Trap Neuter Release and Spay Neuter Flashcards
1
Q
Cat-Human Relationship
A
- Cats have been living outdoors among humans for over 10000 years
- Cats may be the only species to domesticate themselves
- Indoor only cats are primarily a N. American phenomenon
- UK preferential outdoor
- Indoor cats are relatively recent development
- 1947- Edward Lowe invents kitty litter
2
Q
Cats in the USA
A
- 79-88 million pet cats in the US
- 80-85% are sterilized
- 10-90 million free roaming cats in the US
- Approximately the human population divided by 6
- some variation based on community
- 2% sterilized
- Approximately the human population divided by 6
3
Q
Free-Roaming Unowned Community Cats
A
- Stray Cats
- Community Cats
- Abandoned/Lost Pets
- Feral Cats
- Evasive and untamed
- Born wild
- Stray cats turned wild
- Evasive and untamed
- 1 unspayed female, her mate, and all offspring (2.8 kittens/litter) can total:
- 1 year: 12
- 5 years: 11,801
- 9 years: 11,606,077
4
Q
Cat Factory
A
- Pet Cats- 79million
- Female/OVH- 50-85%
- Litter/year: 1.4
- Live birth/year: 3
- Kittens born/year: 25million
- Kittne survival: 75%
- Live at 3 months: 18 million
- Community Cats- 79million
- Female/OVH- 50-2%
- Litter/year: 1.4
- Live birth/year: 3
- Kittens born/year: 166million
- Kittne survival: 25%
- Live at 3 months: 42 million
5
Q
Controversies and Concerns
A
- Environmental
- non-native species impact on wildlife (birds)
- Public Health
- Zoonotic disease concerns
- Cat welfare
- Management Options
- Traditional sheltering
- No-kill sheltering
- TNR
6
Q
Free-Roaming Community Cats
A
- Most important source of cat overpopulation
- single larest souce of shelter animal intake
7
Q
Community Cats - Public Opinion
A
- 2007 telephone survey
- What would you do about unowned cats on the street
- 81% leave them alone
- 14% trap and kill
8
Q
Animal Welfare Inequality - Dogs vs Cats
A
- Intake approximately equal
- Return to owner rate
- Dogs - 38%
- Cats - <2%
- Length of Stay
- Dogs - 14 days
- Cats - 28 days
- Adverse Outcome
- Cats euthanized at a rate consistently 20% or higher thadogs
9
Q
Community Cat Control - Things to Consider
A
- Free roaming community cats may not cause or have problems
- Programs or efforts that only impact a small portion of the resident population are ineffective
- Killing cats in shelters accomplishes nothing.
- not good for the cats
- not good for the shelter
- does not effect the community cat population
10
Q
Community Cat Management
A
- Scale must be significant enough to manage the given unowned cat population
- Safe for the environment
- Affordable
- Sustainable
- Socially acceptable
11
Q
Community Cat Management - Goals
A
- Improve the welfare of individuals cats and the population
- Reduce the negative impact of the cats
- Decrease the resident population
- Decrease shelter intake
- Decrease shelter euthanasia
12
Q
Community Cat Management - Options
A
- Lethal Control
- Destruction, poison, hunting trapping etc.
- Effective on isolatd populations
- Animal Control/Shelter euthanasia controls nuisances short term only
- Destruction, poison, hunting trapping etc.
