4 and VP7)
Describe the GSK vaccine against rotavirus
A live attenuated strain from severe child infection with many passages
Why are vaccines difficult to make?
Antigenic variation Latency Congenital disease Antibody enhancement Lack of growth in vitro
What strategies can be used to rationally attenuate a virus for a vaccine?
Deletion/mutation of a gene
Modify replication fidelity of RNA polymerases
Codon de-optimise
Add miRNAs to the virus genome (can use to target vaccine to only certain areas of the body)
Zn finger nuclease control of virus production
What are the goals of an HSV vaccine?
Herpes simplex virus. A prophylactic vaccine to prevent acute clinical disease, infection (viral replication in genital tract), and reduce establishment of latency. A therapeutic vaccine to reduce clinical recurrence and viral shedding and transmission
What is DISC technology?
Disabled infectious singly cycle technology.
How has DISC technology been used in trying to creating an HSV vaccine?
Delete the gH gene in the virus that it requires for entry. Grow virus on a complementing cell line that expresses gH in trans. When virus moved to a non-complementing cell line, will have gH so can enter but won’t pick it up as it exits the cell so the virus is no longer infectious. Virus can still induce an immune response, so is good for a vaccine
What methods have been used in an attempt to create an HSV vaccine?
Live deletion mutants (replication limited)d
Pox virus and adenovirus vectors for glycoproteins
Inactivated whole virus
Inactivated infected cell extracts
Subunit glycoproteins
DNA plasmids
Peptides
What makes creation of a vaccine against Dengue virus difficult?
Antibody enhancement: if have antibody against one serotype, if another serotype infects the antibody binds the virus but doesn’t neutralise it. The antibody-virus complex then binds to monocytes enabling entry and makes the disease much worse
How has a Dengue vaccine attempted to be created?
Make a chimeric virus that expresses all structural genes. Can delete 30 residues at the 3’ end to attenuate the virus (combine forms of deletion)
What are the issues with RSV vaccination?
Respiratory syncytial virus - need to immunise new borns. Issues with immunological immaturity, maternal antibodies inhibiting an effective response, mucosal immunity to respiratory viruses is short lived, 2 antigenic subgroups, animal models not fully permissive, vaccine for older children is dangerous in infants.
What are the prospects for RSV vaccine development?
Rational attenuation with reverse genetics
Subunit vaccine - have one for older children using F and G proteins
DNA vaccines - plasmid expressing F gene is protective in rodents
What is the rationale behind modifying replication fidelity of RNA viruses?
If can make the polymerase less error prone, the virus is less likely to revert to a virulent phenotype. Has been attempted with polio - mutate the active site to a less error prone residue
What has been the result of looking at codon-deoptimisation in regards to vaccine development?
If can make the virus less fit, might be a safer vaccine - in picornavirus found that codon-deoptimisation of some and all of the virus resulted in less and smaller plaques. Were still some present which is good for a vaccine (need some replication to occur)
How could miRNAs be used in polio vaccine development?
Polio is normally a GI infection and not severe - only bad in the CNS. If could engineer a CNS miRNA into the vaccine, the miRNA would result in cleavage of viral RNA in the CNS with no virus produced. Would be good for immunosuppressed individuals
How would attenuation of a virus for a vaccine using Zn finger nucleases work?
The nuclease would cleave DNA - operates in pairs by recognising 2 lots of a 9 nucleotide sequence. Engineer the viral genome so it had a Zn finger recognition site and the nuclease. The nuclease could be expressed under temporal control so there was still immunogenic proteins expressed.
What is MVA?
A highly attenuated version of VACV - many passages through chick cells, 31kB lost from the genome including immune evasion genes. Is a poxvirus so can take up foreign DNA so is a candidate for a live delivery vector
What is the advantages and disadvantages of using MVA as a live delivery vector?
Is a poxvirus so can take up a lot of DNA, induces interferon, has lost many genes including those for immune evasion e.g. soluble interferon receptor.
Doesn’t replicate well in certain cell types
What has been the result of using MVA as a live delivery vector for a flu vaccine?
MVA could be used to deliver internal proteins of flu virus that would be under less selection. M1 and NP are more stable so wouldn’t need to update vaccine every year. In a human trial saw CD8 and CD4 T cell responses to the vaccine.
What are the advantages of a DNA vaccine?
Plasmids are safe, stable and can be transported long distances. Can give a cocktail of plasmids with multiple antigens. Unlikely to generate an adverse immune response as there is no live vector.
What methods have been used for development of an Ebola vaccine?
DNA vaccine development - good as there is a significant safety risk with growing the vaccine in vitro. DNA plasmids can produce an antibody response
What are the issues with developing an Ebola vaccine?
No implémentation of safety trials - want to develop quickly No small rodent model - only primates Cost and stability Strain variation Host genetic variation
What are the different mechanisms of vaccine trial in the field?
Double blind (2 different vaccines given, and not vaccinated) Stepped wedge (gradually roll out vaccine) Ring method (vaccinate close contacts of infected)
What has been the result of trying to developing an HCMV vaccine?
Congenital infection. Looking at glycoprotein as a vaccine. Have to use seronegative people in trial. No significant changes in chances of becoming infected; no significant changes in pregnancy outcomes
What are the examples of potential adjuvants?
Immunostimulants
Vehicles for optimal antigen presentation
Rational adjuvant design by stimulating TLRs
What are some examples of immunostimulants used as adjuvants?
Attenuated version of LPS (MLP), Cholera toxin B subunit (engineered) as a mucosal adjuvant for orally delivered vaccines
What are some examples of vehicles used as adjuvants?
