Transfer by Administration 2 Flashcards
Will Contest
It is an action to prevent probate of a tendered will or revoke a will that has been admitted to probate.
Who has standing to contest a will?
Any interested person - financial interest, heir, beneficiary of dueling wills
Do creditors of a disinherited heir have sufficient interest to contest the will?
No
Does a judgment creditor have standing to contest the will?
Yes, so long as the judgment pre-dates the death
Does the debtor of the estate have standing to contest the will?
No
Are heirs interested persons and may contest the will?
Yes
Will / Trust Contest timing
- Anytime before the hearing on the petition
- After the will is admitted - you have 120 days
- Minors or incompetent adults have until final distribution
Extraordinary Services
After a will has been admitted to probate, the PR has the duty to defend against attack and is entitled to an award of attorney fees for extraordinary services for any good faith defense, whether successful or not.
PC 21380
Transfers that are presumed to be product of fraud or undue influence
- Drafting attorney
- Person in a fiduciary relationship with transferor
- A relative to a 3rd degree, co-habitant or employee
- Care custodian
How can the presumption of transfers to undue influence be rebutted
Clear and Convincing Evidence - unless it is conclusive
Relatives by affinity
On the in-law side
1st degree relative by blood
Parent
Child
2nd degree relative by blood
Grandparent
Brother / sister
Grandchild
3rd degree relative by blood
Great Grandparent
Aunt / Uncle
Niece / Nephew
Great Grandchild
4th degree relative by blood
Great Great Grandparents
Great Aunt / Uncle
First Cousin
Grand Nephew / Nieces
Are step relationships treated the same as blood relationships?
No
Grounds for a Direct Contest
- Lack of due execution
- Lack of testamentary intent or capacity
- Undue influence, fraud
- Mistake
- Revocation
- Forgery
- Gift to disqualified person (care giver, drafting attorney)
What level is needed to make a will as opposed to a trust
- Will = Testamentary Capacity (PC 6100.5)
* Trust = Contractual Capacity (higher level)
Who has the burden of proof?
- The proponent must show, in a self proving will that it was properly signed/witnessed, etc.
- Contestants have the burden to prove - undue influence, lack of capacity, fraud, mistake, revocation
Challenge a transfer of property
A challenge that transferor transferred property was not his or her property, at the time of the transfer
PC 21312
A No Contest Clause is strictly construed
Action on Contract to Make a Will
A person may have a binding agreement to make a particular disposition of his or her property by will
- Includes a promise not to breach the contract by revoking the will
- If it is an oral contract - it requires clear and convincing evidence of oral agreement
Action Against drafting attorney
*Duty of care to client and expressly named beneficiaries
Does the attorney owe beneficiaries and heirs a duty to ascertain the client’s testamentary capacity?
No
Heyer v. Flaig (1996)
Attorney must anticipate the impact of a subsequent marriage.
Cy pres doctrine
If a gift is made by will or trust (usually for charitable or education purposes), and the named recipient of the gift does not exist or conducts the activity for which the gift is made, then the estate or trustee must make the gift to an organization which comes closes to fulfilling the purpose of the gift.