- Adoption
- Ideal outcome
- Not enough homes
- Feral cats are not suitable for adoption
- Sanctuary
- Limited capacity
- Trap-Neuter-Return (TNR)
13
Q
Trap - Neuter - Return
A
- Goals
- Population reduction via non-lethal means
- Improved cat population health
- Minimized negative impacts
- Reduce complaints from the public
- Process
- Live trapping
- Spay/neuter
- Ear tipping (traditionally left)
- Rabies vaccination
- Triage/treat/euthanize the sick
- Community Education
- Colony level targeted approach
14
Q
Community Cat Management - TNR
A
- Improve the welfare of individuals cats ad the population
- Reduce the negative impact of the cats
- Decrease the resident population
- Decrease shelter intake
- Decrease shelter euthanasia
15
Q
Spay and Neuter - the Good, Bad, and Ugly
A
- Sterilization surgeries have exsisted for over 100 years
- advaned techniques and anesthetics to minimize risk
- Still only 74% of dogs and 84% of cats are altered
- Decreases for underserved areas:
- 12% altered
- 69% pets have never seen a vet
- Decreases for underserved areas:
- Factors include:
- Cost
- Time
- Feelings the procedure is unnecessary
- Too young/unsure of age
- Desire to breed
- Receive advice against the surgery
- Not usually based on fact/coming from reputable sources
16
Q
Spay and Neuter Benefits
A
- Benefits for dog neuter:
- decrease to several types of diseases (benign prostatic hyperplasia, prostatitis, prostatic cysts, etc)
- elimination of testicular tumors
- decreased risk of perneal hernia
- decreased risk of perianal adenoma
- decreased drive for male versus male aggression
- Benefits for cat neuter:
- decrease roaming and marking
- decreased inter-cat aggression (cat-bite abscesses)
- reduced urine odor
- Benefits for Dog spay:
- reduce disease (Brucellosis and Transmissible Venereal Tumor, mamary neoplasia)
- eliminate disease (pyometra, ovarian and uterine neoplasia)
- Beneits for cat spay:
- eliminate disease (pyometra, ovarian and uterine neoplasia)
- eliminates estrus behaviors
- Overall benefit: Control of unwanted pet population
17
Q
Spay and Neuter - Risks
A
- Established risks of spay/neuter:
- Decreased metabolic rate in cats
- Risk of surgery/anesthesia:
- increased risk of prostatic tumors in dogs
- delayed closure of long bone growth plates
- Potential risks are being studied:
- changes in skeletal growth (hip dysplasia, cranial cruciate ligament disease)
- neoplasia (lymphoma, hemangiosarcoma, mast cell tumor, transitional cell carcinoma, osteosarcoma)
- Other diseases (hypothyroidism, diabetes mellitus)
- These are potential risks, however people read these as absolutes
18
Q
Reading literature
A
- Reading current literature on the topic of of risks, must be done in a critical manner
- deterimine what type of study is being done
- expert opinion, case report/series, cross sectional, case control, cohort, randomized controlled trial, systemic review, meta-analysis
- Each type has its pros and cons
- Study types exist as a hierarcy (the ones at the start of the list are less prone to bias and systemic error)
- Must critique each study
- Generally 4 associations found in a study:
- True correlation
- Bias
- Confounding
- Chance
- Reader must identigy which way the association is created
19
Q
Types of Literature
A
- Weakest to Strongest
- Case reports, opinion papers, and letters
- Animal trials & in vitro studies
- Cross sectional studies
- Case-control studies
- Cohort studis
- Randomized Controlled trials
- Meta-analyses & Systematic reviews
20
Q
Study Considerations
A
- Truth
- Bias
- Error in design/implementation
- Enrolled the wrong animals
- Colleced the wrong data or error in data collection
- Error in design/implementation
- Confounding
- 2 differences in 2 groups we are comparing. The 2 groups are not excangeable because their is another pathway for possible association
- Chance
- Random samples are used to extrapolate to a larger population. The sample we use will be a little above or below what we expect for the general population, this is the chance we take
21
Q
High Quality High Volume Spay Neuter (HQHVSN)
A
- Started in the 1970s in California
- only 10% of dogs and 1% of cats were receiving sterilization surgery
- 20 million animals were being euthanized in shelters nationwide
- Government funded clinic was not popular among general practice veterinarians
- A veterinarian in CA opened a new style of clinic- functioned as a low cost spay/neuter clinic during they day and aemergency clinic in the evening
- advanced “quick spay” techniques throughout the decades
- Many are still running today
- 1990s were several HQHVSN organizations across he country
- Many still running today
- Inluding ASPCA Spay/Neuter Alliance, Operation CatNip, and SpayUSA
- Many still running today
- Despite success, the idea is not completely accepted by general practitioners