Oil emulsions, mineral salts, liposomes, virosomes, biodegradable polymer microspheres
What are the theories behind rational adjuvant design?
Want to stimulate TLRs. dsRNA binds TLR3 - use poly I:C as an analogue and see if get increased immunogenicity (get more interferon induction). Flagellin binds TLR5 - use to enhance immunogenicity of HA head group (fusion protein)
What are the issues with developing an HCV vaccine?
Limited tropism in vitro and in vivo
Cell culture systems poor - have now identified human entry receptors so may be able to use this knowledge to add to rodent cells
What is a ‘humanised mouse’ used for hepatitis virus vaccine testing?
Immune deficient mouse with a liver toxin expressed. Kill mouse liver cells and implant human hepatocytes. Is now susceptible to HBV and HCV but mice are infertile, expensive and limited in numbers. Human cell quality is also important
What are some vaccines in trial for HCV?
Peptide vaccine (core, NS3, NS4) MVA (NS3, NS4, NS5B) Purified gpE1/E2 protein DNA (NS3/4A) DNA and protein (E1/E2 plasmid then core protein)
How can viruses be stabilised by cryopreservation?
Important for vaccination in the 3rd world. Trehalose-sucrose dried on a glass slide. Can put virus particles in this and store for a long time - has shown to be promising with adenoviruses: get significant interferon production after thawing.
Why is an HIV vaccine challenging?
Many subtypes with geographical variation
Many routes of transmission
Need serum antibody and mucosal immunity
Describe the Merck vaccine trial for HIV
Was bad - saw increased risk of HIV infection in the vaccinated group compared to the placebo. Was an adenovirus expressing gag, pol and nef
Describe the Thailand HIV vaccine trial
Was reported to be successful (31% protection). Used a prim/boost protocol in which a pox vector was the prime and DNA was the boost. Used strains found in the region. However, no real significant difference in infection risk.
What are the types of antiviral treatments?
Antiviral chemotherapy
Vaccines
Newer/other (e.g. Zmapp - mix of 3 monoclonal antibodies against Ebola surface glycoprotein)
How does basic virology focus on discovering drugs?
By identifying key events in the virus life cycle, solving chemical/crystal structure of targets, identifying target cells, identifying off-target toxicity (human analogues), developing reliable models, identifying mechanisms of resistance latency and reservoirs.
What are the stages of human drug development?
Synthesis of a drug candidate
In vitro studies
Animal studies
Phase I studies (human in vivo safety)
Phase II studies (small efficacy trial)
Phase III studies (large pre-licensing efficacy trial)
Phase IV studies (post licensing safety reporting)
What characteristics does an ideal antiviral posses?
Potent, specific and non-toxic
Reliable models (in vitro, in vivo and in silico) and reliable to produce
Easy to store and administer
High barrier to resistance
What are the challenges in developing antivirals?
Virus factors: if the virus is difficult/dangerous to culture in vitro, no animal model, heterogeneity of the target, resistance develops
Host-virus interaction factors: off target toxicity, compartmentalisation of infection, delayed access to testing and treating
Viral replication uses host metabolism - need to inhibit only the virus. May have antiviral activity in vitro but not in vivo, only works against replicating viruses (not latent)
What are the goals of antiviral chemotherapy?
Want to treat (cure/control) AND prevent infection/disease
What are category 1 antivirals?
Antivirals that are direct inhibitors of the virus, usually at a cellular level. Could block virus entry/egress, inhibit nucleic acid synthesis, inhibit protease, inhibit integrase
What drugs block virus entry?
Maraviroc (HIV) is a CCR5 cellular chemokine receptor antagonist
Enfuvirtide (HIV) inhibits gp41 mediated fusion
Monoclonal antibody palivizumab (RSV)
VZV antibody drugs
Docosano (HSV)
What drugs inhibit nucleic acid synthesis?
Nucleoside analogues such as Acyclovir - requires thymidine kinase which isn’t in uninfected cell)
Nucleotide analogues (as above but with phosphate) such as cidofovir and foscarnet (pyrophosphate, blocks binding site of viral DNA pol
Inhibition of the helicase-primase complex (in clinical trials)
Inhibition of reverse transcriptase for HIV
What drugs inhibit proteases?
Many for HIV to prevent cleavage of polyprotein
Have some for Hep C
How do integrase inhibitors work?
Inhibits strand transfer, the final step of provirus integration
What are category 2 antivirals?
Drugs that modulate the host immune response to up regulate/modify
What are some approaches that can be used to modulate the host immune response?
Reduce immunosuppression
Antiviral prophylaxis and pre-emptive therapy
Interferons to induce antiviral state
Innate immunity stimulators
What is the definition of antiviral resistance?
Lack of clinical and virologic response to treatment. Clinical response - drug sensitive virus in an immunocompromised host fails due to lack of immune response
What are the factors involved in the emergence of resistant virus strains?
Mutations in viral genomes (e.g. SNPs that give amino acid substitutions that result in resistance)
Selective pressure (the drug)
High replicative load
High intrinsic viral mutation rate
What are the consequences of antiviral resistance?
If the resistant strain is as fit as the parent get prolonged and severe disease. If not, there is less impact
How can antiviral resistance be found and how can this knowledge be used in treatment?
Phenotypic assays in cell culture - difficult to do and standardise
Specific genotypic assays - look for changes (need to know what they are and update primers/probes frequently)
For HSV and VZV, only look for resistance if treatment fails as they rarely develop it de novo - could be clinical (immune system failure) or a higher viral load than expected
Resistance is common in HIV, so test for with a baseline assay and select treatment appropriately