- “How to Keep a Humane Society Clinic Out of Your Community” published in June 1990 Veterinary Economics
- 2008 Nationally recognized guideline for Spay/Neuter programs
- Updated in 2016 by Veterinary Medical Care Guidelines for Spay-Neuter Programs by the Association of Shelter Veterinarians
- Today, they are a vital part of the Veterinary Profession, and make the greatest impact for reducing cat and dog overpopulation
- critical to lowring shelter intake and euthanasia numbers
- expanded to provide care in underserved populations
22
Q
HQHVSN Guidelines
A
- Having standards:
- instills confidence by the public
- promote acceptance by the veterinary profession
- provide guidance for veterinarians
- provide transparency
- opens the door for research to document impact
- Certain aspects are emphasized
- separate sterile instruments for each patient
- use of proper surgical technique
- gentle tissue handling
- surgeon expectations
- complete removal of both testies and ovary
- Despite large numbers of surgeries, mobitidy/mortality rates are at or below those in private practice
- partly due to technique
- largley comes from repetition, highly trained staff, selected anesthesia/analgesia protocols, and patient selection
23
Q
HQHVSN Surgical Techniques
A
- May differ from traditional techniques utilized in private practice
- Can be implemented in prvate practine
- Male Dogs:
- Scrotal apprach to neuters are typically performed
- Incision into he scrotum to facilitate removal of the testicles- the incision can be partially closed or left open to allow drainage post-op
- Scrotal apprach to neuters are typically performed
- Female Cats:
- use ovarian pedicle tie (“augoligation”) rather than the traditional double ligation of the ovarian pedicle
- Approaching a spay through flank incision may also be more appealing for feral/community cats and lactating queens
- Using permanent marker to identify altered animals
- Feral cats - removal of the distal most portion of the ear (often left ear tip)
- Creates a visual that the animal need not be removed for TNR
- Companion animas - often delineated with a green tatoo on the ventral abdomen
- implementation of this in private practice assures that animals won’t have to undergo unnecessay anesthetic to verify S/N status
- Feral cats - removal of the distal most portion of the ear (often left ear tip)
24
Q
ASV Standards
A
- Surgeon
- Steril hand/arm scrub
- Cap, mask, sterile gloves
- +/- gown
- Change gloves between each patient
- Use separate sterile instruments for each patient
- Proper surgical technique
- Gental tissue handling
- Meticulous homeostasis
- Aseptic technique
- Attentive suture handling and security
- Both testicles or ovaries need to be removed
- Ovario-hysterectomy vs. ovariectomy
25
High Volume and High Quality
* Speed = Safety
* Not just a podut of surgical technique
* Repitiion
* Well oiled, highly trained team
* Anesthesia/analgesic protocol
* Patient selection
* Peditrics
* TNR
* NOT cutting corners
* Morbidity/Mortality rates at or below privat practice
* Techniques valid in private practice
26
Alternative Canine Neuter Techniques
* Traditional - Pre-scrotal Incision
* clossed or open procedure
* Double ligature
* SQ and skin closure
* Alternative - Scrotal Incision
* Closed procedure
* Double or single ligature
* Single suture closing the raphe
* No sutures in the skin
27
Scrotal vs Pre-Scrotal studies
* Unpublished study at Oklahoma State University
* 84 dogs
* Randomized prospective case series
* Rechecks at 1hr, 3 days, 7 days, and 14 days
* Observations for ste-redness, swelling, hemorrage, dischage or dehiscee
* No statistical difference between the 2 groups
* Scrotal approach is their standard technique \>5 years
* Scrotal Castration vs. Pre-scrotal Castration in Dogs: Veterinary Medicine, May 2015
* 437 dogs
* Prospectie case series
* rechecs at 2, 4, 6, 24, and 72 hours
* Observations for bleeding from the site, pain, self trauma, and swelling at the site and scrotum
* Pre-scroal approach = higher incidence of self trauma, otherwise no difference in complications
* Scrotal approach = 30% faster
28
Suture-less Scrotal Castrations in Canines
* Parients typically \<5 months of age and \<25 lbs
* Single scrotal incision
* spermatic cords are pedicle/instrument tied
* closure with tissue glue or left open
* May be safer than pre-scrotal appeach in puppies
* Suture cost savings in addition to time
* Ongoing study at Oregon Stae University
* Preliminary data shows no increased risk
29
Feline Spays
* Traditional = Double ligate ovarian pedicle
* Midline incision
* Double ligate ovarian pedicle
* Alternative = Ovarian pedicle tie
* Relatively new technique
* Rarely mention in literature
* Alernative = Flank Incision
* Feral cats - TNR
* Lactating Queens